advancing timing...
Re: advancing timing...
Originally posted by PoLo
how is it done?
i know has to be done with the ODB-II, but just want to know how it's done.
how is it done?
i know has to be done with the ODB-II, but just want to know how it's done.
Is advanced timing dangerous for the engine?
It can promote pinging/detonation, moreso than normal, but if you don't advance it much, and use premium gas ALL the time, it may yield better performance. However, if it pings a lot (or worse, detonates) your performance will suffer as the Knock Sensor will cause the ECU to retard the timing somewhat unpredictably, and if it continues on a lot you can damage the engine.
Originally posted by 00MaxSE
Exactly how much performance gain is there from advancing your timing? Is it noticable? Is this the type of thing to do only to boosted cars or N/A?
J.
Exactly how much performance gain is there from advancing your timing? Is it noticable? Is this the type of thing to do only to boosted cars or N/A?
J.
Sloppy, do I just ask my dealer to have this done? How much does it cost?
Also, I did that mod you told me about with the tube leading air from the scoop to the intake. Did you use dryer vent tubing for yours? That's what I did.
Thanks
Also, I did that mod you told me about with the tube leading air from the scoop to the intake. Did you use dryer vent tubing for yours? That's what I did.
Thanks
It's cost is $40 to $5 at the dealer. Some dealers may turn you down for it because they say it's out of specification, but it actually is within specification for the engine. I got rejected at the first dealer I went to, but the second one had no problem with it.
Originally posted by 00MaxSE
Sloppy, do I just ask my dealer to have this done? How much does it cost?
Also, I did that mod you told me about with the tube leading air from the scoop to the intake. Did you use dryer vent tubing for yours? That's what I did.
Thanks
Sloppy, do I just ask my dealer to have this done? How much does it cost?
Also, I did that mod you told me about with the tube leading air from the scoop to the intake. Did you use dryer vent tubing for yours? That's what I did.
Thanks
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally posted by studman
If you only advance it to +17° BTDC, then no. But if you advance it more than that, it can be. Also, if you are SC/Turbo/FI, then you want your timing at normal, if not actually retarded (which the FMU/ECU would do).
If you only advance it to +17° BTDC, then no. But if you advance it more than that, it can be. Also, if you are SC/Turbo/FI, then you want your timing at normal, if not actually retarded (which the FMU/ECU would do).
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally posted by BiggD23
I remember reading that the ECU won't let you go more than 2 degrees up or down from the factory setting, which is 15° BTDC. So anything under 13° or above 17° would be rejected.
I remember reading that the ECU won't let you go more than 2 degrees up or down from the factory setting, which is 15° BTDC. So anything under 13° or above 17° would be rejected.
I had mine advanced 3 degrees... and the tech who did it for me has a 2003 Max that he also advanced 3 degrees.
=R
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally posted by MAKSYMALNY
Not true
I had mine advanced 3 degrees... and the tech who did it for me has a 2003 Max that he also advanced 3 degrees.
=R
Not true
I had mine advanced 3 degrees... and the tech who did it for me has a 2003 Max that he also advanced 3 degrees.
=R
Ok...I wish the search feature worked, so I don't have to repeat this but anywho.
First, the stock timing for a 2K1 is 15-degrees +/-5, so 20-degrees is within spec.. However, I've seen a 2K FSM say +/-2 for the same car. I'm not sure what the FSM recommends for the 2K2, but I'm sure 5-degrees is perfectly fine.
Second, the reason you can't bump the timing more then 2-3degrees before the ECU stops you is because you need to perform an IDLE AIR VOLUME LEARNING procedure after 2-3degrees, then try advancing it further. My THEORY on why this occurs is because as you advance the timing, you're also increasing the base idle, which the ECU controls by adjusting the timing so it stays in spec.. Once you modify any parameter the ECU relies on for base values such as base timing, base idle, TPS value, or MAF value far enough, you must perform an IAVL procedure, so I'm expecting that is the reason why you can't go past 2-3degrees.
Third, this ECU advance is ONLY base ignition timing, which will be overcome/outweighed by the normal advance that is added throughout the RPM band. So, you may eek out a little more power from say idle to 2000rpm, but after that the ECU has added far more advance and accounted for the base-timing change.
