It's 6 speed tinker time again.
#1
It's 6 speed tinker time again.
The other day when I was returning to work from lunch my transmission decided it was time to die. At this point I am not sure of what is broken but I know all of the forward gears function but the thing sounds like it is full of gravel. First gear is the worst and is trying to lock up.
Today I went to my local trusty transmission shop and I purchased another 6 speed gearbox to install. I was fortunate to discover that they had a '04 gearbox on the shelf which is the one I took. As far as I know the '04 box is better than the '02 which I had. This thing is supposed to have a triple coned second gear synchro and I think about everything else is improved. What I am really hoping for is a vastly improved 3rd gear synchro, perhaps even a double coned piece. I will find out once I get the thing apart when I install my HLSD. And IIRC the '04 U.S. car wasn't offered with the HLSD option.
One other thing that I'd forgotten about was the lower final drive. The '02-'03 6 speeds had a 3.812 final drive and the '04 6 speeds have a 4.133 final. Initially I didn't care to test the lower gear but now that I have one I am going to see how the thing feels. First gear should be even more useless but it might make second gear more feasble to launch from.
I also managed to get my hands on a Z33 OE clutch and flywheel. The point of this is to do a thorough comparison of it and the OE Maxima parts to see if 350Z clutch/flywheel combos are feasible. If this works I will have more ammo to persuade people to stay away from JWT garbage and it will open the door for a much wider variety of clutches and flywheels.
Now I just need to find where I put my digicam.
Today I went to my local trusty transmission shop and I purchased another 6 speed gearbox to install. I was fortunate to discover that they had a '04 gearbox on the shelf which is the one I took. As far as I know the '04 box is better than the '02 which I had. This thing is supposed to have a triple coned second gear synchro and I think about everything else is improved. What I am really hoping for is a vastly improved 3rd gear synchro, perhaps even a double coned piece. I will find out once I get the thing apart when I install my HLSD. And IIRC the '04 U.S. car wasn't offered with the HLSD option.
One other thing that I'd forgotten about was the lower final drive. The '02-'03 6 speeds had a 3.812 final drive and the '04 6 speeds have a 4.133 final. Initially I didn't care to test the lower gear but now that I have one I am going to see how the thing feels. First gear should be even more useless but it might make second gear more feasble to launch from.
I also managed to get my hands on a Z33 OE clutch and flywheel. The point of this is to do a thorough comparison of it and the OE Maxima parts to see if 350Z clutch/flywheel combos are feasible. If this works I will have more ammo to persuade people to stay away from JWT garbage and it will open the door for a much wider variety of clutches and flywheels.
Now I just need to find where I put my digicam.
#7
First update.
I had the tranny out of the car in about 45 mins this time (getting much faster).
The OE 350Z clutch is different than the OE Maxima (A33B) clutch however they are interchangeable. You can use a Z33 OE clutch/pressure plate on a A33B.
The flywheels are identical except for one tiny detail. The timing ring on the Z33 flywheel is clocked differently. I already see a very easy fix for this. The real problem is the timing ring offset. It is about 6.5mm further from the engine. Now you can't do anything about the timing ring but the crank sensor could possibly be moved by machining the bellhousing.
This kinda sucks right now because I need another flywheel. My OE dualmass flywheel has tons of play and is causing the pressure plate to rub against the bellhousing. It is junk and needs to be replaced. It looks for certain that I won't finish this project today. I still have to open the '04 tranny and install the HLSD.
It is bad news that the Z33 flywheel isn't a direct fit but at least we all know that they can be made to fit with a few modifications.
I had the tranny out of the car in about 45 mins this time (getting much faster).
The OE 350Z clutch is different than the OE Maxima (A33B) clutch however they are interchangeable. You can use a Z33 OE clutch/pressure plate on a A33B.
The flywheels are identical except for one tiny detail. The timing ring on the Z33 flywheel is clocked differently. I already see a very easy fix for this. The real problem is the timing ring offset. It is about 6.5mm further from the engine. Now you can't do anything about the timing ring but the crank sensor could possibly be moved by machining the bellhousing.
This kinda sucks right now because I need another flywheel. My OE dualmass flywheel has tons of play and is causing the pressure plate to rub against the bellhousing. It is junk and needs to be replaced. It looks for certain that I won't finish this project today. I still have to open the '04 tranny and install the HLSD.
It is bad news that the Z33 flywheel isn't a direct fit but at least we all know that they can be made to fit with a few modifications.
#10
Update #2
The first gear pinion is half a nuetral. I do at least have a spare input shaft and gear for the pinion shaft to repair this. Which are parts that I just so happend to keep while other parts got shipped off to Austrailia.
Overall I am glad I got my hands on a A34 tranny. It is easier to install the HLSD than it would be to repair this tranny. Now all I need is another HLSD so I can have trannys with two different ratios. And I know where one is.
The first gear pinion is half a nuetral. I do at least have a spare input shaft and gear for the pinion shaft to repair this. Which are parts that I just so happend to keep while other parts got shipped off to Austrailia.
