alternator 'noise' - not whine
#1
alternator 'noise' - not whine
Hey folks.
I'm a little confused here. I recently installed a new stereo in my car and I'm having noise come from my alternator itself (at least, I assume that's where it's coming from).
I can't hear any feedback or conductive/inductive noise in my stereo itself - it sounds perfectl fine. But my alternator makes a whining noise when the engine is revved.
I am running a 500Wx1 RMS bridged amp on my subs and a 75Wx4 amp for my highs.
I don't have a cap installed.
I have been unable to find a direct correlation between my amps being on and my engine/alt whining, but it obviously started after the stereo install.
Would a cap fix this problem? Do I need a 2-farad for 800W RMS?
Thanks,
-Drew
Cliffs: My alternator itself makes noise - 2002 SE (there is no audible noise from my stereo). Do I need a cap? What's wrong?
I'm a little confused here. I recently installed a new stereo in my car and I'm having noise come from my alternator itself (at least, I assume that's where it's coming from).
I can't hear any feedback or conductive/inductive noise in my stereo itself - it sounds perfectl fine. But my alternator makes a whining noise when the engine is revved.
I am running a 500Wx1 RMS bridged amp on my subs and a 75Wx4 amp for my highs.
I don't have a cap installed.
I have been unable to find a direct correlation between my amps being on and my engine/alt whining, but it obviously started after the stereo install.
Would a cap fix this problem? Do I need a 2-farad for 800W RMS?
Thanks,
-Drew
Cliffs: My alternator itself makes noise - 2002 SE (there is no audible noise from my stereo). Do I need a cap? What's wrong?
#2
Originally Posted by technogeeky
Hey folks.
I'm a little confused here. I recently installed a new stereo in my car and I'm having noise come from my alternator itself (at least, I assume that's where it's coming from).
I can't hear any feedback or conductive/inductive noise in my stereo itself - it sounds perfectl fine. But my alternator makes a whining noise when the engine is revved.
I am running a 500Wx1 RMS bridged amp on my subs and a 75Wx4 amp for my highs.
I don't have a cap installed.
I have been unable to find a direct correlation between my amps being on and my engine/alt whining, but it obviously started after the stereo install.
Would a cap fix this problem? Do I need a 2-farad for 800W RMS?
Thanks,
-Drew
Cliffs: My alternator itself makes noise - 2002 SE (there is no audible noise from my stereo). Do I need a cap? What's wrong?
I'm a little confused here. I recently installed a new stereo in my car and I'm having noise come from my alternator itself (at least, I assume that's where it's coming from).
I can't hear any feedback or conductive/inductive noise in my stereo itself - it sounds perfectl fine. But my alternator makes a whining noise when the engine is revved.
I am running a 500Wx1 RMS bridged amp on my subs and a 75Wx4 amp for my highs.
I don't have a cap installed.
I have been unable to find a direct correlation between my amps being on and my engine/alt whining, but it obviously started after the stereo install.
Would a cap fix this problem? Do I need a 2-farad for 800W RMS?
Thanks,
-Drew
Cliffs: My alternator itself makes noise - 2002 SE (there is no audible noise from my stereo). Do I need a cap? What's wrong?
If it helps:
I didn't do the under-the-hood wiring, but the front amp is under the passenger seat and the other amp is in the trunk. The power wire for both amps run seperately. The two amps are grounded to cleaned (shaved) ground points near the respective amps.
Would insufficient ground be a cause for the alternator itself making noise?
I haven't done any sort of 'hypergrounding' or whatever it's called.
#5
Originally Posted by machinehead
Things to check in this order:
1) Head Unit Ground.
2) Amp Grounds
3) Big 3 Upgrade
4) RCA's
1) Head Unit Ground.
2) Amp Grounds
3) Big 3 Upgrade
4) RCA's
There is NO audible noise or whine from the stereo itself. I can hear noise from the ENGINE, but not the stereo.
The instructions you listed in my estimation will correct stereo noise, not actual noisy alternators.
#6
Originally Posted by technogeeky
Just to make sure we're on the same page:
There is NO audible noise or whine from the stereo itself. I can hear noise from the ENGINE, but not the stereo.
The instructions you listed in my estimation will correct stereo noise, not actual noisy alternators.
There is NO audible noise or whine from the stereo itself. I can hear noise from the ENGINE, but not the stereo.
The instructions you listed in my estimation will correct stereo noise, not actual noisy alternators.
first you say there is a whine, then you tell us there is no audible noise or whine? Where would it be coming from, if it wasn't the stereo? Makes no sense.
If you really do have alternator whine coming through the speakers, then either it is on the power line or it is an earth problem. More precisely it is an EMC grounding and shielding 2-box problem of which exist hundreds of different reasons for electrical noise. Anyway you need to diagnose where it is getting in.
