Why does the tire chirp when shifting from first to second?
Why does the tire chirp when shifting from first to second?
I know it is a mismatch of speed or engine rpm, but can someone explain it more in detail what exactly causes the tire to chirp, and how to avoid it but still shift more smoothly and fast?
Re: Why does the tire chirp when shifting from first to second?
Originally posted by PimpShiFus
I know it is a mismatch of speed or engine rpm, but can someone explain it more in detail what exactly causes the tire to chirp, and how to avoid it but still shift more smoothly and fast?
I know it is a mismatch of speed or engine rpm, but can someone explain it more in detail what exactly causes the tire to chirp, and how to avoid it but still shift more smoothly and fast?
its the tires losing traction because of the sudden acceleration. just like when you floor it from a stop, but a little less severe.
When your tires chirp its really not a bad thing, especially when you're racing. I guess ideally you dont want your tires to spin, but you're back into gear and going quick enough that you arent really going to hurt your run. Upgraded high grip tires may help with some of the chirp.
Play nice people. We all started somewhere right?
But Pimpshifus, it's due to the sudden torque when u shift. During shift (manual cars) the clutch disengages and the tranny is free for a moment, then u put in 2nd and drop the clutch. When u drop the cluth, the engine is spinning faster than the clutch so when the clutch grabs, it instantly spins up the tranny to the engine speed and therefore causing the chirp.... Basically the tires get a sudden burst of speed..............
I think my IQ just went down. This is a pretty stupid question bro. Figure it out man.
Hope the above get u started.
But Pimpshifus, it's due to the sudden torque when u shift. During shift (manual cars) the clutch disengages and the tranny is free for a moment, then u put in 2nd and drop the clutch. When u drop the cluth, the engine is spinning faster than the clutch so when the clutch grabs, it instantly spins up the tranny to the engine speed and therefore causing the chirp.... Basically the tires get a sudden burst of speed..............
I think my IQ just went down. This is a pretty stupid question bro. Figure it out man.
Hope the above get u started.
I really want to say something to those who posted offensive posts, but I wont cuz I have better things to do then take the time to post something just to call someone else a dumbass. I mean how much free time and how big of a loser is that??
anyways, I did some tests. I can eliminate the chirp when i shift into second gear if i get the engine rpm to 4000 to 5000rpms when i let go of the clutch. The chirp not only produces a chirping sound, but it also slows me down, like half to one second of rough acceleration......like wheel hops or something like that...... but it is hard to get the engine speed to exactly where i want it......
how do u guys shift? do u give gas before u let go of the clutch to get the engine running at the speed it would be running after u let go the clutch? or do u guys just release the clutch and then give gas.
anyways, I did some tests. I can eliminate the chirp when i shift into second gear if i get the engine rpm to 4000 to 5000rpms when i let go of the clutch. The chirp not only produces a chirping sound, but it also slows me down, like half to one second of rough acceleration......like wheel hops or something like that...... but it is hard to get the engine speed to exactly where i want it......
how do u guys shift? do u give gas before u let go of the clutch to get the engine running at the speed it would be running after u let go the clutch? or do u guys just release the clutch and then give gas.
Originally posted by PimpShiFus
I really want to say something to those who posted offensive posts, but I wont cuz I have better things to do then take the time to post something just to call someone else a dumbass. I mean how much free time and how big of a loser is that??
anyways, I did some tests. I can eliminate the chirp when i shift into second gear if i get the engine rpm to 4000 to 5000rpms when i let go of the clutch. The chirp not only produces a chirping sound, but it also slows me down, like half to one second of rough acceleration......like wheel hops or something like that...... but it is hard to get the engine speed to exactly where i want it......
how do u guys shift? do u give gas before u let go of the clutch to get the engine running at the speed it would be running after u let go the clutch? or do u guys just release the clutch and then give gas.
I really want to say something to those who posted offensive posts, but I wont cuz I have better things to do then take the time to post something just to call someone else a dumbass. I mean how much free time and how big of a loser is that??
anyways, I did some tests. I can eliminate the chirp when i shift into second gear if i get the engine rpm to 4000 to 5000rpms when i let go of the clutch. The chirp not only produces a chirping sound, but it also slows me down, like half to one second of rough acceleration......like wheel hops or something like that...... but it is hard to get the engine speed to exactly where i want it......
how do u guys shift? do u give gas before u let go of the clutch to get the engine running at the speed it would be running after u let go the clutch? or do u guys just release the clutch and then give gas.
chirping the tries will not slow you down. while you dont want to the tires to lose traction, the fact that your tires chirped means that you are putting down the maximum amount of power to the ground. if you baby it and dont chirp the tires you are probably wasting precious potential power.
also, about what you are asking...are you talking about regular everyday shifting? or are you talking about race/power shifting? you should not be chirping the tires if you're just driving normally.
Originally posted by Newman
when you say "half a second" im sure in reality it is more like a tenth of a second (if that).
when you say "half a second" im sure in reality it is more like a tenth of a second (if that).
