How much to shave off VG heads to get 10:1 Compression?
#41
Originally Posted by Grace_Imports
I am finishing my VE30DE build today and used VG30DE pistons. I have pics if anyone is interested. I will post how she runs once I am done. Generally, raising compression will raise power across the board provided you don't go overkill and everything else is right. The VE30DE chamber is a "pentroof" design which is probably the most detonation resistant. An American wedge chamber would be more detonation prone. Pentroof heads are more forgiving when raising compression than other designs. The same shape is in the SR20DE head. People bore the SR20DE from 86mm to 87mm for the VG30DE piston and get 11.0 to 1 CR. This is a common mod on the N/A SR20 cars.
#42
Originally Posted by Matt93SE
it doesnt' make the belt slack because the tensioner will simply pull it up.. but what happens is it changes the cam timing since there is physically less distance.
it's not much, but even a half degree can make a measureable difference in power. more losses than gains.
now if you had adjustable cam gears (which nobody makes for these cars), you could negate those issues.
you will also run into clearance problems with the lower intake manifold and the bolt holes and etc no lining up.
it's not much, but even a half degree can make a measureable difference in power. more losses than gains.
now if you had adjustable cam gears (which nobody makes for these cars), you could negate those issues.
you will also run into clearance problems with the lower intake manifold and the bolt holes and etc no lining up.
#44
Originally Posted by Grace_Imports
Yeah but the tensioner has a limit of how much slack it can take out. The tensioner can only move so far. Like I previously stated, I bought a reman head for a Mazda B2200 last year. The head was .006" beyond spec for resurfacing and the tensioner would not pull up the slack so the company had to send me another head. If you were able to properly tension the belt (which I don't you could with that much material removed) then you have the timing issue.
#45
I have the VE30DE longblock done and am getting the old engine ready to come out of the car. Depending on the weather and work etc. I hope to have it running this week. I will say that the engine turns fine on the stand with no clearance issues whatsover. I think that the VG30DE and VE30DE chambers are identical although I don't have the 2 side by side to compare and I have not CC'd the chambers on either. I have taken a lot of pics and I will post some soon. A lot of the pics were to document the work that I have done. I also took some side by side of the 2 different pistons. I may start another thread with a detailed list of the current mods and potential future ones maybe to get feedback from all of you guys. I bought the car not running so all of the current mods are happening at once.
#46
Originally Posted by Matt93SE
the tensioner on the VG has quite a bit of room to go assuming you're using a new OE belt.
#47
yeah, I definitely agree with you there. should be plenty of room in the belt and tensioner, but the other issues are what make it not doable..
I'd definitely like to see what you've got concocted for the VE... that's the project as soon as I get the money.
I'd definitely like to see what you've got concocted for the VE... that's the project as soon as I get the money.
#48
Originally Posted by Grace_Imports
I bought the car not running so all of the current mods are happening at once.
#49
Originally Posted by Matt93SE
now if you had adjustable cam gears (which nobody makes for these cars), you could negate those issues.
#54
I bet my helmet. THAT was not the engine how this thread started. All is market-bs if ppl cannot understand enough to specify explicitly.
Another thing missing: pics, with measured pistons showing differences, not in BMW'S, but 3gen vehicles.
Another thing missing: pics, with measured pistons showing differences, not in BMW'S, but 3gen vehicles.
#57
Wiking, We were reffering to adding VG30DE pistons to the VE30DE to raise the compression ratio to 10.5:1. It was not referring to bradsman87 but to people interested in raising compression in their VE car. BTW...referring to the Volvo B20, I have owned 3 vintage Volvos.
#58
bradsm87: If you still have the heads off the car, you should consider upgrading the exhaust studs to avoid the breakage problem later on. See my post at the bottom of this thread. http://forums.maxima.org/showthread.php?t=435603
#59
Thanks. Alot of known issues have been covered here. Let me know if you want to add to this sticky
http://forums.maxima.org/showthread.php?t=128490
http://forums.maxima.org/showthread.php?t=128490
Originally Posted by Dillbag
bradsm87: If you still have the heads off the car, you should consider upgrading the exhaust studs to avoid the breakage problem later on. See my post at the bottom of this thread. http://forums.maxima.org/showthread.php?t=435603
#60
Still the facts missing for VG30E.
- Exact minimum VG30E head height beyond FSM (=max shave)
- piston critical measures; possibilities to raise VG30E pressure
- rod critical measures; possibilities to raise VG30E pressure
- gasket critical thickness; possibilities to raise VG30E pressure
Notes:
- Manually adjusted valve angles vary tis way tat way lots of degrees. Driver cannot see any difference on produced degr fractions this shavin produces.
- Belt slack is non issue in maximaV6, Mazda >another forum.
Open VG30E issue = nobody here can deliver measured facts (but opinions):
b/c of head shape cc [THKS Mtcookson!], seems that VE30DE piston will not give any gains to VG30E, no other options known. Seems no practical way to raise VG30E pressure.
- Exact minimum VG30E head height beyond FSM (=max shave)
- piston critical measures; possibilities to raise VG30E pressure
- rod critical measures; possibilities to raise VG30E pressure
- gasket critical thickness; possibilities to raise VG30E pressure
Notes:
- Manually adjusted valve angles vary tis way tat way lots of degrees. Driver cannot see any difference on produced degr fractions this shavin produces.
- Belt slack is non issue in maximaV6, Mazda >another forum.
Open VG30E issue = nobody here can deliver measured facts (but opinions):
b/c of head shape cc [THKS Mtcookson!], seems that VE30DE piston will not give any gains to VG30E, no other options known. Seems no practical way to raise VG30E pressure.
#62
Originally Posted by mtcookson
...still searching around for some more info on the VG30E
#63
Mazda is another forum but I used the example to show what can potentially happen. I don't think people realize what a few thousandths difference can make. I have a set of VG30E heads I can dig out and CC when I get the time. I personally would not use (opinion) a VG30DE piston in a VG30E because it is a "fact" that those 2 heads have different chamber designs. It is a "fact" that most pistons are made to be compatible with the chamber they will be working with. There are companies out there that will make any piston you want if they don't have it in their invetory but you will pay.
#65
Originally Posted by Grace_Imports
Mazda is another forum but I used the example to show what can potentially happen. I don't think people realize what a few thousandths difference can make. I have a set of VG30E heads I can dig out and CC when I get the time. I personally would not use (opinion) a VG30DE piston in a VG30E because it is a "fact" that those 2 heads have different chamber designs. It is a "fact" that most pistons are made to be compatible with the chamber they will be working with. There are companies out there that will make any piston you want if they don't have it in their invetory but you will pay.
#67
Originally Posted by todamax
Grace_Imports: So? How is the project?
I have been driving it for a week...I will update the thread I started about the project. Look for "VE30DE build details" I'm no forum whiz so I don't know how to link it to this one.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
CAN-Toronto FS: Basement cleaning
knight_yyz
5th Generation Classifieds (2000-2003)
12
11-01-2015 02:34 PM
worldwiderecognized
6th Generation Maxima (2004-2008)
0
09-30-2015 02:16 PM