Recarta

Im having the inttermitant misfire during idle while in gear. It is a 1996 SE with only one coil ever replaced (I snapped the SOB in half replacing a plug). Some one suggested replacing all the coils. During my search for coils (around town and on the web) I came across two names - BECK ARNLEY and STANDARD MOTOR PRODUCTS. I also found on JC Whitney coil packs for 20$ - 40$ by Replacement.

I would like to know if you get what you pay for when it comes to ignition coils.

I would like to replace all 6 for the price of the Replacements but not if they are ****.

So,
1) Is Replacement a good buy?
2) Should I just replace the bad ones with the Beck or Standard?
3) Any other suggestions will not be ignored.

http://www.jcwhitney.com/replacement...d=d1681y1996j1

http://www.jcwhitney.com/beck-arnley...d=d1681y1996j1

http://www.jcwhitney.com/ignition-co...d=d1681y1996j1

cashoit

OEM coils FTW. hit the Junkyard or ebay.

chinese or autozone coils are hit/miss.

Beck Arnley is reputable but idk about their coils. SEARCH the org for reviews

Shift_A32B

iTrader: (14)

I would replace the spark plugs first if you haven't done so.
I would go with OEM coils..you got Hanshin or Mitsubishi coils as options..

ShocknAwe

iTrader: (3)

If you want to do it on the cheap then your best bet is to get as many coils as you can from the junkyard because those might fail soon after install. Coils are one of the first items to go from a new car on the yard though so when you do find them, take them all. Coils from a yard should only be about $15/ea. Don't get the auto parts store coils because you might have to keep replacing them if they don't work and they usually always fail right after the warranty period is over. You don't have to buy them from the dealership but DO get OEM

dgoodhue

iTrader: (1)

Are you getting engine codes from the coils? I wouldn't replace the coils unless it's giving a code. I replace one of my coil with an aftermarket coil and it gave me check engine light, it worked fine otherwise.

tigersharkdude

iTrader: (20)

It gave you a code because you didnt use an OEM coil, and most likely that code was P1320

dgoodhue

iTrader: (1)

Yes it gave me code 1320. I replaced the aftermarket coil with an oem coil. Lesson learned I wasted my money on aftermarket coil.

SandyMax96

iTrader: (12)

If you want a cheap, yet temporary solution, use NGK Coppers rather than the platinums. They'll last less, but.... You won't have that huge misfire. At least, not continuously. I'll vouch that it's not the best way to go, but when you're on the budget and waiting to buy actual Hanshin OEM coils (don't do Mitsubishi, they've got a funky design) , then it's worth it in the end. The sparks will give you better conductivity, and won't have a stupid large explosion that could further damage your seals/valves/etc on your engine, as I'm suspecting it's doing with your misfire.


Just a thought, even if it's my own crazy philosophy. Believe me, I had that stupid misfire for well over a year. It was not fun

Recarta

I went ahead and purchased the Beck Arnley. Didn't help the miss. I have isolated it to the middle rear cylinder. Could it be the injector? Plugs are brand new. Have ran seafoam through a couple times. Any suggestions?

carsnwomen91

yup, i learned my lesson too. bought OE maf off ebay. works ok with fully stock setup, it doesn't like a cone filter and it really doesn't like a vafc2 lol swapped it with junkyard OEM maf

holymoly

$15? I checked a number of junk yards, and most don't have, yes they are first to go, but the cheapest price was $40; one even demanded $75?

someone linked an ebay site for OEM, the price was $35 and $18 shipping, but can't seem to locate again.

CMax03

iTrader: (3)

Swap the #3 cylinder coilpack and sparkplug with the #1 and see if the problem transfers to the #1 cyl....If it does narrow it down to either the plug or the coilpack.....If the problem doesn't transfer it is more than likely an air intake leak at the #3 cyl either the intake manifold gasket or the injector seal on the intake manifold....GL

jsleezayy

All I can say is dont buy AutoLite plugs. That in itself can cause problems.

I just bought a 99 SE and I was having a misfire on the 4th cylinder. I replaced all the plugs to NGK Plats., and then got an OEM coil pack from the parts house and now I have no misfire, and the motor is running smooth.

jsleezayy

That is cylinder #3, just for your reference. The rear plugs are 1, 3, and 5, while the front plugs are 2, 4, and 6. They set it up interesting...haha. Hope you get it fixed soon!

Recarta

Just a forgotten update.......

The coil pack that was missing after replacing was defective. I had to swap it for a brand new one. Everything works perfect now. I couldn't be happier. Now I'm having oil, transmission, and steering fluid leaks, but that is for another thread.

ShocknAwe

iTrader: (3)

Yea I would never pay more than $20/pc for coils from a yard god lord

eddie982

iTrader: (10)

RockAuto lists Beck Arnley coils as Hanshin.

They're $21.59 and $50.99, right and left as listed on their website.
I'm wondering if BeckArnley has sourced Hanshin coils and they're
selling them after rebranding them??