Stillen vs. Cattman
#1
Stillen vs. Cattman
which y-pipe is better?
i know that Cattman pipes are made out of stainless-steel where as Stillen pipes are not.
but i wanted to hear from people who currently have Stillen pipes(or Cattman pipes) about any kind of problems associated with the Stillen pipe(i.e. rust).
and as far as the installation goes....is this pretty much a simple bolt-on process? or do i need to take my car to a shop and let a professional do it for me? any comments?
anywayz....happy new year guys and let's have more maxima meetings this year!!!
-peace
i know that Cattman pipes are made out of stainless-steel where as Stillen pipes are not.
but i wanted to hear from people who currently have Stillen pipes(or Cattman pipes) about any kind of problems associated with the Stillen pipe(i.e. rust).
and as far as the installation goes....is this pretty much a simple bolt-on process? or do i need to take my car to a shop and let a professional do it for me? any comments?
anywayz....happy new year guys and let's have more maxima meetings this year!!!
-peace
#2
well, here's the deal. If you live in an area that gets snow the stillen pipe WILL rust. The steel just will not hold up to all the snow, salt, and moisture. Most likely this will take a few years though so maybe to you it's worth it, I don't know. Here in NY I would only go stainless steel myself.
About the installation, if you're comfortable working under your car and doing a lot of things yourself you shouldn't have a problem as the install seems pretty straight forward. If you do decide to take it to a shop you might have a little trouble finding someone to do it for you as most shops seem to not want to touch it because it's an illegal pipe.
Hope that helped a little, I'm sure someone will add a whole lot more and give you a different opinion.
Chris
About the installation, if you're comfortable working under your car and doing a lot of things yourself you shouldn't have a problem as the install seems pretty straight forward. If you do decide to take it to a shop you might have a little trouble finding someone to do it for you as most shops seem to not want to touch it because it's an illegal pipe.
Hope that helped a little, I'm sure someone will add a whole lot more and give you a different opinion.
Chris
#3
hehe....thanks a bunch CKNY
Originally posted by CKNY
well, here's the deal. If you live in an area that gets snow the stillen pipe WILL rust. The steel just will not hold up to all the snow, salt, and moisture. Most likely this will take a few years though so maybe to you it's worth it, I don't know. Here in NY I would only go stainless steel myself.
About the installation, if you're comfortable working under your car and doing a lot of things yourself you shouldn't have a problem as the install seems pretty straight forward. If you do decide to take it to a shop you might have a little trouble finding someone to do it for you as most shops seem to not want to touch it because it's an illegal pipe.
Hope that helped a little, I'm sure someone will add a whole lot more and give you a different opinion.
Chris
well, here's the deal. If you live in an area that gets snow the stillen pipe WILL rust. The steel just will not hold up to all the snow, salt, and moisture. Most likely this will take a few years though so maybe to you it's worth it, I don't know. Here in NY I would only go stainless steel myself.
About the installation, if you're comfortable working under your car and doing a lot of things yourself you shouldn't have a problem as the install seems pretty straight forward. If you do decide to take it to a shop you might have a little trouble finding someone to do it for you as most shops seem to not want to touch it because it's an illegal pipe.
Hope that helped a little, I'm sure someone will add a whole lot more and give you a different opinion.
Chris
and i just happened to live 10 minutes from Stillen too...i think i'm going to get the Stillen pipe unless someone else has a different opinion about this...
-peace
#5
Supporting Maxima.org Member
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: City of the Fallen Angel, CA
Posts: 4,728
Are you going to install the Y-pipe yourself . . .
Originally posted by irvine78
well, the thing is...i live in sunny california.
and i just happened to live 10 minutes from Stillen too...i think i'm going to get the Stillen pipe unless someone else has a different opinion about this...[/I]
well, the thing is...i live in sunny california.
and i just happened to live 10 minutes from Stillen too...i think i'm going to get the Stillen pipe unless someone else has a different opinion about this...[/I]
[Edited by y2kse on 01-01-2001 at 12:14 PM]
#6
Re: Are you going to install the Y-pipe yourself . . .
Originally posted by y2kse
or are you going to have it installed for you, irvine78? If you have it installed, who's going to do the work for you?
[Edited by y2kse on 01-01-2001 at 12:14 PM] [/I]
Originally posted by irvine78
well, the thing is...i live in sunny california.
and i just happened to live 10 minutes from Stillen too...i think i'm going to get the Stillen pipe unless someone else has a different opinion about this...
well, the thing is...i live in sunny california.
and i just happened to live 10 minutes from Stillen too...i think i'm going to get the Stillen pipe unless someone else has a different opinion about this...
[Edited by y2kse on 01-01-2001 at 12:14 PM] [/I]
#7
Supporting Maxima.org Member
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: City of the Fallen Angel, CA
Posts: 4,728
Re: Re: Are you going to install the Y-pipe yourself . . .
