Alternator or starter ?
Alternator or starter ?
Hi...I made some searches but nothing seems to be like what I'm experiencing with the car !
my car started 2 or 3 days ago to start not briskly as it was before,especially after short trips....
today at morning , it was cold (18F) , I crancked it , it crancked slowly then it kinda "chocked" and stoped ... tried it again and it was even slower in crancking...I have waited on "on" key position for seconds then third time I crancked , it was dead.........lights inside and out all work,horn also work like normal ...I don't know but the power from the battery seems to be normal , (does the starter maybe needs more power to start the car ?)...I left the car for about 2 and a half hours..........came back and it cracnked then started normaly.........
I don't know if it's a considence , but I have little rattles from the belts areas (idle pulley is going bad ?) ..................
Now do I have a bad battery , alternator or starter ???
no cel by the way...177k car,tb,iacv,maf cleaned months before,spark plugs and fuel filter were replaced not long ago,battery is 2.5 years old
another thing ,the starter used to(from time to time,maybe once a week or 2 weeks) to run when I cranck the engine and it seems like it runs without engaging the fly wheel,,only once then it starts fine in the second time...however never failed to start before
any helpful comments appreciated...
my car started 2 or 3 days ago to start not briskly as it was before,especially after short trips....
today at morning , it was cold (18F) , I crancked it , it crancked slowly then it kinda "chocked" and stoped ... tried it again and it was even slower in crancking...I have waited on "on" key position for seconds then third time I crancked , it was dead.........lights inside and out all work,horn also work like normal ...I don't know but the power from the battery seems to be normal , (does the starter maybe needs more power to start the car ?)...I left the car for about 2 and a half hours..........came back and it cracnked then started normaly.........
I don't know if it's a considence , but I have little rattles from the belts areas (idle pulley is going bad ?) ..................
Now do I have a bad battery , alternator or starter ???
no cel by the way...177k car,tb,iacv,maf cleaned months before,spark plugs and fuel filter were replaced not long ago,battery is 2.5 years old
another thing ,the starter used to(from time to time,maybe once a week or 2 weeks) to run when I cranck the engine and it seems like it runs without engaging the fly wheel,,only once then it starts fine in the second time...however never failed to start before
any helpful comments appreciated...
I'd say it's your starter. One clear symptom of a dying starter is that it'll crank slow...almost as if you have a low battery. Also if the starter sounds like its skipping or stuttering while cranking, that's another good indication.
If your battery is good, then I would suspect the starter. Remove it and bench test it or take it to an auto parts store. They should be able to verify that it's bad. Could just be a bad solenoid. I regreased my starter recently and replaced the solenoid rather than get another starter. Cost me $30 vs. $130.
I think the starter is your culprit. However, I don't think your battery is 100%, either. Take the car to an Autozone parts store and have them do a load test on your battery. Its free, so no damage to your wallet.
Sounds like a bad solenoid. Most likely dirty or worn. I had the exact same problem. The solenoid in the starter gets worn and doesn't make good contact so it doesn't deliver enough voltage to the starter to give it a good oomph to start right away. Soon or later your starter will stop working all together. Get a Nissan rebuilt starter. I got a cheap Napa one that the dealer put in and it had run-on and lasted barely a year. The Nissan rebuilt on has a foam shield to keep dirt out of the starter and was noticeably stronger on starts.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
TallTom
5th Generation Maxima (2000-2003)
57
Oct 14, 2025 05:16 PM
My Coffee
New Member Introductions
15
Jun 6, 2017 02:01 PM
mikeg75
4th Generation Maxima (1995-1999)
12
Nov 30, 2015 05:12 PM
maxima297
4th Generation Maxima (1995-1999)
4
Sep 30, 2015 03:32 PM



?
