I have a set of 18" Murano rims on the max with 235/40/18 Toyo Proxes 4 on them. I hit a pot hole something fierce the other day and my front right tire has a knot in it like it got punched in the forehead. The wheel itself is fine, but I am going to replace the tire. The set has 10,000 miles on them. My question is should I replace both of my front tires so the tread stays around the same level or should I just replace the one tire ?

 

I would replace both personally.

 

Yeah, I would do the same so you are even. Keep the other tire for a spare.