Another believer in KNOCK SENSOR replacement.
#1
Another believer in KNOCK SENSOR replacement.
I changed out my knock sensor last night. I reset the ECU and went for a drive. The car is SO much smoother now. Before whenever i was accelerating moderately the engine would seem a little rough. Now it just purrs and pulls so much harder. My low end power is back and the high end has much more pull. The difference is huge! I am very happy. Anyone with the 0304 engine code needs to change out their sensor. Hello better gas mileage. Maybe now I can break the 14's.
#2
Thanks for the input, I have the same code, my power is awful now and I have jerky acceleration when I am light on the trottle. When JMAXIMA and I used to race it was dead even but now he pulls on me especially in 3rd. I probably need a fuel filter and TBI cleaning as well, I just don't have the cash for any of that now!
#9
#10
Originally posted by matty
NO, the Knock Sensor is the only sensor in the car that will not trip the light...
NO, the Knock Sensor is the only sensor in the car that will not trip the light...
up even though I had a bad neutral/reverse sensor. I ran the ECU
scan manually, per the Hayne's manual, and got the neutral/reverse
code. I changed it and voila, my idle returned to normal and I no
longer had the RPMs rising every time I came to a stop.
Anyhow, the short of it is that several sensors won't cause a light
upon failure, but they will register in the ECU.
#13
Originally posted by korupter
do you need to reset your ecu when u replace the knock sensor?
do you need to reset your ecu when u replace the knock sensor?
P.S. I need to get out of debt first which will happen in two months at the VERY latest. I know alot of you guys have read about my problems in the past...I promise I will find exactly what is wrong with the ride....and btw I have a speed sensor code as well; any input would be nice. If not I will buy a Haynes manual.
#14
Re: Another believer in KNOCK SENSOR replacement.
I've had cold engine idle surge problems
for last summer and this one also.
Cleaning Throttle Body was a help, but
Knock Sensor code appeared after
cleaning TB this summer. I like the theory
that it's a combination of factors that
cause hesitant accel at 1500-2500 RPM
on a cold start and sometimes (5-10% of
cold starts) surge at idle. My question
is how easy is it to replace the knock
sensor and where would be a good place to
get one? How much do shops like Pep Boys
(or dealer) charge for doing the job?
Thanks
for last summer and this one also.
Cleaning Throttle Body was a help, but
Knock Sensor code appeared after
cleaning TB this summer. I like the theory
that it's a combination of factors that
cause hesitant accel at 1500-2500 RPM
on a cold start and sometimes (5-10% of
cold starts) surge at idle. My question
is how easy is it to replace the knock
sensor and where would be a good place to
get one? How much do shops like Pep Boys
(or dealer) charge for doing the job?
Thanks
#15
Re: Re: Another believer in KNOCK SENSOR replacement.
Originally posted by oppaman
I've had cold engine idle surge problems
for last summer and this one also.
Cleaning Throttle Body was a help, but
Knock Sensor code appeared after
cleaning TB this summer. I like the theory
that it's a combination of factors that
cause hesitant accel at 1500-2500 RPM
on a cold start and sometimes (5-10% of
cold starts) surge at idle. My question
is how easy is it to replace the knock
sensor and where would be a good place to
get one? How much do shops like Pep Boys
(or dealer) charge for doing the job?
Thanks
I've had cold engine idle surge problems
for last summer and this one also.
Cleaning Throttle Body was a help, but
Knock Sensor code appeared after
cleaning TB this summer. I like the theory
that it's a combination of factors that
cause hesitant accel at 1500-2500 RPM
on a cold start and sometimes (5-10% of
cold starts) surge at idle. My question
is how easy is it to replace the knock
sensor and where would be a good place to
get one? How much do shops like Pep Boys
(or dealer) charge for doing the job?
Thanks
http://forums.maxima.org/showthread....t=knock+sensor
#16
Originally posted by munji
when my knock sensor went out .... my light went on. I had no other errors on my system .... the cheapest price I found was at the partsbin.com for ~$115 or so..................
when my knock sensor went out .... my light went on. I had no other errors on my system .... the cheapest price I found was at the partsbin.com for ~$115 or so..................