Fourth, I doubt this mod is very beneficial to MANUAL transmission cars, because of how we normally throttle up the RPM(also adds advance) before we engage the clutch and shift above 2000rpm. However, cruising in a higher gear with the RPM below 2000rpm could be more responsive. I think the biggest gainers from this mod are for automatic trans. cars, where you just punch it off the line.
First, the stock timing for a 2K1 is 15-degrees +/-5, so 20-degrees is within spec.. However, I've seen a 2K FSM say +/-2 for the same car. I'm not sure what the FSM recommends for the 2K2, but I'm sure 5-degrees is perfectly fine.
Second, the reason you can't bump the timing more then 2-3degrees before the ECU stops you is because you need to perform an IDLE AIR VOLUME LEARNING procedure after 2-3degrees, then try advancing it further. My THEORY on why this occurs is because as you advance the timing, you're also increasing the base idle, which the ECU controls by adjusting the timing so it stays in spec.. Once you modify any parameter the ECU relies on for base values such as base timing, base idle, TPS value, or MAF value far enough, you must perform an IAVL procedure, so I'm expecting that is the reason why you can't go past 2-3degrees.
Third, this ECU advance is ONLY base ignition timing, which will be overcome/outweighed by the normal advance that is added throughout the RPM band. So, you may eek out a little more power from say idle to 2000rpm, but after that the ECU has added far more advance and accounted for the base-timing change.
Fourth, I doubt this mod is very beneficial to MANUAL transmission cars, because of how we normally throttle up the RPM(also adds advance) before we engage the clutch and shift above 2000rpm. However, cruising in a higher gear with the RPM below 2000rpm could be more responsive. I think the biggest gainers from this mod are for automatic trans. cars, where you just punch it off the line.
Originally posted by IceY2K1
Ok...I wish the search feature worked, so I don't have to repeat this but anywho.
First, the stock timing for a 2K1 is 15-degrees +/-5, so 20-degrees is within spec.. However, I've seen a 2K FSM say +/-2 for the same car. I'm not sure what the FSM recommends for the 2K2, but I'm sure 5-degrees is perfectly fine.
Second, the reason you can't bump the timing more then 2-3degrees before the ECU stops you is because you need to perform an IDLE AIR VOLUME LEARNING procedure after 2-3degrees, then try advancing it further. My THEORY on why this occurs is because as you advance the timing, you're also increasing the base idle, which the ECU controls by adjusting the timing so it stays in spec.. Once you modify any parameter the ECU relies on for base values such as base timing, base idle, TPS value, or MAF value far enough, you must perform an IAVL procedure, so I'm expecting that is the reason why you can't go past 2-3degrees.
Third, this ECU advance is ONLY base ignition timing, which will be overcome/outweighed by the normal advance that is added throughout the RPM band. So, you may eek out a little more power from say idle to 2000rpm, but after that the ECU has added far more advance and accounted for the base-timing change.
Fourth, I doubt this mod is very beneficial to MANUAL transmission cars, because of how we normally throttle up the RPM(also adds advance) before we engage the clutch and shift above 2000rpm. However, cruising in a higher gear with the RPM below 2000rpm could be more responsive. I think the biggest gainers from this mod are for automatic trans. cars, where you just punch it off the line.
Ok...I wish the search feature worked, so I don't have to repeat this but anywho.
First, the stock timing for a 2K1 is 15-degrees +/-5, so 20-degrees is within spec.. However, I've seen a 2K FSM say +/-2 for the same car. I'm not sure what the FSM recommends for the 2K2, but I'm sure 5-degrees is perfectly fine.
Second, the reason you can't bump the timing more then 2-3degrees before the ECU stops you is because you need to perform an IDLE AIR VOLUME LEARNING procedure after 2-3degrees, then try advancing it further. My THEORY on why this occurs is because as you advance the timing, you're also increasing the base idle, which the ECU controls by adjusting the timing so it stays in spec.. Once you modify any parameter the ECU relies on for base values such as base timing, base idle, TPS value, or MAF value far enough, you must perform an IAVL procedure, so I'm expecting that is the reason why you can't go past 2-3degrees.
Third, this ECU advance is ONLY base ignition timing, which will be overcome/outweighed by the normal advance that is added throughout the RPM band. So, you may eek out a little more power from say idle to 2000rpm, but after that the ECU has added far more advance and accounted for the base-timing change.
