djfrestyl's DEFINITIVE "I HAVE A SUSPENSION QUESTION" THREAD!!!
#1401
Suspension Yoda
Thread Starter
iTrader: (89)
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Central, NJ
Posts: 13,501
BC's, Megans, and others are nice because they come fully assembled.
Tein's do not, and require OEM parts to be reused or sourced. Because of this, you don't have camber adjustment.
Both BC's and Teins are good products, with Tein being better in performance. The offset against the performance is sorting out the parts.
Tein's do not, and require OEM parts to be reused or sourced. Because of this, you don't have camber adjustment.
Both BC's and Teins are good products, with Tein being better in performance. The offset against the performance is sorting out the parts.
#1402
Since the Tein do not have a pre load on them, is that something to be concerned about?
If I drop it 2 inch with the Tein, would there be enough factory adjustment to make the camber some what decent?
If I drop it 2 inch with the Tein, would there be enough factory adjustment to make the camber some what decent?
#1404
Is it just the axles that is the big issue with a 2inch drop?
Alot of people use springs that average 1.75 inches. Is there that big of a different in a quarter inch?
My goal is to almost completely eliminate wheel gap
Alot of people use springs that average 1.75 inches. Is there that big of a different in a quarter inch?
My goal is to almost completely eliminate wheel gap
#1405
Suspension Yoda
Thread Starter
iTrader: (89)
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Central, NJ
Posts: 13,501
Axles, control arm bushings, ball joints, tie rod ends...
No, I would say the average lowering spring is closer to 1.4-1.5. Progress at 1.6 are excellent springs. Anything more takes a steep downward curve.
Yes, a tenth or a quarter inch makes a difference. Chances are, you won't go lower than 1.8.
No, I would say the average lowering spring is closer to 1.4-1.5. Progress at 1.6 are excellent springs. Anything more takes a steep downward curve.
Yes, a tenth or a quarter inch makes a difference. Chances are, you won't go lower than 1.8.
#1407
Hello djfrestyl,
It's been awhile since you worked on my car, possible 4-5 years ago, but now I have a new issue. So my rear Eibach springs snapped, and out of necessity, I had to get the stock springs reinstalled all around, and I still have the KYB-GR2 installed. Now, when I turn the car, I hear some kind of clunking noise, but it sounds like if something was over tightened, if that makes any sense. And I noticed when I open my driver side door, it drops a little, as if it was mis-aligned.
What is your diagnosis? Thanks!
It's been awhile since you worked on my car, possible 4-5 years ago, but now I have a new issue. So my rear Eibach springs snapped, and out of necessity, I had to get the stock springs reinstalled all around, and I still have the KYB-GR2 installed. Now, when I turn the car, I hear some kind of clunking noise, but it sounds like if something was over tightened, if that makes any sense. And I noticed when I open my driver side door, it drops a little, as if it was mis-aligned.
What is your diagnosis? Thanks!
#1409
Should I go back to the same guy, or go to the shop where I will get a wheel alignment? If the original guy did not install it properly, most likely he wouldn't know what would be wrong.
#1411
It was on a Saturday afternoon when I started replacing the Q45's struts. The original insulators crumbled when I tried to remove then. So it was like "what can I get on a Saturday afternoon to finish this job?" So I went to Ace Hardware and found this braided tubing. IIRC it stands up to high temp water and pressure. This is some tough stuff.
Since the fit is so tight, I had to put some silicone grease on the spring and in the inside of the tubing and then heat it up with a heat gun to slide it on. I'll be the first to tell you that putting it on is NOT easy. Definitely not easy like the snap on insulators. Over time, it appears the tubing shrinks and gets all the more tighter with the spring. If I ever decide to remove it, it will be a job. I may need to use a small torch to get it off.
Many times I try new things and will not post about it for 3 to 5 years until after I know it will work. It has been 6 years for this mod and the tubing looks like it will last another 10 years. I think it will out last the now 25 year old car.
I've used this on other suspension jobs over the years.
