transmission impossible
#1
transmission impossible
of course nothing's impossible but i'm having a ***** of a time seperating the box from the motor. all bolts are off, have been off for the past few hours while i've been hammering screwdrivers all around the seam. it's seperated about a half inch all around but will not flippin come off. am i missing something here? please help, i really want to get it out today. everything is removed it's just the tranny all by it's lonesome subborn self.
thanks
thanks
#2
Time to break out the cuttin torch..
Look all around the trans,front,back, and check for thing that it could be getting hung up on....A good bright flash light or work light my shed some "light" on the problem..
Look all around the trans,front,back, and check for thing that it could be getting hung up on....A good bright flash light or work light my shed some "light" on the problem..
#3
i've searched all around numerous times, wiggled the thing relentlessly, whatever is sticking, it's sticking in the case, i used a flashlight to look around a while ago, even through the gap between the block and case. all 11 bolts are off, the entire perimiter of the case is detatched. maybe i'm just not strong enough or can't get the leverage to detach. i'm exhausted, been up for 24 hours now. i'll call it a day, god i miss driving my car. thanks for the reply man. it may seriously be caused by broken stuff interlocking. the clutch was giving me issues (slipping, making chainsaw sounds.) isb, bucking, grinding, inability to move to the 1-2 side of the gate sometimes, when i could fuse blows then sometimes the car will drive normal but of course with terrible grinding sounds from broken bearing and whatever else busted in there.. i dunno, we'll see. i'll yank on it some more tomorrow.
#4
did you remove both mounts and both axles already
there are some bolts on the back that are kinda hidden you have to be under the car and look up where the pas side axle goes to see them also you might want to remove the bracket that holds the shift arm to the side of the trans cause it can also get hung up
there are some bolts on the back that are kinda hidden you have to be under the car and look up where the pas side axle goes to see them also you might want to remove the bracket that holds the shift arm to the side of the trans cause it can also get hung up
#5
Vg motor right? sounds like corrosion/crusties between iron block and aluminum trans case. (electrolysis between differing metals + OR moisture) Try a LITTLE heat with a blow torch, some WD-40, and consistent and persistent pounding with a big rubber/plastic hammer. (so you don't damage the soft alum. trans case.)
#7
subs: yes, both axels are seperated. there's 11 nuts/bolts connecting the case to the engine, they are all removed as well as all mounts and shift linkage.
dillbag: it's seperated from the block at the seam about 1/2"
Phasta: it's a 5 speed
we'll see how it goes today when i'm not exhausted.
dillbag: it's seperated from the block at the seam about 1/2"
Phasta: it's a 5 speed
we'll see how it goes today when i'm not exhausted.
#9
Originally Posted by Hectic
Phasta: it's a 5 speed
Originally Posted by DanNY
i thought there were similar bolts around the flywheel too.
In that case Hectic I think the boys above are right... probably something stuck from rust or something like that. But for safety check again in bright light, and take your time. You're gonna be awful pissed off if you brake something, trust me
#13
stupid question... did you remove the starter and sick the bolts back into the tranny case so you don't lose them?
I did that a few years ago, and the starter bolts will hang up on the clutch is you threaded them all the way in. it was about 1/2" away from the engine block as well when that happened.
the other thing- are you lifting the other end of the transmission as well?
the input shaft to the tranny is a decently long shaft, and you may just need to lift the back end of the tranny up a bit while you're pulling.. the engine, resting on only its mounts, will try to tilt one way while the tranny is leaning another. this can cause a bind in there and prevent them from coming apart.
usually what I do when pulling the tranny is to stick something on the pass side of the engine bay (chunk of 2x4 works great) to keep the engine tilted toward the tranny side. this should angle the tranny down a bit and allow it to come out easier..
then I support the tranny with a jack from below and rock/pull on the tranny case until it's out.
good luck. hope that hleps.
I did that a few years ago, and the starter bolts will hang up on the clutch is you threaded them all the way in. it was about 1/2" away from the engine block as well when that happened.
the other thing- are you lifting the other end of the transmission as well?
the input shaft to the tranny is a decently long shaft, and you may just need to lift the back end of the tranny up a bit while you're pulling.. the engine, resting on only its mounts, will try to tilt one way while the tranny is leaning another. this can cause a bind in there and prevent them from coming apart.
usually what I do when pulling the tranny is to stick something on the pass side of the engine bay (chunk of 2x4 works great) to keep the engine tilted toward the tranny side. this should angle the tranny down a bit and allow it to come out easier..
then I support the tranny with a jack from below and rock/pull on the tranny case until it's out.
good luck. hope that hleps.
#14
Originally Posted by Matt93SE
the engine, resting on only its mounts, will try to tilt one way while the tranny is leaning another. this can cause a bind in there and prevent them from coming apart.
#16
Originally Posted by Matt93SE
stupid question... did you remove the starter and sick the bolts back into the tranny case so you don't lose them?