Fourth, I doubt this mod is very beneficial to MANUAL transmission cars, because of how we normally throttle up the RPM(also adds advance) before we engage the clutch and shift above 2000rpm. However, cruising in a higher gear with the RPM below 2000rpm could be more responsive. I think the biggest gainers from this mod are for automatic trans. cars, where you just punch it off the line.
Joined: Sep 2000
Posts: 4,728
From: City of the Fallen Angel, CA
FWIW, I have a manual tranny in my 2K SE and I definitely feel an improvement in low-end torque with my timing advance increased to 17 degrees BTDC. It's not a night and day difference, of course. But any mod that doesn't cost too much and improves low end performance on the 3.0L engine is worth it AFAIC.
Originally posted by y2kse
FWIW, I have a manual tranny in my 2K SE and I definitely feel an improvement in low-end torque with my timing advance increased to 17 degrees BTDC. It's not a night and day difference, of course. But any mod that doesn't cost too much and improves low end performance on the 3.0L engine is worth it AFAIC.
FWIW, I have a manual tranny in my 2K SE and I definitely feel an improvement in low-end torque with my timing advance increased to 17 degrees BTDC. It's not a night and day difference, of course. But any mod that doesn't cost too much and improves low end performance on the 3.0L engine is worth it AFAIC.
If you advance your base timing from 10 BTDC to 13 BTDC, you just moved the whole timing curve up my 3 degrees from idle to redline. Maybe things are different with the Maxima, I am not sure.
--Ray
Originally posted by raynist
Are we talking about advancing the base timing +2 degrees? From what I know about other cars I have worked on, advancing the base timing advances the timing that amount through the whole rev range barring any timing retard by an aftermarket ignition, or a knock sensor.
If you advance your base timing from 10 BTDC to 13 BTDC, you just moved the whole timing curve up my 3 degrees from idle to redline. Maybe things are different with the Maxima, I am not sure.
--Ray
Are we talking about advancing the base timing +2 degrees? From what I know about other cars I have worked on, advancing the base timing advances the timing that amount through the whole rev range barring any timing retard by an aftermarket ignition, or a knock sensor.
If you advance your base timing from 10 BTDC to 13 BTDC, you just moved the whole timing curve up my 3 degrees from idle to redline. Maybe things are different with the Maxima, I am not sure.
--Ray
Definitely NOT for distributorLESS ignition systems.
Got dyno?
Originally posted by y2kse
FWIW, I have a manual tranny in my 2K SE and I definitely feel an improvement in low-end torque with my timing advance increased to 17 degrees BTDC. It's not a night and day difference, of course. But any mod that doesn't cost too much and improves low end performance on the 3.0L engine is worth it AFAIC.
FWIW, I have a manual tranny in my 2K SE and I definitely feel an improvement in low-end torque with my timing advance increased to 17 degrees BTDC. It's not a night and day difference, of course. But any mod that doesn't cost too much and improves low end performance on the 3.0L engine is worth it AFAIC.
I'm not saying don't do it just for the heck of it though.
Originally posted by studman
If you only advance it to +17° BTDC, then no. But if you advance it more than that, it can be. Also, if you are SC/Turbo/FI, then you want your timing at normal, if not actually retarded (which the FMU/ECU would do).
If you only advance it to +17° BTDC, then no. But if you advance it more than that, it can be. Also, if you are SC/Turbo/FI, then you want your timing at normal, if not actually retarded (which the FMU/ECU would do).
EDIT- Doh! I should have read the entire thread. Sorry to double post Icy!
Originally posted by y2kse
FWIW, I have a manual tranny in my 2K SE and I definitely feel an improvement in low-end torque with my timing advance increased to 17 degrees BTDC. It's not a night and day difference, of course. But any mod that doesn't cost too much and improves low end performance on the 3.0L engine is worth it AFAIC.
FWIW, I have a manual tranny in my 2K SE and I definitely feel an improvement in low-end torque with my timing advance increased to 17 degrees BTDC. It's not a night and day difference, of course. But any mod that doesn't cost too much and improves low end performance on the 3.0L engine is worth it AFAIC.
Bryan
Originally posted by IceY2K1
That's only for mechanical vacuum advance systems.
Definitely NOT for distributorLESS ignition systems.