Overall I am glad I got my hands on a A34 tranny. It is easier to install the HLSD than it would be to repair this tranny. Now all I need is another HLSD so I can have trannys with two different ratios. And I know where one is.
#11
I opened the '04 Transmission and visually everything appears intact and fine. I have decided that for now I am going to just put the cover back on the thing and put it in the car. That way I can determine what if anything is wrong with it and see if I really want the lower final drive. Seeing as how I am going to have to take the transmission back off the car once I get another flywheel I may as well do this.
#12
Premilinary results:
I already miss the HLSD. This thing will now peg leg the hell out of third gear. But I will install that at a later time. First gear is almost useless and is way too short for this car. Second is still just out of reach to be a good launch gear. Maybe with slicks at a track this thing would be ideal. With a 7200 RPM rev limit it would be even more ideal except for the wheel roast. Second is now about where it should be and seems to finish at about 60 mph vs the previous 65mph. Third goes to about 84 vs. 90 and fourth goes to 110 vs. 120. Those are my favorite three gears and they are now better suited for my powerband. I also miss the taller sixth gear. Intead of the previous 2000rpm at 60mph it appears to be about 2200-2300 and when cruising at 80mph I feel like I want to shift to a non existant seventh gear.
I already miss the HLSD. This thing will now peg leg the hell out of third gear. But I will install that at a later time. First gear is almost useless and is way too short for this car. Second is still just out of reach to be a good launch gear. Maybe with slicks at a track this thing would be ideal. With a 7200 RPM rev limit it would be even more ideal except for the wheel roast. Second is now about where it should be and seems to finish at about 60 mph vs the previous 65mph. Third goes to about 84 vs. 90 and fourth goes to 110 vs. 120. Those are my favorite three gears and they are now better suited for my powerband. I also miss the taller sixth gear. Intead of the previous 2000rpm at 60mph it appears to be about 2200-2300 and when cruising at 80mph I feel like I want to shift to a non existant seventh gear.
#14
Awesome work as always!
Good to hear that the Z33 OEM clutch is a direct fit. Plenty of aftermarket choices there!
As far as the flywheel I guess JWT would is still our only direct fit flywheel option at this point huh. How time-consuming and/or costly would it be to get the Z33 units to fit?
Good to hear that the Z33 OEM clutch is a direct fit. Plenty of aftermarket choices there!
As far as the flywheel I guess JWT would is still our only direct fit flywheel option at this point huh. How time-consuming and/or costly would it be to get the Z33 units to fit?
#16
Originally Posted by Triple8Sol
Awesome work as always!
Good to hear that the Z33 OEM clutch is a direct fit. Plenty of aftermarket choices there!
As far as the flywheel I guess JWT would is still our only direct fit flywheel option at this point huh. How time-consuming and/or costly would it be to get the Z33 units to fit?
Good to hear that the Z33 OEM clutch is a direct fit. Plenty of aftermarket choices there!
As far as the flywheel I guess JWT would is still our only direct fit flywheel option at this point huh. How time-consuming and/or costly would it be to get the Z33 units to fit?
#24
Matt,
I'm glad to see the car is still a screamer.
I'm curious. What would have happened if I had bought your car a couple of weeks ago and the tranny died on me? Based on our discussions, I hope you would have honored the fact that you knew how the car was driven and helped with the tranny replacement. Moot point now.
Word to the wise, be careful when considering the purchase of a car that has been taken to the drag strip and road courses. Unless, of course, you can afford to replace key components such as the tranny or engine.
Enjoy your toy.
I'm glad to see the car is still a screamer.
I'm curious. What would have happened if I had bought your car a couple of weeks ago and the tranny died on me? Based on our discussions, I hope you would have honored the fact that you knew how the car was driven and helped with the tranny replacement. Moot point now.
Word to the wise, be careful when considering the purchase of a car that has been taken to the drag strip and road courses. Unless, of course, you can afford to replace key components such as the tranny or engine.
Enjoy your toy.
#25
Originally Posted by bladerunr
What would have happened if I had bought your car a couple of weeks ago and the tranny died on me?
#27
Originally Posted by IceY2K1
SR20,
Do you plan on still trying to put the HLSD in the '04 when you do the flywheel?
Do you plan on still trying to put the HLSD in the '04 when you do the flywheel?
That is the plan if I decide to use this transmission vs. rebuilding the other one.
#28
Originally Posted by bladerunr
Matt,
I'm glad to see the car is still a screamer.
I'm glad to see the car is still a screamer.
Originally Posted by bladerunr
I'm curious. What would have happened if I had bought your car a couple of weeks ago and the tranny died on me? Based on our discussions, I hope you would have honored the fact that you knew how the car was driven and helped with the tranny replacement. Moot point now.
Originally Posted by bladerunr
Word to the wise, be careful when considering the purchase of a car that has been taken to the drag strip and road courses. Unless, of course, you can afford to replace key components such as the tranny or engine.
Enjoy your toy.
Enjoy your toy.
