View Poll Results: Do or have you had an engine knock in park at warm idle on your 2009-13 Maxima
Voters: 239. You may not vote on this poll
Buyer Beware, 2009 - 2013 Factory Bearing Problems
So a long block replacement does not warrant an extended warranty but the shortblock replacements do... This seems to back up my theory of Nissan pawning off known faulty short blocks (the knock will reoccur) and offering a warranty in hopes the short block will pacify the owners until the warranty runs out. This also coincides with short blocks being on back order immediately followed by the start of long block replacements. Use up all of the faulty short blocks and offer a warranty with them, then switch to (hopefully) fixed/updated long blocks and offer no warranty.
So noble of you Nissan...
So noble of you Nissan...
Definition: Short Block vs Long Block
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://www.hondashowoff.com/forums/s...ad.php?p=87233
You've probably heard the terms "short block" and "long block" used in reference to automotive engines. The terms are sometimes mistakenly used to refer to engine swap packages, with "short block" meaning just the engine, and "long block" meaning a complete motor swap package (engine, transmission, ecu, etc.). Using the terms in this manner is incorrect and should be avoided.
Now that we've dispelled the incorrect usage of the terms, let's move on to the true definitions:
A Short Block can be defined as the engine block only. This would include the block casting, pistons, rods, and crank, etc., minus the head. A short block is basically the bottom end of a motor.
A Long Block can be defined as a complete motor assembly, i.e. the short block plus the head. A long block may also include some of the motor's accessories, such as the intake and exhaust manifolds, throttle body, fuel rail and injectors, distributor, alternator, intake tubing and filter box, etc.
If you purchase a long block to install in your project car, you will also need to secure a compatible transmission and ECU, any of the above-mentioned accessories that are not present, plus various other parts (mounts, wiring harnesses, axles, shift linkages, sensors, etc.) to make the swap work.
If you purchase a short block, you will need everything mentioned above plus a compatible cylinder head to make the motor swap complete
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://www.hondashowoff.com/forums/s...ad.php?p=87233
You've probably heard the terms "short block" and "long block" used in reference to automotive engines. The terms are sometimes mistakenly used to refer to engine swap packages, with "short block" meaning just the engine, and "long block" meaning a complete motor swap package (engine, transmission, ecu, etc.). Using the terms in this manner is incorrect and should be avoided.
Now that we've dispelled the incorrect usage of the terms, let's move on to the true definitions:
A Short Block can be defined as the engine block only. This would include the block casting, pistons, rods, and crank, etc., minus the head. A short block is basically the bottom end of a motor.
A Long Block can be defined as a complete motor assembly, i.e. the short block plus the head. A long block may also include some of the motor's accessories, such as the intake and exhaust manifolds, throttle body, fuel rail and injectors, distributor, alternator, intake tubing and filter box, etc.
If you purchase a long block to install in your project car, you will also need to secure a compatible transmission and ECU, any of the above-mentioned accessories that are not present, plus various other parts (mounts, wiring harnesses, axles, shift linkages, sensors, etc.) to make the swap work.
If you purchase a short block, you will need everything mentioned above plus a compatible cylinder head to make the motor swap complete
Just to be clear that is just a GUESS. I really have nothing to base it on other than the motor has some miles on it.
As far as 2014's being fine, I would only be guessing but I do know 2013's assembled after the TSB had the bearing knock .Also Kawowski had his short block replaced well after the TSB was released and his new motor had the same issue.
Is it fixed for 2014 , only time will tell.
Last edited by 13Maximasv; Dec 8, 2013 at 12:07 PM.
Originally Posted by Nopike View Post
The OP, 13Maximasv, seems to feel that if the vehicle makes it to 30K miles without an issue, it may be OK.
I stand corrected.
I'm also hearing scary things about the CVT not lasting and how expensive they are to replace. My 98SE has 15 years and 133K miles without any major issues. I was hoping for the same reliability out the 7th gen.
Maybe I'll go with the G37 like 13Maximasv. The all wheel drive lets you tear around turns and the drivetrain seems to be much less of a concern than with the Maxima.
The OP, 13Maximasv, seems to feel that if the vehicle makes it to 30K miles without an issue, it may be OK.
I stand corrected.
I'm also hearing scary things about the CVT not lasting and how expensive they are to replace. My 98SE has 15 years and 133K miles without any major issues. I was hoping for the same reliability out the 7th gen.
Maybe I'll go with the G37 like 13Maximasv. The all wheel drive lets you tear around turns and the drivetrain seems to be much less of a concern than with the Maxima.
Last edited by Nopike; Dec 7, 2013 at 07:06 PM.
In 16 years it never had any issue besides brakes, tires, battery. all expected.
I bought the Maxima without researching possible problems thinking it would be the same rock and I'm sure some are.
As an American worker it hurts me to even think these problems could be cause by the car being built here vs Japan. My mom and dad have a couple of 5th gens that are also great.
Last edited by 13Maximasv; Dec 8, 2013 at 01:30 PM.
