adriena

iTrader: (6)

I am currently doing a vq35 swap. I was wondering if anyone has used this clutch? How is it? Is it legit? Would anyone recommend this clutch? I don't want to go cheap but this swap has already hit the pockets deep.


http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/XTD-S...QQcmdZViewItem

maxboy325

iTrader: (35)

DONT CHEAP OUT ON SUCH AN IMPORTANT PART!, IF ITS JUNK ITS NOT SIMPLE FIX

jacobmh

The XTD looks all fake I would stick with something bettter

Aeiou

Looks like even if its an ok clutch, its meant for a vq30, not 35

Product_Of_Korea

iTrader: (8)

i used this clutch on my car. i got the 6 puck stage 3 clutch. i have had it in for probley 50,000 with absolutly no problems

huyqvu

iTrader: (10)

$140 for a "racing clutch" seems a bit cheap. save up and get something reliable that has history. i wonder whats under the xtd sticker. looks almost like a daikin pressure plate.

adriena

iTrader: (6)

I appreciate the opinions and thoughts but I was looking for more of the problems with the clutch, the good and bad, peoples actual experience of the clutch. And are you guys just saying all that because the price is cheap? Does anyone know is XTD is a reliable brand or is it just because on eBay it might be a bad buy?

wiggafly808

iTrader: (17)

I think someone had problems with one of these recently, ill see if i can find the thread..


Actually never mind.. it was a diff failure.

heres the thread anyway
http://forums.maxima.org/showthread.php?t=543862
http://forums.maxima.org/showthread....ht=ebay+clutch

And they were XTR clutches..

adriena

iTrader: (6)

those threads are for the xtr clutch kit which i know are trash. thanks though.

kzoosho

iTrader: (16)

I have a xtd clutch and has been slipping the whole time i have owned it.

95_maxima

yeah i recommed this clutch plus it cheap you need stage three for the 3.5 its 100% legit

nwell2k3

iTrader: (1)

Only buy things that are proven...

Look at Act, Exedy, Spec, Clutch Master, Clutch Net, and Center Force....

I have had Act and Exedy on my cars for over 3 years...

nwell2k3

iTrader: (1)

I have never had or heard of that clutch. But as a rule of thumb... Only but product on your car that are proven.... I can atest to Act and Exedy. You want to use what the majority of the people use....

My exedy on my N2O Max has seen several races, spining tires from being stuck in the snow, burnouts, mom, and I teach people to drive stick on that car.

My turbo Max same thing. And both are going strong 3 years and counting.... Spend the extra cash and have a piece of mind...

Ohh... I forgot to tell you that I got the Exedy clutch used from me friend who beat the $hit out of it before he totaled his car... And I broke a transmission doing burn outs. I got a used tranny and put the exedy on it...

JonBlz

iTrader: (11)

hey buddy heres a link i bought my Stage 3 Spec gotta say this clutch has taken alot of abuse nd still grabs really hard like if it were brand new:
http://forums.nycmaximas.org/showthr...ghlight=clutch

S1cTech

I dunno. Paying $139 for a racing clutch stage 2 seems kinda sketch considering most really good stage 2 clutches start @ $400... So its ur call... Its a pretty important part and I wouldnt pass up on this one... U can always for for a Gen 5 clutch to make it much easier and cheaper plus with ur VQ35 engine swap it will accommodate it just right. And I think they run like in the low $200s... I am probably gonna put a Gen 5 in... The only diff between the 5 and 4 is I from what I heard is the Gen 5 has more clamping force and supports more TQ on the pressure plate.

adriena

iTrader: (6)

Okay guys thanks for the input if i don't go with the 5th gen i will just wait and get a reliable clutch.

Dbird

i just got an xtd stage 3 clutch and am gonna have it installed tomorrows so ill update you on the performance after the installation.

96nismoSE

iTrader: (2)

I dont think they're going to car all that much threads a year old!!!

petro2342

Well for anyone who does get a XTD clutch off ebay just remember its going to be a hit or miss!! Either it's going to last you 2 - 7 months or 60k miles. I didn't take that chance when I finally gave in and bought a Exedy OEM for $140 shipped (Had a shop change my clutch as it was cold out and didn't have the time so I didn't want to risk a fk up). Just be warned!

Also the pressure plate is made by Exedy iirc.

Dbird

Well i just got the clutch installed. it grabs like hell, doesn't slip at all. the pressure plate is actually the same regular one, just painted red and feels the same but so long as the clutch grabs fine and $160.00 price, cant beat that and am OK with it.

Grand_hustle17

iTrader: (22)

bringing up a fairly old thead "because search".... but im looking into getting the stg 1 XTD clutch, the only bad review ive seen so far is "maybe, probebly, looks like kinds of review... anybody tried the STG1's??? ill be buying this for when my OEM does go out, just wanna know or hear whats the reviews from ppl who actually owns the clutch...

5th gen dd

For everyday stock use it should be ok. It's a cheaper product so material quality will be lower. This can lead to premature failure but that can also depend on you're luck in getting a quality unit.

I have their 6 puck unsprung clutch in my MR2 because it came with my engine swap and decided to use it despite some of the negative reviews. After just a few consecutive passes at a strip I can feel it starting to slip from the heat. Compared to an ACT unsprung, pedal feel offers almost no feedback at all. It's stiff but you don't have that feeling of initial bite like you do with a quality unit. It's just kind of mushy and just gradually builds tension. However, it has held up pretty well. I've used it with little remorse for the past year and a half, roughly 9k miles and plenty of passes at the strip.

Considering it's different cars and different styles of clutches. (stg 1 sprung vs. stg 3 unsprung) This can't be considered much of a review on the specific clutch you're interested in, but I do know the general consensus about all their products is increased chatter and poor pedal feedback.

Centerforce makes a nice "middle of the road" option. I was real happy with the MR2 version in my original NA drivetrain prior to my swap. It still had a little bit a chatter but feedback compared to the stock clutch was amazing. Not real heavy, just enough to have a little bit of added spring to it. You really felt the transition point. I put 15k miles on it, including delivering chinese food, before pulling the drivetrain and it still looked brand new. It ended up being sold it with the tranny and the current owner is still using it everyday.

If we're talking 5th gen...
http://thmotorsports.com/i-305121.as...ingSeanVehSpec

Grand_hustle17

iTrader: (22)

not bad... this would be 95% DD use... maybe 1 or 2 track events over the span of a yr or 2... the OEM feels fine now, im not too much a fan of it like i was with the OE exedy in my 5.5, maybe i need to adjust the clutch pedal.. i see a lot of ppl went with the stage3, im taking it you guys were boosted??? i know a fellow 290's whp local is using OE clutch n working fine...maybe ill go with the OE exedy but i sure would love to save that $40 as i am unemployed and this is going in a lightly bolted 3.0 5th gen