manual vs. auto (merged threads)
Hey maxima98vspec, I hope your a better driver than speller or grammarian because it gets very annoying to read your posts. Anyway, each has its benifits. Even a built auto(VB, TC, Other?) will have more drivetrain loss than a standard but it is definitely more consistent. The standard is cheaper to repair but is also much easier to break and the lower drivetrain loss doesn't matter when consitency goes out the window 2 outta 10 times at the track. Each has its pros and cons.
the auto is reliable when it comes to shifting, no way you can misshift. and if you have a $h!tty driver, the auto will be faster. i think its based more on the driver than on the manual being better than the auto itself
Originally Posted by matty
....I garentee Nissan ONLY made 2-3% 5spd for the 4th Generation Maxima...
-matt
-matt
Originally Posted by eckohb
i think its based more on the driver than on the manual being better than the auto itself

- A manual is 60 pounds lighter.
- A manual has much more aggressive gear ratios.
- A manual puts 5-7% more power to the ground.
It's not the transmission's fault if the putz behind the wheel doesn't know how to shift it!
Originally Posted by Maxjm
I heard that every 1 in 10 Maximas is manual. I love manual, but it does get annoying to shift sometimes. Especially when you are trying to eat a burger while driving.
Originally Posted by eckohb
ive got an auto, and with simple mods such as a hacked air box, a magnaflow muffler, and the DR mod, i've got my numbers down to what a manual stock has...i would prefer a manual, but ill have to wait for that. im just saying an auto can perform too
im saying the manually potentially can be better than an automatic, depending on if the driver knows how to use it correctly. like i said, i would prefer an manual 5 spd, but im not complaining with my auto either.
[QUOTE=Maximum96]just about every manual car i raced,yes even hondas, they get ahead of me on a launch, then i can catch up... racing a manual max or any other manual around our same HP and torque vs. an auto max is like giving the manual 1-1.5 second head start depending on mods,...so i can just imagine what i can do with a manual, not only with a launch, but with more power and better tranny mods
Originally Posted by jtm087
I always wondered why exactly a manual is better if you are planning on racing? and what are the downs to racing with an auto?
Originally Posted by maxima98vspec
u can do the valve body mod and the drop resistor mod. and like the dragsters have auto trannies, u can usualy get some custom stuff done to it..autos better then manuals?!?!? no way, i know i can take a auto any day.
see, i read about this "automagic" that people are talking about. is it something special, or just what they call an automatic? and i agree, with my DR WOT mod, im happy to say my car would be able to keep up with a manual maxima, if not beat it. id like to take you up on that offer to, but youre also too far away.
Originally Posted by eckohb
see, i read about this "automagic" that people are talking about. is it something special, or just what they call an automatic? and i agree, with my DR WOT mod, im happy to say my car would be able to keep up with a manual maxima, if not beat it. id like to take you up on that offer to, but youre also too far away.
...
eckohb, you're proving to me and all that you are stupid. You are ignoring physics. If you don't know what I'm talking about read SteVTEC's last post.
- A manual is 60 pounds lighter.
- A manual has much more aggressive gear ratios.
- A manual puts 5-7% more power to the ground.
- A manual has much more aggressive gear ratios.
- A manual puts 5-7% more power to the ground.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
My Coffee
New Member Introductions
15
Jun 6, 2017 02:01 PM