#30
I took the car out onto the secret Area 51 testing facility tonight. It bounced off it's rev limiter in 5th gear at about 145. The peak& hold on the SAFC showed 6810 rpm.
It is hard to tell from the butt dyno if the car is quicker but the new gearing seems to be a better match for my powerband.
It is hard to tell from the butt dyno if the car is quicker but the new gearing seems to be a better match for my powerband.
#32
Originally Posted by Larrio
is the 04 tranny still a cable shifter? any improvements on feel or whatnot from the 02-03 maximas?
#33
Matt,
I'm not trying to stir any sh#t up. I didn't forget anything about our discussions over the sale of your car. I do remember that you stated you would repair the transmission before selling it - repair the 3rd gear synchro. I also remember a statement about you fixing the body damage - which you hastily retracted 4 days later. And let's not rely on the warranty as a fallback. We all know that the dealer will try to slither out of any responsibility on a stock vehicle-even more on an upgraded and raced vehicle.
I don't live on the org so I had no idea the car has been driven the way that most people seem to know. That's all fine and good. Beat on the car all you want and brag about it. My point is this: it's wrong to try to sell a car that is owned and maintained by a skilled mechanic to anyone other than a lifetime org member or another skilled mechanic without full disclosure. It is not fair to someone looking for a decent 6spd car that won't require immediate repair to even keep it on the road it.
Your posts are informative and somewhat amusing. I've learned much so far. But what the hell do I know I've only posted 3 times. Have fun tinkering.
I'm not trying to stir any sh#t up. I didn't forget anything about our discussions over the sale of your car. I do remember that you stated you would repair the transmission before selling it - repair the 3rd gear synchro. I also remember a statement about you fixing the body damage - which you hastily retracted 4 days later. And let's not rely on the warranty as a fallback. We all know that the dealer will try to slither out of any responsibility on a stock vehicle-even more on an upgraded and raced vehicle.
I don't live on the org so I had no idea the car has been driven the way that most people seem to know. That's all fine and good. Beat on the car all you want and brag about it. My point is this: it's wrong to try to sell a car that is owned and maintained by a skilled mechanic to anyone other than a lifetime org member or another skilled mechanic without full disclosure. It is not fair to someone looking for a decent 6spd car that won't require immediate repair to even keep it on the road it.
Your posts are informative and somewhat amusing. I've learned much so far. But what the hell do I know I've only posted 3 times. Have fun tinkering.
#34
Originally Posted by bladerunr
Matt,
I'm not trying to stir any sh#t up.
I'm not trying to stir any sh#t up.
I didn't forget anything about our discussions over the sale of your car.
I do remember that you stated you would repair the transmission before selling it - repair the 3rd gear synchro. I also remember a statement about you fixing the body damage - which you hastily retracted 4 days later.
And let's not rely on the warranty as a fallback. We all know that the dealer will try to slither out of any responsibility on a stock vehicle-even more on an upgraded and raced vehicle.
I don't live on the org so I had no idea the car has been driven the way that most people seem to know. That's all fine and good. Beat on the car all you want and brag about it. My point is this: it's wrong to try to sell a car that is owned and maintained by a skilled mechanic to anyone other than a lifetime org member or another skilled mechanic without full disclosure. It is not fair to someone looking for a decent 6spd car that won't require immediate repair to even keep it on the road it.
Your posts are informative and somewhat amusing. I've learned much so far. But what the hell do I know I've only posted 3 times. Have fun tinkering.
#36
Matt,
All of this is a moot point now. You did tell me that you had raced it. I guess that I didn't realize that it had been beat so bad that the tranny would die 3 weeks after I looked at it. I guess I need to apologize for throwing this crap on the post. Sorry for getting off the subject. Thank goodness for both us that we couldn't come to an agreement on the car. Good luck with the car. Consider this topic closed.
All of this is a moot point now. You did tell me that you had raced it. I guess that I didn't realize that it had been beat so bad that the tranny would die 3 weeks after I looked at it. I guess I need to apologize for throwing this crap on the post. Sorry for getting off the subject. Thank goodness for both us that we couldn't come to an agreement on the car. Good luck with the car. Consider this topic closed.
#37
Originally Posted by bladerunr
Matt,
All of this is a moot point now. You did tell me that you had raced it. I guess that I didn't realize that it had been beat so bad that the tranny would die 3 weeks after I looked at it. I guess I need to apologize for throwing this crap on the post. Sorry for getting off the subject. Thank goodness for both us that we couldn't come to an agreement on the car. Good luck with the car. Consider this topic closed.
All of this is a moot point now. You did tell me that you had raced it. I guess that I didn't realize that it had been beat so bad that the tranny would die 3 weeks after I looked at it. I guess I need to apologize for throwing this crap on the post. Sorry for getting off the subject. Thank goodness for both us that we couldn't come to an agreement on the car. Good luck with the car. Consider this topic closed.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
vingodine
5th Generation Classifieds (2000-2003)
45
05-21-2016 01:46 PM