Would you buy a remanufactured 5-speed tranny from here?
#1
Would you buy a remanufactured 5-speed tranny from here?
http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/ws/eB...&category=6780
Anyone experienced with this or other resellers of rebuilt transmissions, please offer any insights.
My bearings seem to be on their deathbed in my 5-speed gearbox, (like in so many other's manual trannies, apparently)
(See: http://forums.maxima.org/showthread....ssion+clicking)
I guess my options are:
A) Rebuild my existing tranny (taking a chance on a local shop)
B) Buy a complete remanufactured tranny w/ new clutch (like in the link above).
C) Buy a used tranny (unable to verify condition 'till it's in)
D) Buy a VLSD tranny, used (if I can locate one, again - unverifiable condition)
E) Buy a new tranny ($$$$$)
I like the idea of getting a quality (hopefully) remanufactured unit with a new replacement clutch included; from a remanufacturer with experience and high standards rather than "hoping" a local shop "gets it right" on a rebuild of my current tranny. I've heard a few horror stories on rebuilt trannies going bad way too soon.
But who knows - I'm also a bit biased considering all the sub-standard work my car was subjected to by "professionals" before I went the D.I.Y. route. This is just a job I don't have the time for 2do myself.
I am tempted to try to track down a VLSD, used, or new, if the price is right - anyone with leads/hints on this option, please post.
Any advice, insights, will be greatly appreciated.
Cheers,
-Keith-
Anyone experienced with this or other resellers of rebuilt transmissions, please offer any insights.
My bearings seem to be on their deathbed in my 5-speed gearbox, (like in so many other's manual trannies, apparently)
(See: http://forums.maxima.org/showthread....ssion+clicking)
I guess my options are:
A) Rebuild my existing tranny (taking a chance on a local shop)
B) Buy a complete remanufactured tranny w/ new clutch (like in the link above).
C) Buy a used tranny (unable to verify condition 'till it's in)
D) Buy a VLSD tranny, used (if I can locate one, again - unverifiable condition)
E) Buy a new tranny ($$$$$)
I like the idea of getting a quality (hopefully) remanufactured unit with a new replacement clutch included; from a remanufacturer with experience and high standards rather than "hoping" a local shop "gets it right" on a rebuild of my current tranny. I've heard a few horror stories on rebuilt trannies going bad way too soon.
But who knows - I'm also a bit biased considering all the sub-standard work my car was subjected to by "professionals" before I went the D.I.Y. route. This is just a job I don't have the time for 2do myself.
I am tempted to try to track down a VLSD, used, or new, if the price is right - anyone with leads/hints on this option, please post.
Any advice, insights, will be greatly appreciated.
Cheers,
-Keith-
#2
Re: Would you buy a remanufactured 5-speed tranny from here?
Originally posted by KWheelzSB
http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/ws/eB...&category=6780
Anyone experienced with this or other resellers of rebuilt transmissions, please offer any insights.
My bearings are starting to go bad on my 5-speed, (like so many others here, apparently)
See: http://forums.maxima.org/showthread....ssion+clicking
My options are:
A) Rebuild my existing tranny
B) Buy a complete rebuild w/ clutch (like in the link above).
C) Buy a used tranny in unverifiable condition
D) Buy a new tranny
E) Buy a VLSD tranny, used
Anyway, I like the idea of getting a (hopefully) quality rebuild with a new replacement clutch included, from a remanufacturer with lots of experience and high standards rather than "hoping" the shop "gets it right" & diagnoses all the little problems & fixes them correctly on this repair that requires so much attention to detail.
Buying a rebuilt (as long as it's quality) tranny and turning this into a simple bolt-up job would seem to eliminate a lot of the guesswork, no?
I'm also reluctant to buy a used 5-speed tranny in unknown condition, or a new one (way 2 much $$$$$) and having to cough up more $ for a clutch kit separately.
I am tempted to try to track down a VLSD, used, or new, if the price is right - anyone with leads/hints on this option, please post.
Any advice, insights, will be greatly appreciated.
Cheers,
-Keith-
http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/ws/eB...&category=6780
Anyone experienced with this or other resellers of rebuilt transmissions, please offer any insights.
My bearings are starting to go bad on my 5-speed, (like so many others here, apparently)
See: http://forums.maxima.org/showthread....ssion+clicking
My options are:
A) Rebuild my existing tranny
B) Buy a complete rebuild w/ clutch (like in the link above).
C) Buy a used tranny in unverifiable condition
D) Buy a new tranny
E) Buy a VLSD tranny, used
Anyway, I like the idea of getting a (hopefully) quality rebuild with a new replacement clutch included, from a remanufacturer with lots of experience and high standards rather than "hoping" the shop "gets it right" & diagnoses all the little problems & fixes them correctly on this repair that requires so much attention to detail.
Buying a rebuilt (as long as it's quality) tranny and turning this into a simple bolt-up job would seem to eliminate a lot of the guesswork, no?
I'm also reluctant to buy a used 5-speed tranny in unknown condition, or a new one (way 2 much $$$$$) and having to cough up more $ for a clutch kit separately.
I am tempted to try to track down a VLSD, used, or new, if the price is right - anyone with leads/hints on this option, please post.
Any advice, insights, will be greatly appreciated.
Cheers,
-Keith-
But I wouldn't use the stock clutch anyway, I'd get an ACT Clutch - why not get the best installed while you're at it in the first place?
#3
Re: Re: Would you buy a remanufactured 5-speed tranny from here?
