Repeat Threads/Topics that have been discussed. Suggestion.
01-14-2008, 10:30 AM
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Virginia Beach, VA
Posts: 430
Repeat Threads/Topics that have been discussed. Suggestion.
you know what i think we should ALL do. if we see a thread with a topic that has been beaten to death, then dont respond to it all. if you turn a cold shoulder to it, then the thread will fall off the main page of the 5th gen section and the person who posted it is forced to search. the only thing that were doing by responding to these threads is bumping it the thread to the top. so from now on, how about we dont respond to these threads unless its something that cannot be searched and found. just a suggestion.
im not mod of this forum nor would i like to be one but for those of you who do the repeat "search this" or "read stickies", this might work out well for you.
also i do realize that this should be in the suggestion section of the .org but hardly anyone goes there.
-Najib
im not mod of this forum nor would i like to be one but for those of you who do the repeat "search this" or "read stickies", this might work out well for you.
also i do realize that this should be in the suggestion section of the .org but hardly anyone goes there.
-Najib
01-14-2008, 11:53 AM
#3
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Virginia Beach, VA
Posts: 430
all im saying is if it is a legitimate tech question that has NOT been discussed, then fine post away but if its something that be searched, then a new thread is not nessasary.
01-14-2008, 11:55 AM
#4
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Virginia Beach, VA
Posts: 430
Also ill be the first to say that i have said "search and you will find the answer" but things like spark plug, headers, bose, and etc threads appear almost daily due to someone not taking the time to search.
To mods: i am in not way trying to do your jobs but i thought this little insight might help.
To mods: i am in not way trying to do your jobs but i thought this little insight might help.
01-14-2008, 12:07 PM
#6
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Virginia Beach, VA
Posts: 430
also side note, i dont know if people have those redundant responses just to bring up their post count. it almost seems like the post count determains ones seniority over others.
01-14-2008, 12:44 PM
#7
The lack of a good search to the non supporting member I would suspect has an effect on the repeat threads.
I have been on a few boards where the mods would jump on the throat of any repeat thread. It would get merged with the existing thread. Very clean.
I have been on a few boards where the mods would jump on the throat of any repeat thread. It would get merged with the existing thread. Very clean.
01-14-2008, 01:00 PM
#10
I was here. 
In general, old, reposted threads are locked if they are bumped for no good reason. If the discussion can be continued constructively, we'll let them live. The merging concept only works if the information in the two threads is complimentary, if not, the posts will be sort of redundant. Needless to say, all these are taken on a case by case basis.
In general, old, reposted threads are locked if they are bumped for no good reason. If the discussion can be continued constructively, we'll let them live. The merging concept only works if the information in the two threads is complimentary, if not, the posts will be sort of redundant. Needless to say, all these are taken on a case by case basis.
01-14-2008, 01:10 PM
#11
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Virginia Beach, VA
Posts: 430
to mods: is there a way you guys can place a filter so that when a new thread is trying to be created that it doesnt allow a person to due to similar words? im not sure if that makes sense but
example: i want to make a header thread. my title is "cattman header", if i try to make a new one and the system finds that those similar words are used in a archieved thread or a current one then it doesnt allow that new thread to be created.
example: i want to make a header thread. my title is "cattman header", if i try to make a new one and the system finds that those similar words are used in a archieved thread or a current one then it doesnt allow that new thread to be created.
01-14-2008, 01:20 PM
#13
lol, i've been here long enough these guys know me, and know why i posted that in this thread. i just don't foresee an improvement via this route cause it's hard to babysit every little thread as it is. there is more time involved as well.
your suggestion in your example wouldn't work too well if it could be done in the first place. i can title a thread, "cattman headers" but what if it something like, "my cattman headers just fell off my car" or something like that? that has nothing to do with install, quality, or inquiry of said headers. it's just in the title, so you're going to stop me from creating that thread because of common words? that's what makes it hard to do that, who's to say what's relative and what's not prior to the creation of a thread.
your suggestion in your example wouldn't work too well if it could be done in the first place. i can title a thread, "cattman headers" but what if it something like, "my cattman headers just fell off my car" or something like that? that has nothing to do with install, quality, or inquiry of said headers. it's just in the title, so you're going to stop me from creating that thread because of common words? that's what makes it hard to do that, who's to say what's relative and what's not prior to the creation of a thread.
