Knock Sensor Intermittent Failure?
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Alberta, Canada
Posts: 1,022
Knock Sensor Intermittent Failure?
Questions:
1. My car isn't throwing any codes, but I've noticed that it's really peppy when it's cold out, and a dog when it gets warmer... I know this is normal to an extent, but could an intermittently failing KS cause ignition retardation only when it's warmer out?
2. Where is the best place to buy a knock sensor? Are the cheap eBay ones garbage? It's just hard for me to justify $150 from courtesyparts for something that I don't even know is bad or the problem.
3. Is there anything else that could be making my car abnormally slow when it gets warm outside? (like 40+ degrees, so not even THAT warm)
Like for example, would it be unwise to try something like this?
http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/Brand...#ht_581wt_1167
1. My car isn't throwing any codes, but I've noticed that it's really peppy when it's cold out, and a dog when it gets warmer... I know this is normal to an extent, but could an intermittently failing KS cause ignition retardation only when it's warmer out?
2. Where is the best place to buy a knock sensor? Are the cheap eBay ones garbage? It's just hard for me to justify $150 from courtesyparts for something that I don't even know is bad or the problem.
3. Is there anything else that could be making my car abnormally slow when it gets warm outside? (like 40+ degrees, so not even THAT warm)
Like for example, would it be unwise to try something like this?
http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/Brand...#ht_581wt_1167
Last edited by jowo9; 02-12-2011 at 11:09 AM.
#2
I would make sure you actually have a problem. I would try and stick with the courtesy piece. If you have access to an OBDII reader /logger like the Cipher, then log your WOT timing with respect to the outside temperature or, if it's a logger, against the IAT's or even ECT's and see if there is a difference.
#4
Welcome to the world of ****ty stock ECUs (perhaps).
It's the KS when it's related to engine temp. I never could fix the problem with crap performance in the summer. I had the KS simmed and it didn't matter.
And I know it's the ECUs b/c I also had a brand new 05 engine swapped in and the problem still persisted.
But your issue is even more bizarre considering it's still cool out. You can try simming the KS and see what happens.
It's the KS when it's related to engine temp. I never could fix the problem with crap performance in the summer. I had the KS simmed and it didn't matter.
And I know it's the ECUs b/c I also had a brand new 05 engine swapped in and the problem still persisted.
But your issue is even more bizarre considering it's still cool out. You can try simming the KS and see what happens.
Last edited by Child_uv_KoRn; 02-13-2011 at 12:12 AM.
#5
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Alberta, Canada
Posts: 1,022
Welcome to the world of ****ty stock ECUs (perhaps).
It's the KS when it's related to engine temp. I never could fix the problem with crap performance in the summer. I had the KS simmed and it didn't matter.
And I know it's the ECUs b/c I also had a brand new 05 engine swapped in and the problem still persisted.
But your issue is even more bizarre considering it's still cool out. You can try simming the KS and see what happens.
It's the KS when it's related to engine temp. I never could fix the problem with crap performance in the summer. I had the KS simmed and it didn't matter.
And I know it's the ECUs b/c I also had a brand new 05 engine swapped in and the problem still persisted.
But your issue is even more bizarre considering it's still cool out. You can try simming the KS and see what happens.
#6
I thought I had a ks issue, I went to radio shack and picked up a 470 risistor and threw it in to see if it made a difference, it didn't but I had no issues with putting a resistor in the sub harness
Benifits- if your unsure your ks is the problem its better to try a resitor in the ks sub harness because you won't have to remove the intake or cut your hands up Trying to remove it for nothing.
- you are wasting .50 cents as opposed to 150 dollars
Some people disagree with permemently using a risistor because if your engine does knock there is a chance of some damage. I personally would grab a resistor and drive it around for a day and see if you notice a difference, if there is none you just pull it out and plug the harness back in and all you losr out on is a 50 cent purchase. Let me know if you want to know the color code for the resistor they have little color bands to tell you the different resistors, I picked mine up from radio shack and left it in my car for a week with no issues at all! Trust me try this first
-
Benifits- if your unsure your ks is the problem its better to try a resitor in the ks sub harness because you won't have to remove the intake or cut your hands up Trying to remove it for nothing.
- you are wasting .50 cents as opposed to 150 dollars
Some people disagree with permemently using a risistor because if your engine does knock there is a chance of some damage. I personally would grab a resistor and drive it around for a day and see if you notice a difference, if there is none you just pull it out and plug the harness back in and all you losr out on is a 50 cent purchase. Let me know if you want to know the color code for the resistor they have little color bands to tell you the different resistors, I picked mine up from radio shack and left it in my car for a week with no issues at all! Trust me try this first
-
#7
I have the same problem with my '03 Max. Works great in cold weather, but when it warms up, I feel like I'm hauling a 4000 lbs trailer...
I replaced the MAF with a 2k1 MAF, replaced the KS with an eBay one (around $25), replaced a leaky rear valve cover, cleaned the TB, and no improvement...
Question, there is only one wire on the harness that plugs directly into the KS. is that normal or should there be 2 wires?