I did that a few years ago, and the starter bolts will hang up on the clutch is you threaded them all the way in. it was about 1/2" away from the engine block as well when that happened.
the other thing- are you lifting the other end of the transmission as well?
the input shaft to the tranny is a decently long shaft, and you may just need to lift the back end of the tranny up a bit while you're pulling.. the engine, resting on only its mounts, will try to tilt one way while the tranny is leaning another. this can cause a bind in there and prevent them from coming apart.
usually what I do when pulling the tranny is to stick something on the pass side of the engine bay (chunk of 2x4 works great) to keep the engine tilted toward the tranny side. this should angle the tranny down a bit and allow it to come out easier..
then I support the tranny with a jack from below and rock/pull on the tranny case until it's out.
good luck. hope that hleps.
I did that a few years ago, and the starter bolts will hang up on the clutch is you threaded them all the way in. it was about 1/2" away from the engine block as well when that happened.
the other thing- are you lifting the other end of the transmission as well?
the input shaft to the tranny is a decently long shaft, and you may just need to lift the back end of the tranny up a bit while you're pulling.. the engine, resting on only its mounts, will try to tilt one way while the tranny is leaning another. this can cause a bind in there and prevent them from coming apart.
usually what I do when pulling the tranny is to stick something on the pass side of the engine bay (chunk of 2x4 works great) to keep the engine tilted toward the tranny side. this should angle the tranny down a bit and allow it to come out easier..
then I support the tranny with a jack from below and rock/pull on the tranny case until it's out.
good luck. hope that hleps.
edit: i just checked felt inside the starter hole and there's more than enough clearance. but the operating cylinder bolts are a different story, one of them i screwed all the way back in, so it's probably that one.
#20
Originally Posted by DanNY
damn that tranny is tiny compared to the auto.
oh and you think it's a good time to buck up for a set of jack stands?
oh and you think it's a good time to buck up for a set of jack stands?
danny you should feel the weight difference
#21
hehe, did you think i was supporting the car with the stool?
it's in a lot better shape than i expected. i think i'll get away with rebuilding just the input shaft. i was expecting broken teeth and cracked gears. of course there was a lot of debris from the bearing though. time to tear down.
it's in a lot better shape than i expected. i think i'll get away with rebuilding just the input shaft. i was expecting broken teeth and cracked gears. of course there was a lot of debris from the bearing though. time to tear down.
#23
Originally Posted by Brad92SE
Oh man, that last pic is all too familiar to me. What all was wrong with the tranny, was it just the input shaft bearing, or were gears broken also?
#24
Originally Posted by Hectic
it was the cylinder bolt matt rules. scarred a tooth on the flywheel...
http://www.geocities.com/pearlmax91/trannyout.JPG
http://www.geocities.com/pearlmax91/trannyout.JPG
now I just pull those things off and stick 'em in ziplock baggies. a box of 100 baggies is only like $2. a sharpie is another $1. pull the bolts off and number the bellhousing bolts on the case and the bolt head.
tiny investment for the time and work savings.
#26
I just line the bolts up in order on my strut tower. The sharpie wore off of the tops of the bolts, although I pretty much know what goes where now like the back of my hand, sadly.
Those input shaft bearings are really annoying, hope the rebuild goes smoothly for you!
Those input shaft bearings are really annoying, hope the rebuild goes smoothly for you!
#28
thanks guys. it's probably going to be a mistake, but i'm just going to replace the broken input shaft bearing and anything else that is visibly broken. clean out the metal shavings and debris. check my clearances but not teardown any other shafts uness it's neccessary. i've got to get my car moving again soon. i'm sure my mother wants her TL back and is getting tired of me using it to deliver pizza
'Dillbag'...
'Dillbag'...
#31
Originally Posted by Hectic
thanks guys. it's probably going to be a mistake, but i'm just going to replace the broken input shaft bearing and anything else that is visibly broken. clean out the metal shavings and debris. check my clearances but not teardown any other shafts uness it's neccessary. i've got to get my car moving again soon. i'm sure my mother wants her TL back and is getting tired of me using it to deliver pizza
'Dillbag'...
'Dillbag'...
thats all you need to do and more than likely you wont need to do it again for a long time
#32
Originally Posted by kiyakerz
that pictures makes it look so easy.... *ponder* how long did it take? or will it take...
acid: you may need to read the whole thread. i seriously hope you haven't aready
subs: i should probably replace the wearable parts imo. i've never tore down a tranny before, i'm contemplating just paying a shop to rebulild the shaft(s). seems like i need several special tools. hydraulic press, pullers, ect...