That's only for mechanical vacuum advance systems.
Definitely NOT for distributorLESS ignition systems.
--Ray
Joined: Sep 2000
Posts: 4,728
From: City of the Fallen Angel, CA
Re: Got dyno?
Originally posted by IceY2K1
Butt dynos don't hold water on these small differences IMO.
I'm not saying don't do it just for the heck of it though.
Butt dynos don't hold water on these small differences IMO.
I'm not saying don't do it just for the heck of it though.
Joined: Sep 2000
Posts: 4,728
From: City of the Fallen Angel, CA
Originally posted by h2kFrosty
FWIW and AFAIC??? You abbreviate whole sentences. :P
Bryan
FWIW and AFAIC??? You abbreviate whole sentences. :P
Bryan
Re: Re: Got dyno?
Originally posted by y2kse
I understand your point, Ice. But most who have had their timing advanced say that they can feel a difference, and I'm one of them. Inaccuracies of butt dynos notwithstanding, I agree that those who are interested should do it for the heck of it. Chances are, they'll like it too even if the performance increase doesn't really count.
I understand your point, Ice. But most who have had their timing advanced say that they can feel a difference, and I'm one of them. Inaccuracies of butt dynos notwithstanding, I agree that those who are interested should do it for the heck of it. Chances are, they'll like it too even if the performance increase doesn't really count.
Originally posted by IceY2K1
Edited..
I've only worked on vacuum advanced mechanical distributors.
Edited..
I've only worked on vacuum advanced mechanical distributors.
Joined: Sep 2000
Posts: 4,728
From: City of the Fallen Angel, CA
Re: Re: Re: Got dyno?
Originally posted by IceY2K1
Agreed...too many people claim it makes a difference for me to easily discount it as the placebo effect. It can't hurt UNLESS you get detonation, which is unlikely so why not if it's not to much $$$$.
Agreed...too many people claim it makes a difference for me to easily discount it as the placebo effect. It can't hurt UNLESS you get detonation, which is unlikely so why not if it's not to much $$$$.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Got dyno?
Originally posted by y2kse
Unlikely, but not impossible. I do, in fact, experience a little low rpm detonation in hot weather or when I heat soak my engine. I won't take the time to discuss why that may be happening, although I have my hunches. But the way I get around it is by adding 1 gallon of 100 octane gasoline to every 8 gallons of 91 octane I pour in the tank. (I'm in California, and all we can get here is crap 91 octane gas.) Doing that increases my overall octane rating to 92 and puts an end to the detonation no matter how high the temperature rises.
Unlikely, but not impossible. I do, in fact, experience a little low rpm detonation in hot weather or when I heat soak my engine. I won't take the time to discuss why that may be happening, although I have my hunches. But the way I get around it is by adding 1 gallon of 100 octane gasoline to every 8 gallons of 91 octane I pour in the tank. (I'm in California, and all we can get here is crap 91 octane gas.) Doing that increases my overall octane rating to 92 and puts an end to the detonation no matter how high the temperature rises.
It would be interesting to see if the ECU is retarding your timing to counter the detonation. However, if that's only when it occurs, I wouldn't worry. The ECU won't allow enough to be damaging.
The extra octane helps keep some of the power you normally have when it's not so hot out.
First of all...this thread is AWESOME. Most informative one I've read in a while.
Pardon my ignorance, but what is pre-detonation? In other words, if I had the timing advanced too high, this is something I would immediately notice and ask to have it re-adjusted? Is it just the opposite of knocking? I'm mostly interested that if I had the timing advanced and didn't like it for some reason, that I could be reasonable assured that a dealership could reverse it back to normal without having to take the car back a bazillion times and so on and so forth.
Tony
Pardon my ignorance, but what is pre-detonation? In other words, if I had the timing advanced too high, this is something I would immediately notice and ask to have it re-adjusted? Is it just the opposite of knocking? I'm mostly interested that if I had the timing advanced and didn't like it for some reason, that I could be reasonable assured that a dealership could reverse it back to normal without having to take the car back a bazillion times and so on and so forth.
Tony
Originally posted by Tony Fernandes
First of all...this thread is AWESOME. Most informative one I've read in a while.