I'll let you in on a little secret. I have been trying for a while to win a knock sensor for my 4th gen on ebay for $75 or less, but had been unsuccessful. Completely by mistake, I bid on a KS for a 5th gen Maxima, which I won for $25.
When the KS arrived, I measured the resistance, which came out to ~550 kohms, same as for the 4th gen. The only apparent difference was the connection to the harness. So I modified the harness to fit the 5th gen KS and installed it.
It works perfectly - low end power is back, smooth acceleration, etc.
I've noticed that the 5th gen KS seem to go for much lower prices on ebay than the 4th gen KS, probably because of reduced demand. So you might want to give it a try.
#17
Originally posted by Stephen Max
I'll let you in on a little secret. I have been trying for a while to win a knock sensor for my 4th gen on ebay for $75 or less, but had been unsuccessful. Completely by mistake, I bid on a KS for a 5th gen Maxima, which I won for $25.
When the KS arrived, I measured the resistance, which came out to ~550 kohms, same as for the 4th gen. The only apparent difference was the connection to the harness. So I modified the harness to fit the 5th gen KS and installed it.
It works perfectly - low end power is back, smooth acceleration, etc.
I've noticed that the 5th gen KS seem to go for much lower prices on ebay than the 4th gen KS, probably because of reduced demand. So you might want to give it a try.
I'll let you in on a little secret. I have been trying for a while to win a knock sensor for my 4th gen on ebay for $75 or less, but had been unsuccessful. Completely by mistake, I bid on a KS for a 5th gen Maxima, which I won for $25.
When the KS arrived, I measured the resistance, which came out to ~550 kohms, same as for the 4th gen. The only apparent difference was the connection to the harness. So I modified the harness to fit the 5th gen KS and installed it.
It works perfectly - low end power is back, smooth acceleration, etc.
I've noticed that the 5th gen KS seem to go for much lower prices on ebay than the 4th gen KS, probably because of reduced demand. So you might want to give it a try.
question, if the 550kohms resitance with the engine running not? can you check this resistence while the sensor is out of the car?
thanks for the info, hopefully my knock sensor problem goes away
#18
Originally posted by Vinipux
I went to a local place where u can buy used parts from them and the guy didn't even know what it was, he asked me how much the knock sensor was new and I'm like "like 80 bucks" he said "I'll give it to you for 40", hehe, so I'm picking it up today
question, if the 550kohms resitance with the engine running not? can you check this resistence while the sensor is out of the car?
thanks for the info, hopefully my knock sensor problem goes away
I went to a local place where u can buy used parts from them and the guy didn't even know what it was, he asked me how much the knock sensor was new and I'm like "like 80 bucks" he said "I'll give it to you for 40", hehe, so I'm picking it up today
question, if the 550kohms resitance with the engine running not? can you check this resistence while the sensor is out of the car?
thanks for the info, hopefully my knock sensor problem goes away
Be aware that knock sensors can display intermittent failure behavior. The first time I checked my KS resistance, it showed an open circuit. So I pulled the KS out, checked it again and what the ****, it's showing 550 kohms. So I put the KS back in after sanding the contact surfaces of the KS and the engine, thinking that maybe it was a contact resistance buildup between the KS and the engine. But my car never really seemed to be running as good as it should, and I checked resistance again and it showed up open circuit.
So I made up a faux-knock sensor with a couple of resistors from Radio Shack to give me 550 kohms and plugged that into the harness instead of the KS. That way the engine would think it had a normally operating KS. Voila! An immediate increase in performance. That pretty much determined that either the KS or the KS harness was the problem. I checked out the harness thoroughly and it showed no problem. Eventually I got a new KS, and the problem is solved and the car is running as it should now. Yet, after I pulled out the old one, it checked out OK once again! Weird.
#19
Originally posted by Stephen Max
Check the resistance with the engine off. Yes, you can check the resistance with the KS out of the car.