Here's how it looks after 5+ years on a 4th gen where I installed it in 2011.
For the next up and coming suspension job, I purchased some Tein insulators. They are definitely easy to install. I don't see them lasting as long as the braided tubing. So maybe I will use regular insulators for cars where I'm looking to setup the springs for a 5 year run. Then use the braided tubing on jobs where I plan to keep the car and springs for over 10 years.
Last edited by CS_AR; 01-22-2017 at 10:16 AM.
#1413
Bad Luck with Febest boots
Last July I rebuilt my entire front suspension and also replaced the rear struts.
I used Febest boots for both the front and the rear struts because they looked like the best alternative to OEM boots.
This is what they look like 9 months later:
Drivers side rear
Passenger side rear
Drivers side front
Passenger side front
cracking all over
I am in Southern California and I have only put 5000 miles on the car since the job was done so it isn't an issue of harsh climate or excessive use. This obviously didn't just happen so it is more realistic to say they only lasted about 6 months.
It wouldn't be such a big deal if these weren't so difficult to replace. In order to replace the front boots, you have to get re-aligned.
The company offered to replace the boots but wouldn't comment at all the short lifespan of these boots. They wouldn't say if this was abnormal or anything. They offered no assurance that another set would last any longer. I think the fact that all 4 boots deteriorated indicates that this is not a fluke.
At this point, I wouldn't dare put another set of these on the car. I would suggest going with OEM boots if you can find a deal on them. The rear boots cost about 2x as much as the front.
Can anyone else who has used these boots comment on their experience?
I used Febest boots for both the front and the rear struts because they looked like the best alternative to OEM boots.
This is what they look like 9 months later:
Drivers side rear
Passenger side rear
Drivers side front
Passenger side front
cracking all over
I am in Southern California and I have only put 5000 miles on the car since the job was done so it isn't an issue of harsh climate or excessive use. This obviously didn't just happen so it is more realistic to say they only lasted about 6 months.
It wouldn't be such a big deal if these weren't so difficult to replace. In order to replace the front boots, you have to get re-aligned.
The company offered to replace the boots but wouldn't comment at all the short lifespan of these boots. They wouldn't say if this was abnormal or anything. They offered no assurance that another set would last any longer. I think the fact that all 4 boots deteriorated indicates that this is not a fluke.
At this point, I wouldn't dare put another set of these on the car. I would suggest going with OEM boots if you can find a deal on them. The rear boots cost about 2x as much as the front.
Can anyone else who has used these boots comment on their experience?
Last edited by SquidBeak; 04-03-2017 at 11:10 PM.
#1414
Suspension Yoda
Thread Starter
iTrader: (89)
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Central, NJ
Posts: 13,501
Good info, thanks for sharing.
Interestingly when I compared OEM to Febest I felt Febest's rubber was softer / more pliable. And therefore it would be more durable and less prone to drying out.
Clearly we now realize softer = more susceptible to the elements!
Interestingly when I compared OEM to Febest I felt Febest's rubber was softer / more pliable. And therefore it would be more durable and less prone to drying out.
Clearly we now realize softer = more susceptible to the elements!
#1415
Dj,
Thanks for chiming in. I thought the exact same thing. I was very impressed with the boots when I first received them. But now I'm wondering how could something that comes in such a nice box be such crap?
Do you have febest boots on your car? If so, how are they holding up?
One last thing, could you refresh my memory on why you avoided KYB and Moog boots? I really don't want to spend $100+ on a set of OEM boots and those are looking like the only alternatives.
Thanks again
Thanks for chiming in. I thought the exact same thing. I was very impressed with the boots when I first received them. But now I'm wondering how could something that comes in such a nice box be such crap?
Do you have febest boots on your car? If so, how are they holding up?
One last thing, could you refresh my memory on why you avoided KYB and Moog boots? I really don't want to spend $100+ on a set of OEM boots and those are looking like the only alternatives.
Thanks again
Last edited by SquidBeak; 04-04-2017 at 02:01 PM.