01-14-2008, 01:38 PM
#15
01-14-2008, 01:52 PM
#18
01-14-2008, 02:04 PM
#19
01-14-2008, 02:17 PM
#21
Wouldn't working on the FAQ's/Howto's so they contain more/better information to take care of those repeat question be better?
I would be willing to help on that, if anyone is interested.
Also, searching if you haven't donated is sometimes troublesome, it looks like the forums aren't indexed correctly by Google anymore. They were when I first started reading here, last April.
I would be willing to help on that, if anyone is interested.
Also, searching if you haven't donated is sometimes troublesome, it looks like the forums aren't indexed correctly by Google anymore. They were when I first started reading here, last April.
01-14-2008, 03:15 PM
#25
Junior Member
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Long Island, New York
Posts: 37
01-14-2008, 03:24 PM
#26
Why would people have trouble searching then.... they're too lazy to search?!?
I can see why some of you are annoyed now!
01-14-2008, 03:33 PM
#28
Two threads *****ing about it already, no reason to do so here:
http://forums.maxima.org/showthread.php?t=550763
http://forums.maxima.org/showthread.php?t=550530
01-14-2008, 03:42 PM
#29
People love to increase their post count with statements telling noobs to search. Nothing will change because not everyone will know if it is a repeat thread, etc...
Personally, I think the Newbie Question thread should be enforced, with maybe a small outline of what has been covered in it, in the first post.
Second, the FAQs/How-Tos do need to be updated, as there are a bunch of dead links, etc. Telling someone to search for a thread that should be there, makes that sticky worthless.
Personally, I think the Newbie Question thread should be enforced, with maybe a small outline of what has been covered in it, in the first post.
Second, the FAQs/How-Tos do need to be updated, as there are a bunch of dead links, etc. Telling someone to search for a thread that should be there, makes that sticky worthless.
01-15-2008, 09:46 AM
#30
People love to stress that you should search, makes them feel smart; no specific names! So then they can get their post count up, they feeel smarter and they haven't helped anyone out.
The search wasnt working very good for awhile recently.. but instead of one of these "smart guys" posting a link and being done with it, they just say search and throw a couple other pointless comments out there. And in the end you have another repeat thread that is pages long of nothing but little school girls bickering about everyone else's pointless comments. Grow up and learn some common sense.
As for the dumb threads that are started for a stoopid question as a part number, or where to find something, blah blah blah, just let it die out. Google search still works!
The search wasnt working very good for awhile recently.. but instead of one of these "smart guys" posting a link and being done with it, they just say search and throw a couple other pointless comments out there. And in the end you have another repeat thread that is pages long of nothing but little school girls bickering about everyone else's pointless comments. Grow up and learn some common sense.
As for the dumb threads that are started for a stoopid question as a part number, or where to find something, blah blah blah, just let it die out. Google search still works!
01-15-2008, 10:44 AM
#31
Junior Member
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Atlanta/Athens
Posts: 62
Opening up the vBulletin search should help a LOT in terms of repeat threads. I've been reading on here for a while.. the google search is horrible. I tried something like ""5th gen" +"angel eyes"" and got no result. Now, I can pick the subforum and a topic and I actually get relevant information.. hence, not having to try to start a thread of my own cause I can't find the info I'm looking for.
01-15-2008, 12:41 PM
#32
Calm down people. Search works for everyone now, so please try using that for now. I'm still working on fixing the FAQs and How-Tos. I just have a lot going on these days.