Corporations always try to shave costs so it's more likely inferior parts just as much as the workmanship
I doubt our 7th gens will have stories like this:
http://forums.maxima.org/5th-generat...-achieved.html
http://forums.maxima.org/5th-generat...-achieved.html
I doubt our 7th gens will have stories like this: http://forums.maxima.org/5th-generat...-achieved.html
I think I have the bearing problem on my car as well, but I'm not sure. I've heard the knocking sound twice in the past week. What is weird is that sometimes it is there and sometimes it is not. Once I was just inside the car and opened the window and I could hear a clear knocking from the front of the car but I didn't go check. Today, as I was walking away from my car with the engine on, I could hear a clear knocking from about 5 meters away. So I opened the hood and there was definite knock. After I heard the knock, I shut off the engine and went shopping for a while, came back and drove it for about 15minutes and I couldn't hear the sound anymore. Is the knocking sound suppose to be consistent or it could happen randomly?
Take it to the dealer you have bearing knock and it's lower so depending on load it will sound different until it wears out all the way around and it doesn't go away . Bring it in now hopefully you will be under warranty .
I think this bearing issue is the same since 94 when I started working for Nissan, some of these problems never go away, nothing more then weak spots in the design, combined with a ton of variables and add in some luck, who knows why some cars break and others run forever.
If you bought the car new and have the issue that sucks, if you bought it used, then good luck cause ppl beat the **** out of cars
I stopped reading the forums cause you go from enjoying your car to, looking for a problem to pop up
If you bought the car new and have the issue that sucks, if you bought it used, then good luck cause ppl beat the **** out of cars

I stopped reading the forums cause you go from enjoying your car to, looking for a problem to pop up
I finally dropped my 2010 of this morning and got Sentra as a loaner... The service manager came out and they did verify that there is a knock and they will proceed with stripping down the motor for closer observation and take it up with NISSAN...
The 25 year Nissan Master Tech is who go the job
The 25 year Nissan Master Tech is who go the job
I finally dropped my 2010 of this morning and got Sentra as a loaner... The service manager came out and they did verify that there is a knock and they will proceed with stripping down the motor for closer observation and take it up with NISSAN...
The 25 year Nissan Master Tech is who go the job
The 25 year Nissan Master Tech is who go the job
New bearing or new short/long block ?
Bearing Knock
So today as we pulled into our garage I told my wife we were going to listen for the knocking sound. The car was warm, in park and when she opened the passenger door, we both could hear the knock with the hood closed. Opened the hood and the sound was very noticeable on the passenger end of the engine. Totally different from the rhythmic clicking of the lifters and emission devices.
2013 SV purchased in July - just hit 4100 miles.
Tuesday I'll start the battle with Nissan since the TSB only covers up to 2012 models.
Forutnately I've been following this thread very intently and maybe I've learned from your experiences. Unfortunately, I didn't find this thread before we bought the car.
NOT HAPPY - we had our choice of vehicles to purchase and I convinced my wife to get the Maxima.
2013 SV purchased in July - just hit 4100 miles.
Tuesday I'll start the battle with Nissan since the TSB only covers up to 2012 models.
Forutnately I've been following this thread very intently and maybe I've learned from your experiences. Unfortunately, I didn't find this thread before we bought the car.
NOT HAPPY - we had our choice of vehicles to purchase and I convinced my wife to get the Maxima.
So today as we pulled into our garage I told my wife we were going to listen for the knocking sound. The car was warm, in park and when she opened the passenger door, we both could hear the knock with the hood closed. Opened the hood and the sound was very noticeable on the passenger end of the engine. Totally different from the rhythmic clicking of the lifters and emission devices.
2013 SV purchased in July - just hit 4100 miles.
Tuesday I'll start the battle with Nissan since the TSB only covers up to 2012 models.
Forutnately I've been following this thread very intently and maybe I've learned from your experiences. Unfortunately, I didn't find this thread before we bought the car.
NOT HAPPY - we had our choice of vehicles to purchase and I convinced my wife to get the Maxima.
2013 SV purchased in July - just hit 4100 miles.
Tuesday I'll start the battle with Nissan since the TSB only covers up to 2012 models.
Forutnately I've been following this thread very intently and maybe I've learned from your experiences. Unfortunately, I didn't find this thread before we bought the car.
NOT HAPPY - we had our choice of vehicles to purchase and I convinced my wife to get the Maxima.
BTW, Mr DETECTIVE both of those users joined this forum months BEFORE I started this thread or even knew MY CAR had a bearing knock..................I guess I knew I would need some fake logins down the road
I STRONGLY encourage the mods to post the IP address' where all these posts originated from to show SHOOK that he/she s 100% wrong !
Last edited by 13Maximasv; Jan 14, 2014 at 11:56 AM.
This is going in the wrong direction.... Its a real matter, if it wasn't for this thread I would have not known that the noise was abnormal
We should just ignore those who are offended
We should just ignore those who are offended




















