Do you guys think that the 04 is going to be overated in power like the 02/03's claim
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Manhattan Beach, Ca / Dallas, Tx
Posts: 3,751
Do you guys think that the 04 is going to be overated in power like the 02/03's claim
With all the talk of the 02/03's not making their full 255 Hp do you guys think that the 04 will be in the same boat. You think Nissan is going to over rate it as well, I cant wait to see a dyno on it when its claimed horsepower/torque shows up vs its actual numbers.
#2
There is no CONCLUSIVE scientific proof (w/ multiple runs on multiple dyno's w/ the exact same methodology used) that the current hp ratings are in fact overrated. The Max auto tranny may just sop up more juice than the altima tranny, despite the fact that many say they're the same tranny. (just an example, I welcome all hotheads to claim I'm wrong, power to you)
#4
Originally posted by PeterUbers
There is no CONCLUSIVE scientific proof (w/ multiple runs on multiple dyno's w/ the exact same methodology used) that the current hp ratings are in fact overrated. The Max auto tranny may just sop up more juice than the altima tranny, despite the fact that many say they're the same tranny. (just an example, I welcome all hotheads to claim I'm wrong, power to you)
There is no CONCLUSIVE scientific proof (w/ multiple runs on multiple dyno's w/ the exact same methodology used) that the current hp ratings are in fact overrated. The Max auto tranny may just sop up more juice than the altima tranny, despite the fact that many say they're the same tranny. (just an example, I welcome all hotheads to claim I'm wrong, power to you)
My friend dynoed his 350Z 6-speed and got 225-230hp and got same torque as what 6-speed Max is getting, I think this is no where close to 287hp Nissan is claiming. Nissan is just playing with numbers.
#7
i think nissan will overrate some of their cars and underrate some.
the G35 sedan with the auto 5spd is putting down some good numbers. i've seen dynos graphs of 213rwhp - 225rwhp. i also, believe that the g35c 6spd and Z 6spd should be rated at around 270 or 275 hp..not 280 and 287.
if the 04 is rated at around 270 hp then i dont think it would overrated, but i wouldn't be surprised if it dynos the same as the g35 and the Z
they can overrate the hp #s cus they underrate the torque. that's one reason the car is still pretty quick.
oh and i think the torque in all the 3.5L is about the same even tho nissan rates them differently.
the G35 sedan with the auto 5spd is putting down some good numbers. i've seen dynos graphs of 213rwhp - 225rwhp. i also, believe that the g35c 6spd and Z 6spd should be rated at around 270 or 275 hp..not 280 and 287.
if the 04 is rated at around 270 hp then i dont think it would overrated, but i wouldn't be surprised if it dynos the same as the g35 and the Z
they can overrate the hp #s cus they underrate the torque. that's one reason the car is still pretty quick.
oh and i think the torque in all the 3.5L is about the same even tho nissan rates them differently.
#8
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally posted by PeterUbers
There is no CONCLUSIVE scientific proof (w/ multiple runs on multiple dyno's w/ the exact same methodology used) that the current hp ratings are in fact overrated. The Max auto tranny may just sop up more juice than the altima tranny, despite the fact that many say they're the same tranny. (just an example, I welcome all hotheads to claim I'm wrong, power to you)
There is no CONCLUSIVE scientific proof (w/ multiple runs on multiple dyno's w/ the exact same methodology used) that the current hp ratings are in fact overrated. The Max auto tranny may just sop up more juice than the altima tranny, despite the fact that many say they're the same tranny. (just an example, I welcome all hotheads to claim I'm wrong, power to you)
because I just don't understand?
-vq
#9
I thought I'd make a point. When your dyno'ing a car, the hp your getting is the hp at wheels. One guy posted a dyno from a 350Z being at 225-230hp. That would be rear wheel horsepower. The numbers nissan gives is the amount of power at the crank, which is different. It has always been a given that you will loose power through the powertrain, because there is hp needed to turn all that weight. So I highly doubt that Nissan is merely throwing numbers around. There is away to calculate whp to bhp though I don't know what those calculations are, but they take into effect the distance from the motor to the wheels, gear ratios, weight, etc. The only other way to see if nissan is telling the true is to remove the motor, and dyno the motor. Hope this helps some.
S
S
#10
Originally posted by maximase86
I thought I'd make a point. When your dyno'ing a car, the hp your getting is the hp at wheels. One guy posted a dyno from a 350Z being at 225-230hp. That would be rear wheel horsepower. The numbers nissan gives is the amount of power at the crank, which is different. It has always been a given that you will loose power through the powertrain, because there is hp needed to turn all that weight.
I thought I'd make a point. When your dyno'ing a car, the hp your getting is the hp at wheels. One guy posted a dyno from a 350Z being at 225-230hp. That would be rear wheel horsepower. The numbers nissan gives is the amount of power at the crank, which is different. It has always been a given that you will loose power through the powertrain, because there is hp needed to turn all that weight.
the point we are trying to make is, "why does the max, Z, etc. lose sooo much power?"
if a 6spd Z dynos at 225rwhp, that's almost 22% loss. i dont know about u, but that's a bit much to me
#11
Originally posted by MaximaPower
i believe everyone knows that.
the point we are trying to make is, "why does the max, Z, etc. lose sooo much power?"
if a 6spd Z dynos at 225rwhp, that's almost 22% loss. i dont know about u, but that's a bit much to me
i believe everyone knows that.
the point we are trying to make is, "why does the max, Z, etc. lose sooo much power?"
if a 6spd Z dynos at 225rwhp, that's almost 22% loss. i dont know about u, but that's a bit much to me
Basically to combat this, you can go with lighter shafts, smaller diameter pullys (underdrive pulley's), lighter drivetrain components, etc. People can be very surprised how much horsepower you can free up by just doing that.
Does this help?
S
#12
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally posted by maximase86
I thought I'd make a point. When your dyno'ing a car, the hp your getting is the hp at wheels. One guy posted a dyno from a 350Z being at 225-230hp. That would be rear wheel horsepower. The numbers nissan gives is the amount of power at the crank, which is different. It has always been a given that you will loose power through the powertrain, because there is hp needed to turn all that weight. So I highly doubt that Nissan is merely throwing numbers around. There is away to calculate whp to bhp though I don't know what those calculations are, but they take into effect the distance from the motor to the wheels, gear ratios, weight, etc. The only other way to see if nissan is telling the true is to remove the motor, and dyno the motor. Hope this helps some.
S
I thought I'd make a point. When your dyno'ing a car, the hp your getting is the hp at wheels. One guy posted a dyno from a 350Z being at 225-230hp. That would be rear wheel horsepower. The numbers nissan gives is the amount of power at the crank, which is different. It has always been a given that you will loose power through the powertrain, because there is hp needed to turn all that weight. So I highly doubt that Nissan is merely throwing numbers around. There is away to calculate whp to bhp though I don't know what those calculations are, but they take into effect the distance from the motor to the wheels, gear ratios, weight, etc. The only other way to see if nissan is telling the true is to remove the motor, and dyno the motor. Hope this helps some.
S
-vq
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
maxinout93
5th Generation Maxima (2000-2003)
3
08-20-2015 02:17 AM
MaximaDrvr
7th Generation Maxima (2009-2015)
16
08-19-2015 08:20 PM