01-15-2008, 12:51 PM
#33
01-20-2008, 01:03 PM
#34
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: houston tx
Posts: 189
I'm brand new to the site and am doing my best to keep up with all the jargon that goes on with forums, but at the same time most ppl new to forums need the experienced guys to give them a hand and get them going.
if nobody helped me out, i'd say forget it to the site. But i've gained a bunch of knowledge in just 2 days, and hell, maybe after a year or 2 with my maxima and the forum, i'll be albe to start helping the future newbies. I'm 25 years old, so i have some time left....
if nobody helped me out, i'd say forget it to the site. But i've gained a bunch of knowledge in just 2 days, and hell, maybe after a year or 2 with my maxima and the forum, i'll be albe to start helping the future newbies. I'm 25 years old, so i have some time left....
01-20-2008, 01:26 PM
#35
I'm brand new to the site and am doing my best to keep up with all the jargon that goes on with forums, but at the same time most ppl new to forums need the experienced guys to give them a hand and get them going.
if nobody helped me out, i'd say forget it to the site. But i've gained a bunch of knowledge in just 2 days, and hell, maybe after a year or 2 with my maxima and the forum, i'll be albe to start helping the future newbies. I'm 25 years old, so i have some time left....
if nobody helped me out, i'd say forget it to the site. But i've gained a bunch of knowledge in just 2 days, and hell, maybe after a year or 2 with my maxima and the forum, i'll be albe to start helping the future newbies. I'm 25 years old, so i have some time left....
01-20-2008, 02:27 PM
#36
Ive been here for a while, and look at my post count. This is a very useful place.... if used correctly. I think if you really want to fix a problem, you should understand it first. Being "spoonfed" doesn't really help in the long run.
01-20-2008, 02:33 PM
#37
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Philadelphia, PA
Posts: 2,898
not to be a nay-sayer here, but i dont think this idea will work...
there are so many people on this board, it's insane.. the people that respond to the repeat threads aren't just the more seasoned members who are tired of the same topic being posted over and over again... you also have the people who have a little bit of knowledge, and have the mindset where they want to share that knowledge and help people.. these people have been here long enough to learn some things, but not long enough where they're tired of seeing the same topic posted 10 billion times... and these will be the ones who respond to the threads and keep them alive
there are so many people on this board, it's insane.. the people that respond to the repeat threads aren't just the more seasoned members who are tired of the same topic being posted over and over again... you also have the people who have a little bit of knowledge, and have the mindset where they want to share that knowledge and help people.. these people have been here long enough to learn some things, but not long enough where they're tired of seeing the same topic posted 10 billion times... and these will be the ones who respond to the threads and keep them alive
01-20-2008, 02:36 PM
#38
if we all follow the same mindset (which was also the rules for years before they were changed to be more polite and let everyone do what they want) this wouldnt be an issue.
veterans will say to search, but all we need is one person to spoon feed the person and its all over. that person now knows he can get away with it.
veterans will say to search, but all we need is one person to spoon feed the person and its all over. that person now knows he can get away with it.
01-21-2008, 03:16 PM
#39
Junior Member
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Long Island, New York
Posts: 37
5th gen maximas have been out for ~7 years. Realistically, how many new, interesting threads can possibly be made? Ive been reading pretty much everything on this forum since i got my car about five months ago, and all the information (which was brand new to me) here was pretty exciting. Now that I've finished, every new thread seems to be about some small problem someones had with their car, or poor gas mileage, etc.
I guess the point i'm trying to make is that I think its time for people to accept that pretty much every "new" thread will be on a topic that has already been discussed. Instead of bashing a person who asks a question thats already been answered, why not just answer it, especially if its a simple one that doesn't require any research on the part of the person answering it?
I guess the point i'm trying to make is that I think its time for people to accept that pretty much every "new" thread will be on a topic that has already been discussed. Instead of bashing a person who asks a question thats already been answered, why not just answer it, especially if its a simple one that doesn't require any research on the part of the person answering it?