View Poll Results: What type of oil do you use in your 3.5L and does it burn oil?
Voters: 45. You may not vote on this poll
5.5 gen oil burning and what type of oil you use.
Originally Posted by TheBigDu
I've got an auto, and my engine burns oil like crazy too.
When I first got the car, I put full synthetic in, and the engine was clearly burning oil. So I then went back to regular oil and noticed a decrease in the amount being burned. I thought for a while that the engine wasn't burning much...up until the last time I changed the oil. When I did so about two weeks ago, only 3 qts. came out! That's 1.5 quarts low! And I check the dipstick regularly; the oil was still within the meshed region. You'd think if the engine was 1.5 quarts low, the oil shouldn't reach the dipstick, but it does.
When I first got the car, I put full synthetic in, and the engine was clearly burning oil. So I then went back to regular oil and noticed a decrease in the amount being burned. I thought for a while that the engine wasn't burning much...up until the last time I changed the oil. When I did so about two weeks ago, only 3 qts. came out! That's 1.5 quarts low! And I check the dipstick regularly; the oil was still within the meshed region. You'd think if the engine was 1.5 quarts low, the oil shouldn't reach the dipstick, but it does.
So technically, if you are having someone else do your oil changes, they could leave out a quart or more in the process and no one would know. How can we have a 4.5 quart capacity in the 3.5L and be missing 1/3 of the total oil capacity and not get a engine oil low light (idiot light) or better yet, still show good on the stick?
Wow, how can we ever be sure that what we have in the crankcase is sufficient to protect the motor, especially at high speeds or in hot of cold conditions? If the vehicle can be a quart or more low and still show on the dipstick, we could be setting ourselves up for catastrophic engine failure.
Originally Posted by Puppetmaster
Yeah, all five people who answered your question. That is hardly convincing to me.
The other thing is that you have no idea how people are measuring the oil they are draining, or if they are just going by the dipstick, which may or may not be accurate.
Just a couple of things for you to think about if you want to make this avenue of research worthwhile.
The other thing is that you have no idea how people are measuring the oil they are draining, or if they are just going by the dipstick, which may or may not be accurate.
Just a couple of things for you to think about if you want to make this avenue of research worthwhile.
Originally Posted by TheBigDu
^^ Yes, that included the oil in the filter. I put it all in the oil pan and then poured it all into a 1 gallon container and it only filled the container to just above 3 qts.
Has anyone here thought of running a 20w oil or even 40w? I was talking to an Altima SE-R owner today at work and he said he researched this problem somewhat, and it was reccomended to run a 40w oil...
Guest
Posts: n/a
Our cars do not take 4.5 quarts. If you were to let all the oil drain out for no less than 4 hours then you might get 4.3-4.35 but with the engine brand new it takes 4.4. if you let the oil drain out for about half an hour to where its down to a barely small drip then 4.25 fills it right to the top after waiting 20 minutes to accurately check the dipstick.
There is no way the problem can be caused by the six speeds themselves unless it is like one person stated that they are just revving up alot higher because its a stick.
Also, synthetic oil does not burn. Its impossible. The oil is going somewhere. Also, it is true that if you do have worn or cracked piston rings or any leaks that synthetic oil will go thru the very small cracks. Other than that if you have no worn piston rings, synthetic oil will very well keep you from getting worn or cracked rings because of the better protection.
When you start your car up cold and its got the little top end engine noise, the synthetic would also help with that problem as well seen as how it flows atleast twice as fast as conventional oil at all temps. low and high.
When I first bought my 03 maxima it had 36k on it and every once and a while it would get the little engine noise when the car sat for a while. I found out the dealership changed the oil when they received the car and obvioulsy put conventional. I then changed to mobil 1 5w 30 and even tho the filter was empty and the car had sat for a while when i started it up there was no engine noise. Since then there hasnt been. Knock on wood.
Just some thoughts..........
There is no way the problem can be caused by the six speeds themselves unless it is like one person stated that they are just revving up alot higher because its a stick.
Also, synthetic oil does not burn. Its impossible. The oil is going somewhere. Also, it is true that if you do have worn or cracked piston rings or any leaks that synthetic oil will go thru the very small cracks. Other than that if you have no worn piston rings, synthetic oil will very well keep you from getting worn or cracked rings because of the better protection.