Be aware that knock sensors can display intermittent failure behavior. The first time I checked my KS resistance, it showed an open circuit. So I pulled the KS out, checked it again and what the ****, it's showing 550 kohms. So I put the KS back in after sanding the contact surfaces of the KS and the engine, thinking that maybe it was a contact resistance buildup between the KS and the engine. But my car never really seemed to be running as good as it should, and I checked resistance again and it showed up open circuit.
So I made up a faux-knock sensor with a couple of resistors from Radio Shack to give me 550 kohms and plugged that into the harness instead of the KS. That way the engine would think it had a normally operating KS. Voila! An immediate increase in performance. That pretty much determined that either the KS or the KS harness was the problem. I checked out the harness thoroughly and it showed no problem. Eventually I got a new KS, and the problem is solved and the car is running as it should now. Yet, after I pulled out the old one, it checked out OK once again! Weird.
Check the resistance with the engine off. Yes, you can check the resistance with the KS out of the car.
Be aware that knock sensors can display intermittent failure behavior. The first time I checked my KS resistance, it showed an open circuit. So I pulled the KS out, checked it again and what the ****, it's showing 550 kohms. So I put the KS back in after sanding the contact surfaces of the KS and the engine, thinking that maybe it was a contact resistance buildup between the KS and the engine. But my car never really seemed to be running as good as it should, and I checked resistance again and it showed up open circuit.
So I made up a faux-knock sensor with a couple of resistors from Radio Shack to give me 550 kohms and plugged that into the harness instead of the KS. That way the engine would think it had a normally operating KS. Voila! An immediate increase in performance. That pretty much determined that either the KS or the KS harness was the problem. I checked out the harness thoroughly and it showed no problem. Eventually I got a new KS, and the problem is solved and the car is running as it should now. Yet, after I pulled out the old one, it checked out OK once again! Weird.
#20
allright, so I got this knock sensor, and I'm trying to get the resistance on the sucker and it's only showing like 20 kohms, vs. the old one (it was cracked by the way) was showing like 13 kohms
i checked the codes and it gave me nothing, (it did give me 0505 which is "No Failure Recorded/Detected")
so I don't know what to think now, the resistance is wrong but the ecu doesn't throw out a code, I went for a drive around the block the car feels like it has more power in 2nd gear now, where before it felt like a dog.
i checked the codes and it gave me nothing, (it did give me 0505 which is "No Failure Recorded/Detected")
so I don't know what to think now, the resistance is wrong but the ecu doesn't throw out a code, I went for a drive around the block the car feels like it has more power in 2nd gear now, where before it felt like a dog.
#21
Originally posted by Vinipux
allright, so I got this knock sensor, and I'm trying to get the resistance on the sucker and it's only showing like 20 kohms, vs. the old one (it was cracked by the way) was showing like 13 kohms
i checked the codes and it gave me nothing, (it did give me 0505 which is "No Failure Recorded/Detected")
so I don't know what to think now, the resistance is wrong but the ecu doesn't throw out a code, I went for a drive around the block the car feels like it has more power in 2nd gear now, where before it felt like a dog.
allright, so I got this knock sensor, and I'm trying to get the resistance on the sucker and it's only showing like 20 kohms, vs. the old one (it was cracked by the way) was showing like 13 kohms
i checked the codes and it gave me nothing, (it did give me 0505 which is "No Failure Recorded/Detected")
so I don't know what to think now, the resistance is wrong but the ecu doesn't throw out a code, I went for a drive around the block the car feels like it has more power in 2nd gear now, where before it felt like a dog.
As long as you aren't getting 0304 and the car feels like it has good low end power and smooth acceleration, I wouldn't worry about the resistance reading. But how were you measuring the resistance? You should have one lead at the pin going into the KS (there are two pins, but only one is used) and the other lead on a good grounding location or on the metal base of the KS. And you should be using a good digital multimeter, too.
#22
Originally posted by Stephen Max
As long as you aren't getting 0304 and the car feels like it has good low end power and smooth acceleration, I wouldn't worry about the resistance reading. But how were you measuring the resistance? You should have one lead at the pin going into the KS (there are two pins, but only one is used) and the other lead on a good grounding location or on the metal base of the KS. And you should be using a good digital multimeter, too.