Originally posted by iansw
I've spoken with those guys on several occassions when doing my research - they seem pretty on the ball, and their prices on EBay are pretty good.
But I wouldn't use the stock clutch anyway, I'd get an ACT Clutch - why not get the best installed while you're at it in the first place?
I've spoken with those guys on several occassions when doing my research - they seem pretty on the ball, and their prices on EBay are pretty good.
But I wouldn't use the stock clutch anyway, I'd get an ACT Clutch - why not get the best installed while you're at it in the first place?
The Raybestos clutch they use - any good, or no?
So Ian, would you consider a remanufactured unit vs. having a local shop monkey around inside your existing tranny? (Plse excuse the bias)
(My problem is I don't know any good Nissan techs in Miami/Ft. Lauderdale area, so I'm thinking maybe it's better to just get the remanufactured unit so I know all the internals are good from the get-go).
Crap, I dunno - I really could use some good advice here, guys.
Please, anyone - opinions on this greatly appreciated.
Thanks Ian & thank you all.
-Keith-
#5
Since nearly every internal component is checnged/repaired during a rebuild, I owuld probably trust the refanufactured unit more than just having a general mechanic do a "rebuild".
This shop seems to sell alot of them, and then they Dyno test it. Sounds really good to me.
This shop seems to sell alot of them, and then they Dyno test it. Sounds really good to me.
#6
Originally posted by iansw
Since nearly every internal component is checnged/repaired during a rebuild, I owuld probably trust the refanufactured unit more than just having a general mechanic do a "rebuild".
This shop seems to sell alot of them, and then they Dyno test it. Sounds really good to me.
Since nearly every internal component is checnged/repaired during a rebuild, I owuld probably trust the refanufactured unit more than just having a general mechanic do a "rebuild".
This shop seems to sell alot of them, and then they Dyno test it. Sounds really good to me.
I agree, I havent heard too many positive "mechanic rebuild" stories of the 5 speed. I for one, opened mine up after it was rebuilt by a "speciality tranny shop" and found they had parts missing (shims and oil guides), didnt change any bearings, and it looks like they didnt check the tolerances of jack. Its really hard to find quality work these days.
#7
Yep - get the rebuild
I would have if I had the money to buy that AND everything else for the converison.
Unfortunately, I didn't, and now I've got a tranny with 110k on it.
But if it ever goes, I plan on rebuilding it myself.
I would have if I had the money to buy that AND everything else for the converison.
Unfortunately, I didn't, and now I've got a tranny with 110k on it.
But if it ever goes, I plan on rebuilding it myself.
#9
Hey all,
My car went into storage for the summer & now it's free again, so time to deal with this. . .
I've since done some more research & read some negative customer experiences regarding phoenixhardparts (http://www.phoenixhardparts.com/Merchant2/merchant.mv), so I'm shopping around for other reputable rebuilders who offer good solid warranties.
Anyone know any good 5-speed tranny rebuilders/remanufacturers? I'm continuing my online research. . .
All advice appreciated.
UPDATE EDIT:
Shopped all day online 2day - I have come to the conclusion that there are not many used 5-speed trannies out there and those who have them are asking a small fortune for them. -And with high mileage/no warranty, to boot!
Example: found one '96 w/ 105,000 mi: seller asking $900!
I also found rebuilders were asking anywhere from $1,130-$1,800 for rebuilt units with 12mo/12kmi warranties.
Just because I felt I was out of options, I gave phoenixhardparts a call - they have 4th gen 5-speeds remanufactured with all the Nissan factory update specifications to 2003 for $925 plus $180 shipping for both the reman unit & your core back to them. 12mo/12kmi warranty applies.
I think I may go this route, despite some concerns I have re: customer feedback I've read about them.* I'm hoping it represents only a small % of their total business. . .
*See: www.phoenixhardpartssucks.com
My car went into storage for the summer & now it's free again, so time to deal with this. . .
I've since done some more research & read some negative customer experiences regarding phoenixhardparts (http://www.phoenixhardparts.com/Merchant2/merchant.mv), so I'm shopping around for other reputable rebuilders who offer good solid warranties.
Anyone know any good 5-speed tranny rebuilders/remanufacturers? I'm continuing my online research. . .
All advice appreciated.
UPDATE EDIT:
Shopped all day online 2day - I have come to the conclusion that there are not many used 5-speed trannies out there and those who have them are asking a small fortune for them. -And with high mileage/no warranty, to boot!
Example: found one '96 w/ 105,000 mi: seller asking $900!
I also found rebuilders were asking anywhere from $1,130-$1,800 for rebuilt units with 12mo/12kmi warranties.
Just because I felt I was out of options, I gave phoenixhardparts a call - they have 4th gen 5-speeds remanufactured with all the Nissan factory update specifications to 2003 for $925 plus $180 shipping for both the reman unit & your core back to them. 12mo/12kmi warranty applies.
I think I may go this route, despite some concerns I have re: customer feedback I've read about them.* I'm hoping it represents only a small % of their total business. . .
*See: www.phoenixhardpartssucks.com
#11
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
jmlee44
4th Generation Maxima (1995-1999)
8
10-02-2022 02:13 PM
My Coffee
New Member Introductions
15
06-06-2017 02:01 PM
tseng1023
5th Generation Classifieds (2000-2003)
3
10-15-2015 08:30 AM
atriuum
4th Generation Classifieds (1995-1999)
3
09-28-2015 01:19 PM
Kyle Lee Cleveland
6th Generation Maxima (2004-2008)
3
09-28-2015 07:58 AM