Stillen or Cattman Y-Pipe?
08-31-2000, 01:41 PM
#1
I'm going to get a y-pipe within the next two months and I wanted some opinions? How much is each, pros and cons of each, and any experience with either y-pipe. Also, how much would it cost to get installed?
08-31-2000, 03:16 PM
#2
Y-pipes
I have a Cattman Jet-Hot coated y-pipe on my 96 Maxima and I like it very much. I have not had any problems with my Maxima after I put on the y-pipe. The ceramic coated pipes that Cattman is putting out now would be the way to go as I have heard that some people have had problems with Stillens unit. Cattman has a good reputation about him in that he will try to fix a problem to the best of his ability if there is something wrogn with his product. Good man and good products. I think that Stillen's y-pipe might be less than Cattmans but their service is really the pits from what some people say. Don't take my word for it keep asking around. I have never had any problems with Stillens products (FSTB, RSB, Greddy cat-back) so I have only good things to say about them. Just my .02
08-31-2000, 03:31 PM
#3
Guest
Posts: n/a
CATTMAN, CATTMAN
I had a Stillen first, and it cost about 50 less I think. I had problems fitting it correctly, then when it did fit I had buzzing in the exhaust. As soon as I bought the cattman, the buzzing went away, and it fit perfectly into place. The cattman pipe seems like it gives better HP to, but it could just be me tired of Stillen. Their service is the pits! I have a Stillen fstb and B-pipe. I got rid of thier y-pipe and muffler. Sour grapes! Anyway...I would suggest any cattman product over any Stillen product
08-31-2000, 04:10 PM
#4
Not DAVEB the parts guy
Join Date: Aug 2000
Posts: 8,555
Very happy with my Stillen Y-pipe..
I stayed away from Cattman because there have been lots of problems with his Y-pipes. I keep hearing about the problems have been solved and then you read about coatings coming off, the y-pipe hitting sub-frames, ill fitment, etc.
The Stillen Y-pipe might be built out of lower quality materials, but it lasts. Mine has been flawless for about a year now. No rust even though our winters are full of salty slush.
Dave
The Stillen Y-pipe might be built out of lower quality materials, but it lasts. Mine has been flawless for about a year now. No rust even though our winters are full of salty slush.
Dave
08-31-2000, 05:06 PM
#7
Donating Maxima.org Member
Join Date: Aug 2000
Posts: 867
one little trick.. i was going to get the stillen all set to buy it then i called them, guess what back order.. whats new this is stillen.. so i called cattman's 800# and had one shipped same day.. i guess of the 2 cattman is easier to get especially since his are in stock..
09-01-2000, 05:44 AM
#8
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2000
Posts: 333
On the stillen y-pipe
I just ordered mine about 2 1/2 weeks ago through got rice? It was sent to me and it didn't fit. I think there is a problem with a batch of stillen y-pipes not joining together properly. So be forewarned that neither product is perfect. Which one is better is also debateble.
09-01-2000, 05:47 AM
#9
Donating Maxima.org Member
Join Date: Aug 2000
Posts: 1,530
Cattman SS Y-pipe
I've had mine for close to a year now and I absolutely love it. No fitment problem, no weird noises -- nothing. Took some time for me to install it, but other than that, it's the best ~$400 I've spent so far.
09-01-2000, 05:51 AM
#10
Supporting Maxima.org Member
Join Date: Aug 2000
Posts: 604
Re: Cattman SS Y-pipe
Originally posted by Jambo
I've had mine for close to a year now and I absolutely love it. No fitment problem, no weird noises -- nothing. Took some time for me to install it, but other than that, it's the best ~$400 I've spent so far.
I've had mine for close to a year now and I absolutely love it. No fitment problem, no weird noises -- nothing. Took some time for me to install it, but other than that, it's the best ~$400 I've spent so far.