When you start your car up cold and its got the little top end engine noise, the synthetic would also help with that problem as well seen as how it flows atleast twice as fast as conventional oil at all temps. low and high.
When I first bought my 03 maxima it had 36k on it and every once and a while it would get the little engine noise when the car sat for a while. I found out the dealership changed the oil when they received the car and obvioulsy put conventional. I then changed to mobil 1 5w 30 and even tho the filter was empty and the car had sat for a while when i started it up there was no engine noise. Since then there hasnt been. Knock on wood.
Just some thoughts..........
Originally Posted by Derek626k
When I first bought my 03 maxima it had 36k on it and every once and a while it would get the little engine noise when the car sat for a while. I found out the dealership changed the oil when they received the car and obvioulsy put conventional. I then changed to mobil 1 5w 30 and even tho the filter was empty and the car had sat for a while when i started it up there was no engine noise. Since then there hasnt been. Knock on wood.
Just some thoughts..........
Just some thoughts..........
I have the same rattle for a second when I first start my car in the morning, but it hasn't bother me. I have always run conventional oil.
Originally Posted by bvenvert
Sounds like synthetic oil eliminates the problem with timing chain rattle at startup? Has anyone else found this to be true?
Originally Posted by bvenvert
Sounds like synthetic oil eliminates the problem with timing chain rattle at startup? Has anyone else found this to be true?
I have the same rattle for a second when I first start my car in the morning, but it hasn't bother me. I have always run conventional oil.
I have the same rattle for a second when I first start my car in the morning, but it hasn't bother me. I have always run conventional oil.
Not True for my 2000 either. I run Mobil 1 5/20 and I still have timing chain rattle once in a while.
Originally Posted by Puppetmaster
No. I switched from regular to synthetic and while it reduced the cold start rattle, it did not eliminate it completely.
Originally Posted by babymac
This is exactly what happened to the 2.5 motors in the spec v's and the altima's. There was a major recall for it.
You might talk about the butterfly screws inspection campaign right?
But yes they do believe pieces of the cat could get sucked in due to valve overlap. Intake/exhaust
Originally Posted by soonerfan
when i started having the problem, the dealership pulled that BS about sythetic oil so i switched. 8,000 miles later the problem didnt go away.
i dont understand why nissan would recommend not using sythetic. it is better period. i guess they just dont like that it shows there is problem with the engine
i dont understand why nissan would recommend not using sythetic. it is better period. i guess they just dont like that it shows there is problem with the engine
Originally Posted by GBAUER
reducing cold start rattle: nissan filter. Just buy them. they work better.
Originally Posted by NisTech
The cold start rattle is caused by a sprocket. Nissan says to replace it. Perhaps that is of a new design to retain more oil. To do that you have to have the side cover off. Not fun!
Originally Posted by Puppetmaster
No. I switched from regular to synthetic and while it reduced the cold start rattle, it did not eliminate it completely.
Guest
Posts: n/a
Maximas have been well known for many years since at least the 4th gen to have oil circulation issues. Not that I would persay call it an issue but when cold or been off for a while, they do take an extra second for the oil to travel to the topend of the engine. As far as right now synthetic oil is the best solution I have seen or heard of.
I didn't say that synthetic oil would necessarily fix the problem but it did do a very good job for me.
I didn't say that synthetic oil would necessarily fix the problem but it did do a very good job for me.
Originally Posted by NisTech
what recall are you talking about?
You might talk about the butterfly screws inspection campaign right?
But yes they do believe pieces of the cat could get sucked in due to valve overlap. Intake/exhaust
You might talk about the butterfly screws inspection campaign right?
But yes they do believe pieces of the cat could get sucked in due to valve overlap. Intake/exhaust
Auto Recall Date: 20060621
Vehicle Component: ENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING
Estimated Vehicles Affected: 85000
2006 NISSAN ALTIMA/SENTRA Defect Summary:
CERTAIN PASSENGER VEHICLES EQUIPPED WITH 2.5L ENGINES MAY EXPERIENCE EXCESSIVE ENGINE OIL CONSUMPTION AS A RESULT OF IMPROPER PERFORMANCE OF THE PISTON RINGS.
Defect Consequence:
IF THE OIL IS NOT MAINTAINED AT LEAST AT THE MINIMUM LEVEL, ENGINE DAMAGE CAN OCCUR AND IN EXTREME CASES RESULT IN AN ENGINE FIRE.
