Compact portable navigation systems. any good?
Thread Starter
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 1,081
From: BUENA PARK, CA (orange county)
Compact portable navigation systems. any good?
such as tom tom, garmin, magellan. etc. does anyone got one? how accurate and good are they comparing to expensive in dash units. which brand is better?
They did a recent review on just this subject in the Jan 07 issue of Car Audio & Electronics:
Garmin Streetpilot C550 = A+
Pioneer AVIC S1 = B+
Navman ICN 530 = C+
Cobra Electronics NAV ONE 2500 = Not Graded
I'd probably opt for the Garmin stuff simply because they are the market leader in this catagory. And, as kpr10is said, it's pretty easy to use (I work for a stereo shop and we sell Garmin all day long)
Garmin Streetpilot C550 = A+
Pioneer AVIC S1 = B+
Navman ICN 530 = C+
Cobra Electronics NAV ONE 2500 = Not Graded
I'd probably opt for the Garmin stuff simply because they are the market leader in this catagory. And, as kpr10is said, it's pretty easy to use (I work for a stereo shop and we sell Garmin all day long)
Originally Posted by kpr10is
Garmin FTW. Ive sold plenty of the Streetpilot 330's/340's, never really a complaint. Every Magellan I used has been hard as hell to navigate through the menus comparatively.
about the magellan, have heard the same complaints at my shop. I have no experience with the Garmin, though.Id highly suggest the Alpine Blackbird however, they work very well - it even tells you that the entrance to a place is through a parking lot, where you cant see -
It's more thurough and exact than the tomtom, we did a head to head contest once

Also, the blackbirds just dropped in price by $200.. cant complain.
Thread Starter
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 1,081
From: BUENA PARK, CA (orange county)
Originally Posted by mendon99
about the magellan, have heard the same complaints at my shop. I have no experience with the Garmin, though.Id highly suggest the Alpine Blackbird however, they work very well - it even tells you that the entrance to a place is through a parking lot, where you cant see -
It's more thurough and exact than the tomtom, we did a head to head contest once

Also, the blackbirds just dropped in price by $200.. cant complain.
so how accurate is alpine blackbird and can you mention the model # so i can look it up on ebay. i heard the alpine blackbird can be hooked to alpine dvd indash head unit. so if we compare tom tom with blackbird you think blackbird is more accurate?
I just bought the Garmin C320 and a 512sd card for $300.00 last month and really like it. I haven't used the poi's that much but it sure beats paying 1500.00 for oem one. I have had the suction cup fall off after 3 weeks once but have orderd a dash mount from Amazon a few days ago.
Thread Starter
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 1,081
From: BUENA PARK, CA (orange county)
Originally Posted by DONS459
I just bought the Garmin C320 and a 512sd card for $300.00 last month and really like it. I haven't used the poi's that much but it sure beats paying 1500.00 for oem one. I have had the suction cup fall off after 3 weeks once but have orderd a dash mount from Amazon a few days ago.
and If you miss a turn or go a different way, will it automatically reroute you?
Thread Starter
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 1,081
From: BUENA PARK, CA (orange county)
Originally Posted by mendon99
blackbird is better than the tomtom, period.
PMD-B100
PMD-B100
Originally Posted by Bollwerk
Now if they would just drop the price on the NVE-N872A ... *sigh*
$1700 is painful
$1700 is painful
Originally Posted by OC guy
I have a question. If you miss a turn or go a different way, will it automatically reroute you?
the only downside is, if you're going a different route to a certain highway, it will try to reroute you backwards to the first road it told you to go to..
after a few failed attempts however, it usually figures out what you're trying to do and routes you your planned route to get to the said highway. Did that make any sense? its tough to describe..
Thread Starter
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 1,081
From: BUENA PARK, CA (orange county)
Originally Posted by mendon99
simple answer, yes.
the only downside is, if you're going a different route to a certain highway, it will try to reroute you backwards to the first road it told you to go to..
after a few failed attempts however, it usually figures out what you're trying to do and routes you your planned route to get to the said highway. Did that make any sense? its tough to describe..
the only downside is, if you're going a different route to a certain highway, it will try to reroute you backwards to the first road it told you to go to..
after a few failed attempts however, it usually figures out what you're trying to do and routes you your planned route to get to the said highway. Did that make any sense? its tough to describe..
by the way what do you say about Clarion N.I.C.E. P200 its for $400 and has all the functions that other units do. this one also have 4'' tft lcd touch screen and built in 20GB Hard Disc Drive and 2 Million Points of Interest but the only problem in this unit is i have no idea if it does automatically reroute the missed lacation? but under specifications it says "Automatic Route Recalculation" so does this mean that it does automatically reroute you?
and last question: are they all made in china? because i dont trust china stuff.
i have no experience with the clarion unit, and my shop even carries clarion
: i guess since we sell so many blackbirds we just dont need it
, ill ask about it though..20GB hard drive for what? music? thats pretty cool..
the blackbird has 6 million points of interest. not that that really matters to most people.. they just wanna get to their destination and stop if they need to.