[QUOTE]Originally posted by irvine78
I assume you're talking about Premier Autoworks on Lambert. Have they installed a Y-pipe on a Maxima before? How much do they charge?
well....i have a friend from this forum. he lives in irvine too. so i'll probably ask him to help me with the Y-pipe. or i'm going to take my car to Primier in La Habra, CA....
#8
Re: Re: Re: Are you going to install the Y-pipe yourself . . .
[QUOTE]Originally posted by y2kse
Lambert? uh...actually....i don't know if it is in Lambert. my friend goes there often so i asked him about the shop. as far as shop's experience, they are working on cams for my friend's max(99 se-L)..and my friend said that they'll charge me like $50 for the install....which i don't think is bad at all...
-peace
Originally posted by irvine78
I assume you're talking about Premier Autoworks on Lambert. Have they installed a Y-pipe on a Maxima before? How much do they charge?
well....i have a friend from this forum. he lives in irvine too. so i'll probably ask him to help me with the Y-pipe. or i'm going to take my car to Primier in La Habra, CA....
-peace
#9
Supporting Maxima.org Member
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: City of the Fallen Angel, CA
Posts: 4,728
Re: Re: Re: Re: Are you going to install the Y-pipe yourself . . .
[QUOTE]Originally posted by irvine78
You're right. $50.00 isn't bad at all. By the way, I think I found Premier's web site. Check out:
http://www.premierautoworks.com/
Lambert? uh...actually....i don't know if it is in Lambert. my friend goes there often so i asked him about the shop. as far as shop's experience, they are working on cams for my friend's max(99 se-L)..and my friend said that they'll charge me like $50 for the install....which i don't think is bad at all...
http://www.premierautoworks.com/
#10
YUP...THAT'S IT!!
[QUOTE]Originally posted by y2kse
by the way, isn't 2.5 inch piping a bit too large for NA maxima? no?
Originally posted by irvine78
You're right. $50.00 isn't bad at all. By the way, I think I found Premier's web site. Check out:
http://www.premierautoworks.com/
Lambert? uh...actually....i don't know if it is in Lambert. my friend goes there often so i asked him about the shop. as far as shop's experience, they are working on cams for my friend's max(99 se-L)..and my friend said that they'll charge me like $50 for the install....which i don't think is bad at all...
http://www.premierautoworks.com/
#11
Supporting Maxima.org Member
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: City of the Fallen Angel, CA
Posts: 4,728
Re: YUP...THAT'S IT!!
by the way, isn't 2.5 inch piping a bit too large for NA maxima? no?
#12
2.25?
Originally posted by y2kse
by the way, isn't 2.5 inch piping a bit too large for NA maxima? no?
It works well for me, particularly at higher rpms. But I've read a couple of posts that indicate you may be better off with 2.25" if you're installing a y-pipe.
by the way, isn't 2.5 inch piping a bit too large for NA maxima? no?
i was thinking about 2" piping for my exhaust(if i get one soon enough!!).
but i guess since we have 6 cylinder engines instead of honda 4 banger....maybe larger piping's still ok.
how do you like the sound? is it loud all the time or only at WOT?
and what kind of exhaust do you have?
-peace
#13
Supporting Maxima.org Member
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: City of the Fallen Angel, CA
Posts: 4,728
Re: 2.25?
Originally posted by irvine78 hmmm....
i wonder even 2.25" are ok for NA cars. i was thinking about 2" piping for my exhaust(if i get one soon enough!!). but i guess since we have 6 cylinder engines instead of honda 4 banger....maybe larger piping's still ok. how do you like the sound? is it loud all the time or only at WOT? and what kind of exhaust do you have?
i wonder even 2.25" are ok for NA cars. i was thinking about 2" piping for my exhaust(if i get one soon enough!!). but i guess since we have 6 cylinder engines instead of honda 4 banger....maybe larger piping's still ok. how do you like the sound? is it loud all the time or only at WOT? and what kind of exhaust do you have?
My exhaust runs through a 24" Magnaflow straight-through muffler. The sound is deep and powerful . . . not at all farty. It drones a little between 2000 and 2500 rpm, but it's practically silent at cruising speeds (~3000 rpm). All in all, I'm real happy with it.
[Edited by y2kse on 01-01-2001 at 05:41 PM]
#15
Hahaha!!!!
Premier didn't have a website last time I checked. And yes, it is the one on Lambert. They have installed a Y-pipe on 1 Maxima before (not mine) and they will do it again. When I talked to Kennedy (owner), he said labor will probably be less than $50. Well, hope you're happy with your Y-pipe Irvine78. Lemme know when you get it, I can either help you put it on or I'll go with you to the shop.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Stagnet04
4th Generation Classifieds (1995-1999)
1
09-14-2015 11:28 PM