Remedy:
NISSAN HAS NOT YET PROVIDED A REMEDY FOR THIS CAMPAIGN. ON JUNE 9, 2006, NISSAN NOTIFIED OWNERS OF THE POSSIBILITY OF EXCESSIVE OIL CONSUMPTION AND THE IMPORTANCE OF MAINTAINING THE OIL AT A PROPER LEVEL. OWNERS MAY CONTACT NISSAN AT 1-800-647-7261.
Notes: NISSAN NORTH AMERICA, INC.,
Originally Posted by Derek626k
Maximas have been well known for many years since at least the 4th gen to have oil circulation issues. Not that I would persay call it an issue but when cold or been off for a while, they do take an extra second for the oil to travel to the topend of the engine.
Which motor that you know of builds full oil pressure while cranking?
Originally Posted by kingrukus
Has anyone here thought of running a 20w oil or even 40w? I was talking to an Altima SE-R owner today at work and he said he researched this problem somewhat, and it was reccomended to run a 40w oil...
Originally Posted by Derek626k
Our cars do not take 4.5 quarts.... 4.25 fills it right to the top after waiting 20 minutes to accurately check the dipstick.
All told, I added 4.63 quarts (I have 400ml left in the 5th quart I was adding) and the oil level is sitting dead on the top of the crosshatches. I will be monitoring my oil consumption and measuring how much comes out when I change it in 3k miles. Incidentally, I am using conventional Mobil 5W-30 (called "Clean 5000" by their marketing dept) because that weight was recommended in the owners manual (I changed it yesterday prior to seeing this thread). I'll probably be switching to a heavier 10W-30 as it doesn't get much below 15-20 degrees F in North Carolina in the winter. As for the conventional/synthetic discussion, I change my own oil every 3k so I'd be wasting money if I used synthetic.
On the topic of oil usage, in my short amount of reading, it does appear there is a mild correlation between oil consumption and owners running synthetic oil in their motors. The consumption issue also seems to be exacerbated slightly in those cars that also have a manual tranny (although belief that the org responses could be viewed as a representative sample of all 5.5 gen owners would be just plain wrong). As consumers buying a Maxima, we expect tight tolerances and do not expect our cars to consume oil as our past experience with Japanese cars has likely shown little to no oil consumption.
However, with '02 being the 1st year of the 3.5 in the Maxima, one could almost predict some problems arising (same reason 1st and 2nd yr production quality is almost always lower in any model year redesign) as the engineers can't model and/or test everything. Issues (some big/some small) with the initial design make themselves known through real world use of the cars and the engineers redesign things in subsequent model years to improve quality. This is the way the auto industry works.
It appears (again from a small sample size) that Nissan has improved whatever quality problem they found associated with oil consumption as the issue has been reported considerably less from 6th gen owners. In the meantime, us 5.5 gen owners have to pray that our cars don't have oil consumption issues and if we do happen to be one of the unlucky ones, figure out ways to mitigate our own oil consumption issues or fight Nissan for a new motor in cases where consumption is really bad so that we can spend time enjoying our rides, which is what drove us to buy the Maxima in the first place.
20xxx miles on Mobil 1 5W-30 and 9E000 filter, I too had to add more than 4.25 quarts to get the dip stick to read exactly to the HI mark (more like 4.6). Last time I filled exactly 4.25 and my dip stick read 1/2 between LO and HI.
Originally Posted by utas424
I use Nissan filters as well. But no Rattle
Oil Consumption
I have a 02 SE 6sp with 55K. For the last 10K miles I have been noticing that after about 2K miles between oil changes the engine will start to make a ticking noise when I am just coasting around 1500-2000 rpm. I will add about a ½ -3/4 of a quart and the noise goes away. I have owned this car since new, and I have changed the oil religiously every 3K miles. Most of the oil changes have been done by the dealership. The last time I had it at the dealership I told them about the oil consumption, and they told me to drive it 2K and bring it back. I dove it the 2K and the noise was just starting, and the dealership said it was fine??? Has anyone been able to get Nissan to replace the motor under the extended warrantee for this problem, and if so, what is the best way to approach it?
