ACTUAL Performance Gains
ACTUAL Performance Gains
On my 2001 SE, I had done some intake and exhaust enhancements, and while it sounded better and "felt better", I never really quantified the change.
On my 11, I would of course like to get REAL wheel HP gains, that are effective and worthwhile. I don't want to spend 200-300 bucks for 3 HP.
The BOPs interest me, as does some intake work.
What is the best bang-for-the-buck combo out there with ACTUAL DYNO info, not just butt-dyno...
On my 11, I would of course like to get REAL wheel HP gains, that are effective and worthwhile. I don't want to spend 200-300 bucks for 3 HP.
The BOPs interest me, as does some intake work.
What is the best bang-for-the-buck combo out there with ACTUAL DYNO info, not just butt-dyno...
you cant dyno the CVT using an RPM dyno because it forcibly goes into the next gear aroudn 6200-6400 RPMs so it cant hold a steady gear for an accurate dyno test.
I've heard you can remove the traction control relay to get it working, or you can dyno using a MPH dyno but other than that I haven't heard any possibilities.
if yall wanna chip in for a dyno ill go get it done but other than that i havent cared enough to go test it. pulls harder - stats wont change my mind on that.
I've heard you can remove the traction control relay to get it working, or you can dyno using a MPH dyno but other than that I haven't heard any possibilities.
if yall wanna chip in for a dyno ill go get it done but other than that i havent cared enough to go test it. pulls harder - stats wont change my mind on that.
The issue is with the CVT, I did a Dyno run and posted the results on this board last year. If you look at CVT Dyno runs you'll see the data jumping up and down as the CVT changes the gear ratios as the RPM's climb, it's impossible to ascertain the results and come up with a solid conclusion of course that's my opinion, we have a vendor on this board that thinks otherwise.
With that said I think the best measure is to use a smartphone app that can measure accurate or in our case accurate enough 0-60 and 1/4 mile times. www.dynolicious is one such app, g-tac is another (http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/g-tac/id285540401?mt=8) and many others are available. This has proven to be very accurate and won't break the bank like a vbox system would (http://www.vboxusa.com/products.php#vb20sl3) If you want to be accurate you also need to make sure the elevation and air temps are close to the same for every test and make sure you post those variables with each test. Some apps even take those variables into account just like a real dyno.
With that said I think the best measure is to use a smartphone app that can measure accurate or in our case accurate enough 0-60 and 1/4 mile times. www.dynolicious is one such app, g-tac is another (http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/g-tac/id285540401?mt=8) and many others are available. This has proven to be very accurate and won't break the bank like a vbox system would (http://www.vboxusa.com/products.php#vb20sl3) If you want to be accurate you also need to make sure the elevation and air temps are close to the same for every test and make sure you post those variables with each test. Some apps even take those variables into account just like a real dyno.
Nah you'd have to rely on what others have posted with bone stock. Best I saw was 13.9 I think or somethin' like that. I know it's won't be as accurate as we need but really the manufacturers should be doing before and after runs with their parts and posting up 1/4 mile times if they can't dyno it.
Nah you'd have to rely on what others have posted with bone stock. Best I saw was 13.9 I think or somethin' like that. I know it's won't be as accurate as we need but really the manufacturers should be doing before and after runs with their parts and posting up 1/4 mile times if they can't dyno it.
This is what I am worried about. Marketing / Image versus Reality.
eg.: "Gain 10 HP with this air filter!"
Seriously, if that was so easy and realistic, it would be dumb for the manufacturer not to put in things like that as options at purchase time. Unless the gain is not that great in strict testing.
No use spending money for a "maybe" that might shave a couple 10ths off. Or worse, screw up low end or top end to make the mid-range feel better, but actually slow the car down.
eg.: "Gain 10 HP with this air filter!"
Seriously, if that was so easy and realistic, it would be dumb for the manufacturer not to put in things like that as options at purchase time. Unless the gain is not that great in strict testing.
No use spending money for a "maybe" that might shave a couple 10ths off. Or worse, screw up low end or top end to make the mid-range feel better, but actually slow the car down.
Only real way to know is to hit the track in similar 50-55* temps like I ran in last year
True true, how much heavier are they though? Also some parts are lighter than OEM like the Racingline sway and Y pipe. We def need a proper tune to take full advantage of these.
With weight in mind my sub sure isn't helping me. When I go to capital raceway I'ma take out my sub and back seat before i go to help offset any weight changes
With weight in mind my sub sure isn't helping me. When I go to capital raceway I'ma take out my sub and back seat before i go to help offset any weight changes
I’d like to address the original question with some things I was told by a local performance shop owner who’s been in the business for a while. He said these cars are so well designed and built that they are already pretty peaked out in engine performance. He also told me that Nissan encrypts its ECU programming so it’s difficult to make changes to the software. That being said he told me the following:
The car has a CAI and expected it was tuned to more than adequately supply the engine with air. Even if you did change it, he said he wouldn’t be able to tune the ECU to deal with a change in airflow. This is me talking now—it seems we’re left with trying to keep the intake pathway as cool as possible which would lead to insulation or trying to adjust air movement in the engine compartment to keep the intake path as cool as possible. My suspicion is this is moot once the car is moving.