1. First try for the power line. Get an old mains transformer, dremel the winding off it, and wind, instead, a low-resistance iron choke using insulated 12G cable. As many turns as possible. Connect that in series with the power line to the amp that suffers from the noise.
Does the noise stop?
Yes: It's alternator commutation noise on the car's 12V bus and installing a cap might be one way to help that.
No: It's either getting in on the input or it is common-ground effect.
2. Test the signal input by unplugging it. Does the whine stop?
Yes: It's cable related.
No: It's common return problem (common-mode)
3. If it's common mode, it is because you are using multiple grounds.
In general ALL grounds should be returned to a common ground point. Called 'star' earthing. Read up on it.
And also: With screened cables used for signal, only ground one end of the screen! Otherwise you will set up earth loops.
#7
With all due respect, clive, you need to ease up on the electrical jargon. The means by which you have been suggesting your solutions are yes, effective and certainly backed by knowledge, but they are not the most practical for the majority of the users on this forum, myself included.
Technogeeky, when you have whine, you need to get all points of grounding, including RCA's, HU ground, and amplifiers.
Are you SURE the whine is not coming out of your speakers?
Technogeeky, when you have whine, you need to get all points of grounding, including RCA's, HU ground, and amplifiers.
Are you SURE the whine is not coming out of your speakers?
#8
Originally Posted by djfrestyl
With all due respect, clive, you need to ease up on the electrical jargon. The means by which you have been suggesting your solutions are yes, effective and certainly backed by knowledge, but they are not the most practical for the majority of the users on this forum, myself included.
Technogeeky, when you have whine, you need to get all points of grounding, including RCA's, HU ground, and amplifiers.
Are you SURE the whine is not coming out of your speakers?
Technogeeky, when you have whine, you need to get all points of grounding, including RCA's, HU ground, and amplifiers.
Are you SURE the whine is not coming out of your speakers?
I can usually hear it some AFTER turning off the headunit - it slowly fades away.
It's coming from my engine bay area.
#9
Originally Posted by clive
first you say there is a whine, then you tell us there is no audible noise or whine? Where would it be coming from, if it wasn't the stereo? Makes no sense.
If you read my post again, you'll see the magical words
from the stereo itself
That's entirely correct. The stereo doesn't make the noise I'm talking about.
Originally Posted by clive
If you really do have alternator whine coming through the speakers, then either it is on the power line or it is an earth problem. More precisely it is an EMC grounding and shielding 2-box problem of which exist hundreds of different reasons for electrical noise. Anyway you need to diagnose where it is getting in.
Originally Posted by clive
1. First try for the power line. Get an old mains transformer, dremel the winding off it, and wind, instead, a low-resistance iron choke using insulated 12G cable. As many turns as possible. Connect that in series with the power line to the amp that suffers from the noise.
Does the noise stop?
Yes: It's alternator commutation noise on the car's 12V bus and installing a cap might be one way to help that.
No: It's either getting in on the input or it is common-ground effect.
2. Test the signal input by unplugging it. Does the whine stop?
Yes: It's cable related.
No: It's common return problem (common-mode)
3. If it's common mode, it is because you are using multiple grounds.
In general ALL grounds should be returned to a common ground point. Called 'star' earthing. Read up on it.
And also: With screened cables used for signal, only ground one end of the screen! Otherwise you will set up earth loops.
Does the noise stop?
Yes: It's alternator commutation noise on the car's 12V bus and installing a cap might be one way to help that.
No: It's either getting in on the input or it is common-ground effect.
2. Test the signal input by unplugging it. Does the whine stop?
Yes: It's cable related.
No: It's common return problem (common-mode)
3. If it's common mode, it is because you are using multiple grounds.
In general ALL grounds should be returned to a common ground point. Called 'star' earthing. Read up on it.
And also: With screened cables used for signal, only ground one end of the screen! Otherwise you will set up earth loops.
If there is some grounding problem, I submit that the alternator may be overloaded becasue of it. I'm not entirely sure how alternators work, and I'm having trouble deciphering your electrical jargon despite my somewhat-educated background.
I am not lying to you people - it would do no good for me. My stereo works great. I can't, at any point, hear anything other than music in my stereo. If I turn the volume to 0, however, I can hear my alternator itself quite well.
#15
Well frankly, this thread is in the wrong area! This isn't to do with hifi. This is to do with car electrics and should be in the thread for your appropriate generation of car.
If the alternator itself is whining, then the bearings must be shot. I'd take it out and have the bearings replaced and at the same time, replace the field brushes, the two little graphite blocks on springs.
If the alternator itself is whining, then the bearings must be shot. I'd take it out and have the bearings replaced and at the same time, replace the field brushes, the two little graphite blocks on springs.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
My Coffee
New Member Introductions
15
06-06-2017 02:01 PM