Originally posted by PimpShiFus
Actually, it is pretty close to half a second. The car was not smooth at all, like I can hear my dash area shakes. heck, i think it was just bad shifting on my part. the faster i shift, the more the dash shakes, and the longer the tires can't grip right. This is redline shifting btw, not normal driving. maybe it's our transmission or whatever, it is just not designed to handle that kind of rough shifting??
Actually, it is pretty close to half a second. The car was not smooth at all, like I can hear my dash area shakes. heck, i think it was just bad shifting on my part. the faster i shift, the more the dash shakes, and the longer the tires can't grip right. This is redline shifting btw, not normal driving. maybe it's our transmission or whatever, it is just not designed to handle that kind of rough shifting??
EDIT: when i say chirping is not bad, i mean it like bumping your head on the wall isnt bad. it is harmless just as long as you dont go overboard and do it a lot. the fact that you are chirping your tires means you are pushing your engine and transmission hard so it isnt a good thing. but its not something you should be worried about unless you do it alllllllll the time.
and do not hit the gas to get the rpm up before letting go of the clutch. Shift as fast as you can and get the clutch out as fast as you can, then get back on the gas as fast as you can, but you really shouldn't be touching the gas when the clutch is in unless you're in the mood for a new clutch/tranny.
Don't forget, even though it's fun to drive, it's not a race car. our transmissions are good for what they're designed to do. Shift it like you would a race car and in a month or two you'll be posting "why does our tranny suck so bad" and THEN you'll really get flamed.
Don't forget, even though it's fun to drive, it's not a race car. our transmissions are good for what they're designed to do. Shift it like you would a race car and in a month or two you'll be posting "why does our tranny suck so bad" and THEN you'll really get flamed.
Yeah bro, listen to 2k2wannabe and Newman, they're on the money!
Chirping tires will NOT slow you down by 0.5 second, and will probably not slow you down at all compared to taking it easier and not chirping. When you're racing, you want to shift the tranny as fast as possible and get back on the gas as fast as possible. As a result, if you do this fast enough and you're in the lower gears (1-3) you should experience chirping. Heck, I've chirped 1-2 and 2-3 (barely though) with 2 of my friends in the car.
Also, when you're shifting, foot off the gas, jab the clutch while moving the shifter into the next gate, clutch comes all the way out, and back on the gas. Sounds like a long procedure, but this is done in a fraction of a second once you practice it a little. Make sure you don't rev the engine while clutch is disengaged or slipping (this is known as powershifting) or else you'll be burning up your clutch extremely fast.
Chirping tires will NOT slow you down by 0.5 second, and will probably not slow you down at all compared to taking it easier and not chirping. When you're racing, you want to shift the tranny as fast as possible and get back on the gas as fast as possible. As a result, if you do this fast enough and you're in the lower gears (1-3) you should experience chirping. Heck, I've chirped 1-2 and 2-3 (barely though) with 2 of my friends in the car.
Also, when you're shifting, foot off the gas, jab the clutch while moving the shifter into the next gate, clutch comes all the way out, and back on the gas. Sounds like a long procedure, but this is done in a fraction of a second once you practice it a little. Make sure you don't rev the engine while clutch is disengaged or slipping (this is known as powershifting) or else you'll be burning up your clutch extremely fast.
Thanks for the input guys! I didn't know it is bad for the transmission if I get the engine speed up (or to match the rpm of the next gear) before letting go of the clutch.... at least I couldn't hear any bad noises or feel any bad things happening when i do that..... But thanks for the tip.. i'll watch myself.
Originally posted by PimpShiFus
Thanks for the input guys! I didn't know it is bad for the transmission if I get the engine speed up (or to match the rpm of the next gear) before letting go of the clutch.... at least I couldn't hear any bad noises or feel any bad things happening when i do that..... But thanks for the tip.. i'll watch myself.
Thanks for the input guys! I didn't know it is bad for the transmission if I get the engine speed up (or to match the rpm of the next gear) before letting go of the clutch.... at least I couldn't hear any bad noises or feel any bad things happening when i do that..... But thanks for the tip.. i'll watch myself.
Originally posted by PimpShiFus
Thanks for the input guys! I didn't know it is bad for the transmission if I get the engine speed up (or to match the rpm of the next gear) before letting go of the clutch.... at least I couldn't hear any bad noises or feel any bad things happening when i do that..... But thanks for the tip.. i'll watch myself.
Thanks for the input guys! I didn't know it is bad for the transmission if I get the engine speed up (or to match the rpm of the next gear) before letting go of the clutch.... at least I couldn't hear any bad noises or feel any bad things happening when i do that..... But thanks for the tip.. i'll watch myself.
The only time you need to rev your engine to "match the rpm of the next gear" would be when you are downshifting, not upshifting. Watch your tachometer.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Unclejunebug
5th Generation Maxima (2000-2003)
10
Apr 2, 2016 05:42 AM
hayne
6th Generation Maxima (2004-2008)
2
Oct 5, 2015 11:53 AM