#1416
Suspension Yoda
Thread Starter
iTrader: (89)
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Central, NJ
Posts: 13,501
I don't even own a Maxima anymore
Fitment was the issue with KYB & Moog. Just not as well as OEM. Also KYB often required the center to be bored out to fit the strut piston. And Moog occasionally were noisy because they didn't sit well.
Fitment was the issue with KYB & Moog. Just not as well as OEM. Also KYB often required the center to be bored out to fit the strut piston. And Moog occasionally were noisy because they didn't sit well.
#1419
Has anyone put 4th gen Koni SRT.T's on their 5th gen? Is it the same as with 4th gen AGX's. That is, you need 4th gen front and rear mounts. Can 5th gen springs be reused, what about 5th gen front spring seats? I'd do Koni inserts but the fronts don't seem that secure with two tabs on the top and a bolt on the bottom holding them tight. Any thoughts?
#1421
Yeah. I meant can the springs be used with 4th gen struts. I've read at least once someone had a problem with the 5th gen springs seating properly in a 4th gen strut. It was with the Cattman modified KYB AGX's. I read the 4th gen mounts kind of suck so 5th gens have to be modified, plus the bottom mounts have to be stretched or compressed not sure. There isn't much detail, I guess it's proprietary to Cattman.
#1422
I'd still like to know the answers but I pulled the trigger on some KYB Excel-G's. I got them dirt cheap on RockAuto. With the $40 mail in rebate and 5% off it was like $240 for all of them. I'm just worried about the supposed harshness...there are mixed reviews. I might regret not getting the Koni's but the KYB's were half the price.
#1424
Last July I rebuilt my entire front suspension and also replaced the rear struts.
I used Febest boots for both the front and the rear struts because they looked like the best alternative to OEM boots.
This is what they look like 9 months later:
I am in Southern California and I have only put 5000 miles on the car since the job was done so it isn't an issue of harsh climate or excessive use. This obviously didn't just happen so it is more realistic to say they only lasted about 6 months.
It wouldn't be such a big deal if these weren't so difficult to replace. In order to replace the front boots, you have to get re-aligned.
The company offered to replace the boots but wouldn't comment at all the short lifespan of these boots. They wouldn't say if this was abnormal or anything. They offered no assurance that another set would last any longer. I think the fact that all 4 boots deteriorated indicates that this is not a fluke.
At this point, I wouldn't dare put another set of these on the car. I would suggest going with OEM boots if you can find a deal on them. The rear boots cost about 2x as much as the front.
Can anyone else who has used these boots comment on their experience?
I used Febest boots for both the front and the rear struts because they looked like the best alternative to OEM boots.
This is what they look like 9 months later:
I am in Southern California and I have only put 5000 miles on the car since the job was done so it isn't an issue of harsh climate or excessive use. This obviously didn't just happen so it is more realistic to say they only lasted about 6 months.
It wouldn't be such a big deal if these weren't so difficult to replace. In order to replace the front boots, you have to get re-aligned.
The company offered to replace the boots but wouldn't comment at all the short lifespan of these boots. They wouldn't say if this was abnormal or anything. They offered no assurance that another set would last any longer. I think the fact that all 4 boots deteriorated indicates that this is not a fluke.
At this point, I wouldn't dare put another set of these on the car. I would suggest going with OEM boots if you can find a deal on them. The rear boots cost about 2x as much as the front.
Can anyone else who has used these boots comment on their experience?
I recently purchased some Febest boots to replace the short lived OEMs hoping to find something better. I like the look but if they won't last, I guess I should get more OEMs.
#1425
Plan on tackling rear strut replacement with eibach springs. Can someone confirm if I will need to use any of the old parts or will I be able get away with new strut mount kit/dust cover. I learned the hard way and had to use the old top hat for the front strut springs. .
#1426
Plan on tackling rear strut replacement with eibach springs. Can someone confirm if I will need to use any of the old parts or will I be able get away with new strut mount kit/dust cover. I learned the hard way and had to use the old top hat for the front strut springs. .