I noticed the oil-burning issue when my car had about 30k. The engine was making a loud knocking noise for several days so I took it to the dealer and they informed me my car had less than 2qts of oil left. Needless to say, I was pissed. I had been using mobil1 5w30 full syn since the first oil change at 3k. The dealer started a consumption test using regular 5w30 which they checked every 500 miles. They said the car was not burning enough to replace the engine (1/2qt every 1k vs. 1qt per 1k with syn). I recently switched to mobil1 clean 5000 5w30 and the car is now burning at LEAST 1qt every 1k. I have 42k on the motor. I purchased an extended warranty due to this problem so I will probably just let the motor destroy itself then they will have to replace the engine. I am very disappointed about all of this because I love my car.
Originally Posted by madmxx
I noticed the oil-burning issue when my car had about 30k. The engine was making a loud knocking noise for several days so I took it to the dealer and they informed me my car had less than 2qts of oil left. Needless to say, I was pissed. I had been using mobil1 5w30 full syn since the first oil change at 3k. The dealer started a consumption test using regular 5w30 which they checked every 500 miles. They said the car was not burning enough to replace the engine (1/2qt every 1k vs. 1qt per 1k with syn). I recently switched to mobil1 clean 5000 5w30 and the car is now burning at LEAST 1qt every 1k. I have 42k on the motor. I purchased an extended warranty due to this problem so I will probably just let the motor destroy itself then they will have to replace the engine. I am very disappointed about all of this because I love my car.
Originally Posted by 1whtmax
when you guys determine how much oil is consumed do you follow what the dipstick measures or the amount of oil that comes out of the oil pan?
i had a 4th gen 5spd which never burnt a drop of oil. now i have a 5.5gen which burns like crazy i always thought it was because of the way i drive but one of my friend's wife has a murano which is also a 3.5l burns oil at the same rate as the max, i think the two best way of fixing this issue is either by changing to the conventional oil or ripping the motor apart and change the rings (too expensive though)
Originally Posted by MaxSE-R
most of us measure the amount of oil that drains out. it would be kinda stupid to use the dipstick since it doesnt measure correctly anyways, you have to wait 15mins to get a good reading and most of the time it doesnt even give you a good reading anyways.
I have a 2003 six speed. Got it at 34,500. Put sythetic in shortly after, say 35-36. I haven't seen any oil consumption worth mentioning, I even went 5k before changing the oil and it didn't burn any or at least unnoticeable(synthetic- mobile one). Royal purple in there now with mobile 1 filter.
This stuff scares me but thought i'd mention my car has been ok so far at 47k. A reason some of the cars may burn oil is if they were not broken in properly, when the parts are new they become "married" as they wear and the pistons seat in the cylinder wall. If the breakin process is not done right the parts won't properly "mesh" together and may cause oil consumption the rest of the cars life. A picture of a stupid salesman beating on a new car as he goes for a joy ride comes to mind, or even the 1st owner. Also lugging is very bad, it breaks the seal of oil and causes metal on metal which can cause leaks due to wear.
This stuff scares me but thought i'd mention my car has been ok so far at 47k. A reason some of the cars may burn oil is if they were not broken in properly, when the parts are new they become "married" as they wear and the pistons seat in the cylinder wall. If the breakin process is not done right the parts won't properly "mesh" together and may cause oil consumption the rest of the cars life. A picture of a stupid salesman beating on a new car as he goes for a joy ride comes to mind, or even the 1st owner. Also lugging is very bad, it breaks the seal of oil and causes metal on metal which can cause leaks due to wear.
lugging is when your rpms are too low for the gear you are in when using a manual transmission. It puts excessive force on the piston, piston rings, crankshaft, stuff. There is a thin layer of oil riding between the metal parts in your engine(they are hydroplaning essentially) and when you lug the oil seal breaks down and you get metal on metal, very bad. Thats why on 6-speeds the owner's manual says not to shift into 5 until you goin 36 mph and not to shift into sixth until 48 mph. People who ride in 6th gear at like 30 to 47 can be/are causing excessive wear.
I ckd. my dipstick first thing this morning and it was about half way thorough the hash marks. After driving the car and bringing her home, I waited for about 20 mins, then re-ckd. and the oil level was almost at the top of the hash marks on the stick. What's up with that?? (The manual does say to let the car reach normal operating temp. then wait about 10 mins to ck. the oil level, so that the oil goes back to the pan, but Ive always thought ckg. oil in the morning allows plenty of time for the oil to get back in the pan. So why do I show less oil when the cars' been sitting overnight for hours)?