Pardon my ignorance, but what is pre-detonation? In other words, if I had the timing advanced too high, this is something I would immediately notice and ask to have it re-adjusted? Is it just the opposite of knocking? I'm mostly interested that if I had the timing advanced and didn't like it for some reason, that I could be reasonable assured that a dealership could reverse it back to normal without having to take the car back a bazillion times and so on and so forth.
Tony
First of all...this thread is AWESOME. Most informative one I've read in a while.
Pardon my ignorance, but what is pre-detonation? In other words, if I had the timing advanced too high, this is something I would immediately notice and ask to have it re-adjusted? Is it just the opposite of knocking? I'm mostly interested that if I had the timing advanced and didn't like it for some reason, that I could be reasonable assured that a dealership could reverse it back to normal without having to take the car back a bazillion times and so on and so forth.
Tony
Pre-ignition will destroy the motor in seconds.
Originally posted by IceY2K1
There is no such thing as "pre-detonation". It's either detonation or pre-ignition. Detonation is analogous(sp?) to pinging or knocking and depending on engine design, can occur for long periods of time without serious damage.
Pre-ignition will destroy the motor in seconds.
There is no such thing as "pre-detonation". It's either detonation or pre-ignition. Detonation is analogous(sp?) to pinging or knocking and depending on engine design, can occur for long periods of time without serious damage.
Pre-ignition will destroy the motor in seconds.
Tony
Tony
Originally posted by Tony Fernandes
First of all...this thread is AWESOME. Most informative one I've read in a while.
Pardon my ignorance, but what is pre-detonation? In other words, if I had the timing advanced too high, this is something I would immediately notice and ask to have it re-adjusted? Is it just the opposite of knocking? I'm mostly interested that if I had the timing advanced and didn't like it for some reason, that I could be reasonable assured that a dealership could reverse it back to normal without having to take the car back a bazillion times and so on and so forth.
Tony
First of all...this thread is AWESOME. Most informative one I've read in a while.
Pardon my ignorance, but what is pre-detonation? In other words, if I had the timing advanced too high, this is something I would immediately notice and ask to have it re-adjusted? Is it just the opposite of knocking? I'm mostly interested that if I had the timing advanced and didn't like it for some reason, that I could be reasonable assured that a dealership could reverse it back to normal without having to take the car back a bazillion times and so on and so forth.
Tony
Engine Basics: Detonation and Pre-Ignition
thats a crazy article.........
Heres my 2cents.
i had my timing advanced by Nissan 2 degrees, using their Consult scan tool, so far they r the only scan tool with reflashing programs for our cars. i also made 2 trips to the dragstrip since, and have seen my MPH go up just a bit....
The theory is that the more timing advance u can get, without detonation, the more power u will produce, but the problem ur vq's have, is that we have some overactive knock senosrs (A good safety measure), so unless ur runnin in Ideal conditions with high octane gas, u won't see that few extra hp u CAN gain....
U guys may know this, but the most they can reset the timing with the scan tool is 3 Degrees off of factory base timing, in my case 15 degrees btdc...........
I'll shut up now
Heres my 2cents.
i had my timing advanced by Nissan 2 degrees, using their Consult scan tool, so far they r the only scan tool with reflashing programs for our cars. i also made 2 trips to the dragstrip since, and have seen my MPH go up just a bit....
The theory is that the more timing advance u can get, without detonation, the more power u will produce, but the problem ur vq's have, is that we have some overactive knock senosrs (A good safety measure), so unless ur runnin in Ideal conditions with high octane gas, u won't see that few extra hp u CAN gain....
U guys may know this, but the most they can reset the timing with the scan tool is 3 Degrees off of factory base timing, in my case 15 degrees btdc...........
I'll shut up now
yea, i saw page one, maybe i didn't read it too well, but nobody mentioned what the limits of the scan tool...since the factory only lets u modify timing plus or minus 3 degress.......
Yea....i thought the advance slighty helped, but then again...... along with my buddy, were tryin to setup a driver system for my Variable intake cams,, maybe that will help me more.......
Yea....i thought the advance slighty helped, but then again...... along with my buddy, were tryin to setup a driver system for my Variable intake cams,, maybe that will help me more.......
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
BPuff57
Advanced Suspension, Chassis, and Braking
33
Apr 16, 2020 05:15 AM
magiconthetire
Audio and Electronics
2
Oct 26, 2015 09:03 PM