09-01-2000, 01:12 PM
#11
when i got my stillen ypipe after Maxima Day, there was a fitment problem with the two separate pipes.
i used my dremel to sand down the inside so that the two pipes would interlock better.
that was the only problem for the stillen pipe.
two days later, i installed a cattman ypipe on another maxima, but the cattman's pipe was made so sloppily, the o2 sensor would hit parts of the undercarriage and it was a complete pain in the *** trying to get it to attach to the catalyst converter due to the welds on the flange-connection part.
even with the stillen problem, i got the stillen pipe in under three hours.
the cattman pipe took over 4 hours to install due to the fact we had to bang out parts of my friend's car cuz the o2 sensor wouldn't fit, and we had to remove parts of the ypipe-holder near the catalyst converter.
imho. go with the stillen ypipe.
i used my dremel to sand down the inside so that the two pipes would interlock better.
that was the only problem for the stillen pipe.
two days later, i installed a cattman ypipe on another maxima, but the cattman's pipe was made so sloppily, the o2 sensor would hit parts of the undercarriage and it was a complete pain in the *** trying to get it to attach to the catalyst converter due to the welds on the flange-connection part.
even with the stillen problem, i got the stillen pipe in under three hours.
the cattman pipe took over 4 hours to install due to the fact we had to bang out parts of my friend's car cuz the o2 sensor wouldn't fit, and we had to remove parts of the ypipe-holder near the catalyst converter.
imho. go with the stillen ypipe.
09-24-2001, 09:57 AM
#13
Originally posted by Nismo87SE
Damn a Y pipe get some headers. Or go with the WSP Y pipe if your on a budget.
Damn a Y pipe get some headers. Or go with the WSP Y pipe if your on a budget.
tell that to my blown flex section.. that sounds like a tractor trailer..new cattman pipe is on the way
09-24-2001, 10:11 AM
#15
Originally posted by Nismo87SE
Damn a Y pipe get some headers. Or go with the WSP Y pipe if your on a budget.
Damn a Y pipe get some headers. Or go with the WSP Y pipe if your on a budget.
As for headers. Don and Emax replaced their headers, and they got crap for gains. Maybe you should read around before you suggest something to another person. I think everyone agrees that the Y-pipe is one of the best bank for the buck performance mods for the maxima (and it's much easier to install then headers)
09-24-2001, 11:24 AM
#18
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: NJ
Posts: 5,630
I have Stealin Y. The fitment was a bit off but the quality was good. I was alos kinda mad that it ony replaced 1 of the precats. I have a 99 cali spec. I am almsot mad that my y makes a funny noise and i think its leakin already. Blah!
09-24-2001, 11:38 AM
#19
Originally posted by Synki
I have Stealin Y. The fitment was a bit off but the quality was good. I was alos kinda mad that it ony replaced 1 of the precats. I have a 99 cali spec. I am almsot mad that my y makes a funny noise and i think its leakin already. Blah!
I have Stealin Y. The fitment was a bit off but the quality was good. I was alos kinda mad that it ony replaced 1 of the precats. I have a 99 cali spec. I am almsot mad that my y makes a funny noise and i think its leakin already. Blah!
09-24-2001, 12:13 PM
#21
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2000
Posts: 2,075
Hmmm
I'd have to say Stillen... You'd have a better chance of returning it if something is wrong. So many ppl in the DC .org have had problems with the Cattman's longevity, customer service and fitment. Hopefully the New version of the Cattman will last long(fitment is still an issue).
09-24-2001, 12:59 PM
#23
i loved
my cattman although i admit i didn't have it long since i totaled my ride it was amazing, as for the stillen i have friends who have problems with them, one of them being synki, he says his flex is already leaking.
09-25-2001, 04:55 AM
#27
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2000
Posts: 2,075
Re: Stillen or Catman Y-Pipe, what about budget?!
Here's a short write up with some pics no real performance data yet though.. http://members.aol.com/~dcmaxclub/
\
\
Originally posted by Tai Mai Shu
Has anyone had a budget Y-pipe, thats the one i was looking at beacuse of its low cost so, if anyone know whats the workmanship or any problems, it would help thanks!
Has anyone had a budget Y-pipe, thats the one i was looking at beacuse of its low cost
so, if anyone know whats the workmanship or any problems, it would help thanks!
09-25-2001, 06:49 AM
#29
Originally posted by BriGuyMax
COUGH COUGH CATTMAN COUGH COUGH
if for no other reasons than quality and the AWESOME customer service...
COUGH COUGH CATTMAN COUGH COUGH
if for no other reasons than quality and the AWESOME customer service...
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Stagnet04
4th Generation Classifieds (1995-1999)
1
09-14-2015 11:28 PM