#33
Originally Posted by Hectic
i'm hoping it's all uphill from here
yeah you wish
just kidding, but the passenger side axle bearing is nice isn't it? makes you wanna call Nissan up and tell them what a nice solution they came up with, right? ...not. damn I hated that the first time.
and the axle hub bolt..? first time I removed it it took me about 1 hour before giving up, then 2 hours drive and shopping better tools, then 5 minutes to remove it. proper tools are a god given gift.
after you've done this some 8 times it's not that difficult anymore though
#34
all you need is a press and an FSM
and if you dont have a press and you plan on doing work on cars in the future its a good idea to have one for wheel bearings and suspention bushing plus harborfrieght has a 12 ton for 100$ so it pays for itself pretty fast
and if you dont have a press and you plan on doing work on cars in the future its a good idea to have one for wheel bearings and suspention bushing plus harborfrieght has a 12 ton for 100$ so it pays for itself pretty fast
#35
Originally Posted by Phatsta
yeah you wish
just kidding, but the passenger side axle bearing is nice isn't it? makes you wanna call Nissan up and tell them what a nice solution they came up with, right? ...not. damn I hated that the first time.
and the axle hub bolt..? first time I removed it it took me about 1 hour before giving up, then 2 hours drive and shopping better tools, then 5 minutes to remove it. proper tools are a god given gift.
after you've done this some 8 times it's not that difficult anymore though
i learned my lesson when i tried to get my crankshaft sprocket off with manual tools a few seconds with an impact wrench and the axle bolts were off. beats a few hours trying it with a breaker bar.
subs: i see a 10 ton on their website for $160. i'm not sure what i'll do exactly. i'll probably buy the bearing and go to a shop and ask if they can press it on for $20 or something.
#37
just got back to work on it today. where's a cheap place online to order the new bearing from? brian carry them? i don't see them if he does. stealership wants $43 which isn't terrible but aren't they around $20-something at other places? it'd be nice to order new axles and bearing at the same time if anyone has a suggestion, thanks. courtesy doesn't list them either. what's you're theory cookson? hope the pic shows what you want.
#38
Originally Posted by Hectic
just got back to work on it today. where's a cheap place online to order the new bearing from? brian carry them? i don't see them if he does. stealership wants $43 which isn't terrible but aren't they around $20-something at other places? it'd be nice to order new axles and bearing at the same time if anyone has a suggestion, thanks. courtesy doesn't list them either. what's you're theory cookson? hope the pic shows what you want.
if it's just a generic looking bearing you can sometimes read the numbers on the side of them to get a bearing place to sell you better bearings or replacement ones. I've used SKF bearings before with success....(general application..not in a manual tranny)
#39
www.drivetrain.com has a bunch of parts. i've used them before and they had pretty good prices.
my theory on another reason why the input shaft bearing goes to hell is the lack of the input shaft using the pilot bushing. i was doing some mock up things with the VH45 and Z32 tranny. i couldn't get the tranny stabbed in there and decided to try out my maxima input shaft (since it was just laying in a box from the first tranny that died). it went in fine of course but i noticed a big difference between it and the Z input shaft. the Z input shaft has more metal sticking out so that it would ride in the pilot bushing.
correct me if i'm wrong, but wouldn't the lack of possibly cause some wobbling of the input shaft? nothing extremely noticable but enough for the bearings to keep dieing. it seems like that could be very likely, but i'm not positive.
i'll get some pictures of the Z tranny to show the comparison but to get an idea of what it looks like, just look at a clutch alignment tool. the tool is designed the same basic way that the input shaft of the Z32 tranny is.
edit: actually, here's a picture of what i'm talking about.
my theory on another reason why the input shaft bearing goes to hell is the lack of the input shaft using the pilot bushing. i was doing some mock up things with the VH45 and Z32 tranny. i couldn't get the tranny stabbed in there and decided to try out my maxima input shaft (since it was just laying in a box from the first tranny that died). it went in fine of course but i noticed a big difference between it and the Z input shaft. the Z input shaft has more metal sticking out so that it would ride in the pilot bushing.
correct me if i'm wrong, but wouldn't the lack of possibly cause some wobbling of the input shaft? nothing extremely noticable but enough for the bearings to keep dieing. it seems like that could be very likely, but i'm not positive.
i'll get some pictures of the Z tranny to show the comparison but to get an idea of what it looks like, just look at a clutch alignment tool. the tool is designed the same basic way that the input shaft of the Z32 tranny is.
edit: actually, here's a picture of what i'm talking about.
#40
dan: yep, complete destruction. i'm looking forward to having a healthy tranny again. i haven't been without grinding and churning sounds for 6 months. no more redlines for me. doesn't serve much of a purpose with the vg anyhow. 53-5400 tops from now on.
cook: thanks for that link, i'll check it out. lack of support i'm sure could cause stress. how did craig get the 5800 figure? was it a test performed on the vehicle or a test of the bearing only? whatever the exact cause it's some bad engineering by the tranny folks. there's always the ipt mod..i think you're actually the one who told me about that. i'm surprised you turbo guys don't do it instead of constantly replacing the bearing. money i guess. thanks again for the tips on the passenger axle. way easier hammering the axle out from the tranny end then trying to pry that bearing support apart
cook: thanks for that link, i'll check it out. lack of support i'm sure could cause stress. how did craig get the 5800 figure? was it a test performed on the vehicle or a test of the bearing only? whatever the exact cause it's some bad engineering by the tranny folks. there's always the ipt mod..i think you're actually the one who told me about that. i'm surprised you turbo guys don't do it instead of constantly replacing the bearing. money i guess. thanks again for the tips on the passenger axle. way easier hammering the axle out from the tranny end then trying to pry that bearing support apart