The engine could deal with headers and good exhaust system. He didn’t give an idea of the gain you’d get from it. The CBE system vendors seem to think you can get 10-15 hp gains—not much IMO for $800+. At that point the rationale for a CBE is more personal and sound preference oriented.
That leaves us with saving on weight and power robbers. This makes me look at wheel/tire weight, tire size (diameter of the front tire), smaller pulley wheels, etc.
Finally – I’m not clear on what the Break Out Plates are doing. The values being replaced are there for a reason; is it fuel economy, controlling engine spin-down from off throttle? What do you get from the BOP mod?
The car has a CAI and expected it was tuned to more than adequately supply the engine with air. Even if you did change it, he said he wouldn’t be able to tune the ECU to deal with a change in airflow. This is me talking now—it seems we’re left with trying to keep the intake pathway as cool as possible which would lead to insulation or trying to adjust air movement in the engine compartment to keep the intake path as cool as possible. My suspicion is this is moot once the car is moving.
The engine could deal with headers and good exhaust system. He didn’t give an idea of the gain you’d get from it. The CBE system vendors seem to think you can get 10-15 hp gains—not much IMO for $800+. At that point the rationale for a CBE is more personal and sound preference oriented.
That leaves us with saving on weight and power robbers. This makes me look at wheel/tire weight, tire size (diameter of the front tire), smaller pulley wheels, etc.
Finally – I’m not clear on what the Break Out Plates are doing. The values being replaced are there for a reason; is it fuel economy, controlling engine spin-down from off throttle? What do you get from the BOP mod?
I’d like to address the original question with some things I was told by a local performance shop owner who’s been in the business for a while. He said these cars are so well designed and built that they are already pretty peaked out in engine performance. He also told me that Nissan encrypts its ECU programming so it’s difficult to make changes to the software. That being said he told me the following:
The car has a CAI and expected it was tuned to more than adequately supply the engine with air. Even if you did change it, he said he wouldn’t be able to tune the ECU to deal with a change in airflow. This is me talking now—it seems we’re left with trying to keep the intake pathway as cool as possible which would lead to insulation or trying to adjust air movement in the engine compartment to keep the intake path as cool as possible. My suspicion is this is moot once the car is moving.
The engine could deal with headers and good exhaust system. He didn’t give an idea of the gain you’d get from it. The CBE system vendors seem to think you can get 10-15 hp gains—not much IMO for $800+. At that point the rationale for a CBE is more personal and sound preference oriented.
That leaves us with saving on weight and power robbers. This makes me look at wheel/tire weight, tire size (diameter of the front tire), smaller pulley wheels, etc.
Finally – I’m not clear on what the Break Out Plates are doing. The values being replaced are there for a reason; is it fuel economy, controlling engine spin-down from off throttle? What do you get from the BOP mod?
The car has a CAI and expected it was tuned to more than adequately supply the engine with air. Even if you did change it, he said he wouldn’t be able to tune the ECU to deal with a change in airflow. This is me talking now—it seems we’re left with trying to keep the intake pathway as cool as possible which would lead to insulation or trying to adjust air movement in the engine compartment to keep the intake path as cool as possible. My suspicion is this is moot once the car is moving.
The engine could deal with headers and good exhaust system. He didn’t give an idea of the gain you’d get from it. The CBE system vendors seem to think you can get 10-15 hp gains—not much IMO for $800+. At that point the rationale for a CBE is more personal and sound preference oriented.
That leaves us with saving on weight and power robbers. This makes me look at wheel/tire weight, tire size (diameter of the front tire), smaller pulley wheels, etc.
Finally – I’m not clear on what the Break Out Plates are doing. The values being replaced are there for a reason; is it fuel economy, controlling engine spin-down from off throttle? What do you get from the BOP mod?
Being FWD, 350 hp would probably overwhelm the tranny and create a torque-steering monster at low speed and WOT.
What I would like would be a supercharger that would give some boost but not really hit until over a certain speed, to tame the torque steer. 0-60 is not as important to me anymore as is passing power and power reserve at hwy speed.
ETA: NISMO needs to bring out ECU programs for our cars.
Loll I gave up on performance for this car, in stock form its perfect for me, I think of it more as a luxury sedan. I no longer believe in CBE's, Intakes and such for this car. Savin the mod money for my next ride, until then Ill cruise comfortably and in style in my Max!
We're doing intake/plenum spacers next and will be posting up dyno and intake temps before/after. SG may have given up on the VQ but there's a whole lot of us who haven't. You guys are right that without a proper tune these bolt-ons aren't doing what they really could be, we did buy tuners after all..check out UpRev
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
BPuff57
Advanced Suspension, Chassis, and Braking
33
Apr 16, 2020 05:15 AM