As long as you aren't getting 0304 and the car feels like it has good low end power and smooth acceleration, I wouldn't worry about the resistance reading. But how were you measuring the resistance? You should have one lead at the pin going into the KS (there are two pins, but only one is used) and the other lead on a good grounding location or on the metal base of the KS. And you should be using a good digital multimeter, too.
#23
Originally posted by Stephen Max
So I made up a faux-knock sensor with a couple of resistors from Radio Shack to give me 550 kohms and plugged that into the harness instead of the KS. That way the engine would think it had a normally operating KS. Voila! An immediate increase in performance. That pretty much determined that either the KS or the KS harness was the problem. I checked out the harness thoroughly and it showed no problem. Eventually I got a new KS, and the problem is solved and the car is running as it should now. Yet, after I pulled out the old one, it checked out OK once again! Weird.
So I made up a faux-knock sensor with a couple of resistors from Radio Shack to give me 550 kohms and plugged that into the harness instead of the KS. That way the engine would think it had a normally operating KS. Voila! An immediate increase in performance. That pretty much determined that either the KS or the KS harness was the problem. I checked out the harness thoroughly and it showed no problem. Eventually I got a new KS, and the problem is solved and the car is running as it should now. Yet, after I pulled out the old one, it checked out OK once again! Weird.
#24
Originally posted by KINGMAX
You need to reset it anytime you (hopefully) fix the problem. This will probably be a good indicator for me wheather or not the knock sensor code(0304) is actually a "ghost code". I plan on seriously tuning the car up, fuel filter, TBI cleaning, and plugs before I change the knock sensor. My car has 55k and I plan on doing all of these things before I change the knock sensor. One of my theories is that I have a misfire due to an injector that is clogged or not giving a good spray pattern. I have no idea what kind of gas was put in before I bought it(28k, every gas has detergents but some not as many as others) but the injector theory is a longshot. Another theory, of course is the plugs, even though I have gone to the track alot a doubt this is the problem i.e. heavy acceleration(even though I am too lazy to inspect them for deposits etc.). So finnaly this leads to either a nasty TB, fuel filter, or of course the knock sensor. As far as I am concerned it is a combination of everything, to a greator or lessor degree, and trust me everyone....I will include a write up if needed for each time I change or fix one of these parts...just let me know.
P.S. I need to get out of debt first which will happen in two months at the VERY latest. I know alot of you guys have read about my problems in the past...I promise I will find exactly what is wrong with the ride....and btw I have a speed sensor code as well; any input would be nice. If not I will buy a Haynes manual.
You need to reset it anytime you (hopefully) fix the problem. This will probably be a good indicator for me wheather or not the knock sensor code(0304) is actually a "ghost code". I plan on seriously tuning the car up, fuel filter, TBI cleaning, and plugs before I change the knock sensor. My car has 55k and I plan on doing all of these things before I change the knock sensor. One of my theories is that I have a misfire due to an injector that is clogged or not giving a good spray pattern. I have no idea what kind of gas was put in before I bought it(28k, every gas has detergents but some not as many as others) but the injector theory is a longshot. Another theory, of course is the plugs, even though I have gone to the track alot a doubt this is the problem i.e. heavy acceleration(even though I am too lazy to inspect them for deposits etc.). So finnaly this leads to either a nasty TB, fuel filter, or of course the knock sensor. As far as I am concerned it is a combination of everything, to a greator or lessor degree, and trust me everyone....I will include a write up if needed for each time I change or fix one of these parts...just let me know.
P.S. I need to get out of debt first which will happen in two months at the VERY latest. I know alot of you guys have read about my problems in the past...I promise I will find exactly what is wrong with the ride....and btw I have a speed sensor code as well; any input would be nice. If not I will buy a Haynes manual.
Just curious, what octane of fuel have you gues been using? Nothing but 93 octane in my 95 max with 192,000 miles, and no problems with KS.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
AaronL
5th Generation Maxima (2000-2003)
15
08-08-2020 10:31 AM
hayne
6th Generation Maxima (2004-2008)
2
10-05-2015 11:53 AM
DC_Juggernaut
7th Generation Maxima (2009-2015)
4
09-28-2015 04:07 PM