I replaced the MAF with a 2k1 MAF, replaced the KS with an eBay one (around $25), replaced a leaky rear valve cover, cleaned the TB, and no improvement...
Question, there is only one wire on the harness that plugs directly into the KS. is that normal or should there be 2 wires?
#9
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Alberta, Canada
Posts: 1,022
I thought I had a ks issue, I went to radio shack and picked up a 470 risistor and threw it in to see if it made a difference, it didn't but I had no issues with putting a resistor in the sub harness
Benifits- if your unsure your ks is the problem its better to try a resitor in the ks sub harness because you won't have to remove the intake or cut your hands up Trying to remove it for nothing.
- you are wasting .50 cents as opposed to 150 dollars
Some people disagree with permemently using a risistor because if your engine does knock there is a chance of some damage. I personally would grab a resistor and drive it around for a day and see if you notice a difference, if there is none you just pull it out and plug the harness back in and all you losr out on is a 50 cent purchase. Let me know if you want to know the color code for the resistor they have little color bands to tell you the different resistors, I picked mine up from radio shack and left it in my car for a week with no issues at all! Trust me try this first
-
Benifits- if your unsure your ks is the problem its better to try a resitor in the ks sub harness because you won't have to remove the intake or cut your hands up Trying to remove it for nothing.
- you are wasting .50 cents as opposed to 150 dollars
Some people disagree with permemently using a risistor because if your engine does knock there is a chance of some damage. I personally would grab a resistor and drive it around for a day and see if you notice a difference, if there is none you just pull it out and plug the harness back in and all you losr out on is a 50 cent purchase. Let me know if you want to know the color code for the resistor they have little color bands to tell you the different resistors, I picked mine up from radio shack and left it in my car for a week with no issues at all! Trust me try this first
-
I dunno.
#11
I have the same problem jowo. I need to do this test. Here it is for you though, same for a 97 as it is for the 2001, I can't verify if it's the same for the 5.5 but I'd ASSUME so.
EDIT: THERE ARE 2 WIRES
it's just essentially a resistor to ground, the ECM senses VDC needed to make the 'jump' across the KS to ground. This is based on the resistance of the KS. IIRC when it 'knocks' resistance goes down? Thus increasing VDC at the ECM.
FYI you can also test KS as follows:
1. ECU terminal #93 (wire colour W) Engine running at idle, should be about 2.5 VDC
2. ECU connector #93 (harness side, ECU unplugged) Resistance from KS to ground should be about 500-620 OHMS at operating temperature.
3. Similar to above test just easier, disconnect harness in engine bay, install Ohm meter on KS side wire terminal 1, to ground, same OHM reading should apply.
4. If these tests give you Ohm readings outside of the range specified, there are further tests, but it's likely that the KS is the issue, this is the point that I would install a resistor - a 550 OHM resistor.
EDIT: THERE ARE 2 WIRES
it's just essentially a resistor to ground, the ECM senses VDC needed to make the 'jump' across the KS to ground. This is based on the resistance of the KS. IIRC when it 'knocks' resistance goes down? Thus increasing VDC at the ECM.
FYI you can also test KS as follows:
1. ECU terminal #93 (wire colour W) Engine running at idle, should be about 2.5 VDC
2. ECU connector #93 (harness side, ECU unplugged) Resistance from KS to ground should be about 500-620 OHMS at operating temperature.
3. Similar to above test just easier, disconnect harness in engine bay, install Ohm meter on KS side wire terminal 1, to ground, same OHM reading should apply.
4. If these tests give you Ohm readings outside of the range specified, there are further tests, but it's likely that the KS is the issue, this is the point that I would install a resistor - a 550 OHM resistor.
Last edited by TunerMaxima3000; 02-27-2011 at 04:44 AM.
#12
If his symptoms are the same as mine, power is lost as soon as the engine starts warming up, and power loss is not better/worse depending on specific temperature, just hot/cold.
#14
#15
Someone with the VQ35 needs to verify.
These were my readings.
Reference Voltage at harness, unplugged - 4.86VDC
Cold Resistance (OHMS) @ KS - 455
Operating Temp Resistance (OHMS) @ KS - 630
These readings are to spec. Strange thing happened though, after I checked the cold resistance I plugged it back in, went for a drive, and the car performed amazing, like it usually does when cold, the entire time I was driving.
I don't know why this is, I very much doubt it was a bad connection in the harness I unplugged (although that would make sense).
I can only suspect that something occured in the ECM when I unplugged it, I did have the engine running when I unplugged it and plugged it back in.
Just thought I'd share.
#16
Sorry to steal your thread but I can't post yet lol. But will the check engine light go off if your sensor is bad? I just bought a 2000 Max, I used to have a 96 and my sensor was bad but I dont ever remeber it causing the CEL to go on.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
jmlee44
4th Generation Maxima (1995-1999)
8
10-02-2022 02:13 PM
my03maxima
7th Generation Maxima (2009-2015)
8
04-29-2020 12:48 AM
DC_Juggernaut
7th Generation Maxima (2009-2015)
4
09-28-2015 04:07 PM