#1427
This is true. I just did mine and I did them without removing the top mounts; jack up car at jack point, not axle, remove wheel, unbolt the bottom of the shock first then undo the strut nut holding the spring. Yes, there is a bit of tension left on the stock springs, but very little. DON'T try this on the front EVER. If you have a helper to step on the axle to push it down while reinstalling the shock/spring it is super easy and only takes half an hour per side, most of which is spent in the trunk ratcheting the nut 15 degrees at a time.
#1428
Thanks for the info. I have New rear strut mount, new boot, new rear struts and new lowering springs. Will I need to re use any of the old parts? Trying to find out if I can just assemble new rear components as a whole new assembly and swap out old strut assembly?
Last edited by Maximer02; 08-08-2017 at 04:10 PM.
#1429
You will also need the lower isolators for the springs if you don't have new ones.
#1432
#1434
Is it necessary to grease front strut mounts/bearings? Thought I read somewhere some do as a precaution. BTW, energy suspension polyurethane sway bar bushings made a huge difference along with new moog end links. Solved suspension noise/clunking that I had after the new struts went in. Wow, a must if you still have original! Moog end links have the greasable fittings too, uses 15mm and 18mm to install end links...different bolt size from oem but works just as well if not better!
#1435
Hey DJ,
I know you're not in the max game, anymore, but wanted to offer a thank you for all the great info you've provided over the years. I'm in the middle of a complete suspension re-fresh on my 5.5gen and I've read this entire thread and used it for so much information. Thank you!
I have one question that I didn't really see addressed regarding Inner Tie Rods.....
As I mentioned, I'm re-doing all of the suspension components because they are all almost 15 years old (and many not working anymore). However the ITRs appear to be working just fine. The boots are fine, and they rotate fine. The "arms" are just rusty. Is there any reason why I'd need to replace them?
I mean, with other components, you know that if they're 15 yrs old, they are going to die soon. Is that the case with ITRs? Or can these last a long time?
I know you're not in the max game, anymore, but wanted to offer a thank you for all the great info you've provided over the years. I'm in the middle of a complete suspension re-fresh on my 5.5gen and I've read this entire thread and used it for so much information. Thank you!
I have one question that I didn't really see addressed regarding Inner Tie Rods.....
As I mentioned, I'm re-doing all of the suspension components because they are all almost 15 years old (and many not working anymore). However the ITRs appear to be working just fine. The boots are fine, and they rotate fine. The "arms" are just rusty. Is there any reason why I'd need to replace them?
I mean, with other components, you know that if they're 15 yrs old, they are going to die soon. Is that the case with ITRs? Or can these last a long time?
#1436
I'm re-doing all of the suspension components because they are all almost 15 years old (and many not working anymore). However the ITRs appear to be working just fine. The boots are fine, and they rotate fine. The "arms" are just rusty. Is there any reason why I'd need to replace them?
I mean, with other components, you know that if they're 15 yrs old, they are going to die soon. Is that the case with ITRs? Or can these last a long time?
I mean, with other components, you know that if they're 15 yrs old, they are going to die soon. Is that the case with ITRs? Or can these last a long time?
#1437
Depends..I replaced the inner tie rods on the 2000 a couple months ago for the first time (somewhere around 510,000kms) and one side was in not great condition, very loose and what not, while the other side was in surprisingly good condition with little play. I replaced both with the moog problem solvers. They are not too expensive or hard to replace, here is the one I chose http://www.rockauto.com/en/moreinfo....359222&jsn=428
#1439
Sorry if this is a dumb question but I have been searching for an hour and am unable to find an answer. My back end has been jumpy when I hit bumps and Ive read its the suspension. I just want to replace it and I'm wondering what I should get(inexpensive)?
#1440
If by jumpy you mean it bounces it's likely your struts are going bad. Springs will soften but don't really go bad in my experience. You could either get new struts, or buy an all-in-one set that's both springs & struts.