: i guess since we sell so many blackbirds we just dont need it
, ill ask about it though..20GB hard drive for what? music? thats pretty cool.. the blackbird has 6 million points of interest. not that that really matters to most people.. they just wanna get to their destination and stop if they need to.
Thread Starter
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 1,081
From: BUENA PARK, CA (orange county)
Originally Posted by mendon99
i have no experience with the clarion unit, and my shop even carries clarion
: i guess since we sell so many blackbirds we just dont need it
, ill ask about it though..20GB hard drive for what? music? thats pretty cool..
the blackbird has 6 million points of interest. not that that really matters to most people.. they just wanna get to their destination and stop if they need to.
: i guess since we sell so many blackbirds we just dont need it
, ill ask about it though..20GB hard drive for what? music? thats pretty cool.. the blackbird has 6 million points of interest. not that that really matters to most people.. they just wanna get to their destination and stop if they need to.
anyone know where you can get the blackbird dock for the alpine iva-w200 for cheap? I am considering the blackbird as well, since I can get it for a great price, and use my alpine double din
Thread Starter
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 1,081
From: BUENA PARK, CA (orange county)
Originally Posted by reeloop
anyone know where you can get the blackbird dock for the alpine iva-w200 for cheap? I am considering the blackbird as well, since I can get it for a great price, and use my alpine double din
http://www.alpine-usa.com/en/product...&lang=en&tab=A
and do you know a place where i can get a alpine blackbird for a great price aswell? i saw few they around $500.
Originally Posted by OC guy
can we update maps and data on alpine blackbird over the internet? and is this unit turn by turn voice prompt plus hows the satelite signal?
yes, selectable turn by turn voice prompt
sat signal, i never had a problem.. it seems to suffer a little bit in really bad weather however.. just took a bit longer to calculate a destination route.
Thread Starter
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 1,081
From: BUENA PARK, CA (orange county)
Originally Posted by mendon99
right now at authorized dealers they should be 500, the docks i think are 200.. try crutchfield.
Thread Starter
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 1,081
From: BUENA PARK, CA (orange county)
California and Minnesota state laws prohibit mounting portable electronics on a vehicle's windshield with suction-cup mounts while the vehicle is in use. Portable electronics in these states must be mounted on the dash or console.
can we mount these units on dashboard if yes then what do we need beside that windshield cups?
can we mount these units on dashboard if yes then what do we need beside that windshield cups?
Originally Posted by OC guy
should be on ebay, but try this>
http://www.alpine-usa.com/en/product...&lang=en&tab=A
and do you know a place where i can get a alpine blackbird for a great price aswell? i saw few they around $500.
http://www.alpine-usa.com/en/product...&lang=en&tab=A
and do you know a place where i can get a alpine blackbird for a great price aswell? i saw few they around $500.
why is this dock $200, that is a silly price for a dock.
Thread Starter
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 1,081
From: BUENA PARK, CA (orange county)
I changed my mind on blackbird i am planning to with garmin streetpilot c550 or Garmin Nuvi 350
i think garmin nuvi 350 is the best choice. anyone got a garmin?
i think garmin nuvi 350 is the best choice. anyone got a garmin?
I have a Tom Tom 700 & a garmin streetpilot c340.
I rarely get to use the 340 anymore, wife took for everyday use - has text to speech - got it for $450 from costco - wife won't use the "other" gps - doesn't say the street names.
Whatever you get make sure it has text to speech (says street names) makes a huge difference!!!!!
I rarely get to use the 340 anymore, wife took for everyday use - has text to speech - got it for $450 from costco - wife won't use the "other" gps - doesn't say the street names.
Whatever you get make sure it has text to speech (says street names) makes a huge difference!!!!!
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
The Frye
7th Generation Maxima (2009-2015)
6
Sep 2, 2021 11:03 AM
MaxLife17
8th Generation Maxima (2016-)
43
Jun 27, 2019 01:37 PM
maxfever1987
Maximas for Sale / Wanted
0
Sep 6, 2015 06:20 PM




