das

ah, a similar option:

with all the problems with Frankencar customer service and getting the intake on time, I just order the full Berk Tech intake. similar design, higher grade steel and only $99 shipped with an 8" K&N!!

plus, I ordered it one day and it shipped out the next. should be in my hot hands on monday.....

check the group deal section for more info....


another bit of mind change..... (2 cents worth)


das

Lumbee1

Scientific evidence

And your measurement technique was??? Temperature scope owns joo!

jessemcd

im not sure if the bigger filter will make the intake louder but, it will suck in more air and thats what i want!

spirilis

iTrader: (2)

yeah, 92 SE-R 02 SE just got

Dave Jr

Took the words right out of my mouth

And again since when does a cold air intake HAVE to be in the fender. Is there some kind of Auto Dictionary that I don't know about ?? CAI = Fender mounted Filter system

As stated before I am not bad mouthing anything any intake system over stock is an improvement. It all depends on your needs and wants.

jjames

since people who have cold air intakes have been looking to intake cold air.

MannyNJ2k2max

iTrader: (3)

you should dyno your car if you swear by the power it makes....that way you can truly say its worth it.....and we can see where in the powerband it helps.....
because the general concensus is that the Injen doesnt create much power up top.....

for some reason lv2dmax (the thread starter) is not happy with the gains....

Dave Jr

Ohhh I see the only place to get cold are is from the fender. It's so clear to me now.......

MannyNJ2k2max

iTrader: (3)

In a way its unclear how on a summer day the Injen could suck in anything but
warm air off steaming asphalt......

my Franken is a CAI anytime its under 50F Degrees ....its freggin' 20F degrees out right now

Dave Jr

I've never stated that the Injen was making more power than any of the other intakes. The issue at hand here is that the Injen is claimed not to be a CAI. I disagree do to the temperatures that I have seen on the intake piping taken at the source of air.

You are right dyno's tell all at least we think but considering all the HP loss we have seen lately with the TC ECU and the Headers. If the people Dynoing the cars don't know what there doing the numbers are no better proof than an A$$ dyno meter.

So power wise my " opinion " for my car and my situation is the injen feels better in the mid to high end power band. I am not selling the Injen just adding my opinion as was asked by the thread starter.

Once again I will state it. Any intake system over stock is an improvement.

MannyNJ2k2max

iTrader: (3)

We are talking a hp here and there- in either case- CAI or not....
Glad you like it Dave!

Dave Jr

Yeah I like the cold weather car likey me likey. I had the same thoughts this past summer when i did my testing with the intakes. That is the main reason I did my testing. As for the hot asphalt and air the fender is getting the air from the same place its still the same air.

The fender mounted CAI is completely enclosed from the outside with all the sheilds. When you cut the hole look inside you can't see anything but the funder and sheilds. In a warm summer day this will cause a more severe heat soaking condition. Even when the car is moving again it doesn't see direct air flow because of it being completely enclosed. It's kinda like driving down the road with your windows up. Yes there is air there but your not seeing the air flow.

If you look down in front where the Injen CAI would go you see ground. There will be more elements let in but will also allow more air flow.

If the fender had that much cooler air flow why aren't intercoolers mounted there ???

Dave Jr

Point taken ! But I just ment the debate between me and a few other members not the topic of the post.

And in my case I just wanted to clarify that I wasn't stating that Injen made more power than other intakes I was just defending it's status as a true CAI

Dave Jr

It was 6 degrees here on the way to work and is now about 15

Lumbee1

From this we can conclude:

Frankencar - Hot Air Intake

Place Racing - Cold Air Intake

Injen - Colder Air (fact) Warm Air (opinion) Intake?

MannyNJ2k2max

iTrader: (3)

the Franken is a foot and a half away from being a CAI (place racing)

ghostrider17

iTrader: (6)

Where's the best place to buy a PRCAI????

Their website only offers a brochure to be mailed....

gr

MannyNJ2k2max

iTrader: (3)

www.custommaxima.com
and Cattman sells their own version of it
www.cattmanperformance.com

Dave Jr

Now this would probably require the cutting of the stock air box but has anyone with a pop charger tried using the stock air scoop that sits at the base of the hood that brings in air from the outside?? I can't remember the actual shape at this point but leaving that connected it would bring in cooler air from outside of the vehicle and allow that to flow towards the filter element that may not be a bad Idea to allow cooler air flow into the engine compartment.

Am I making sense? I think I confused myself

BiggD23

Yes, I've seen this done or attempted by several org members. The one that I can remember he used dryer tubing from Home Depot and like you said he had it flowing out right near the cone filter. Now if only someone could come up with a nicely fabricated tube to do this and sell it I would to them. It would make my intake decision alot easier!!

MannyNJ2k2max

iTrader: (3)

Weapon R sells a ram air kit for their Dragon filters
but I'm not sure how effective it could be-
http://www.weapon-r.com/ramair.html

92 SE-R 02 SE

by who? i seen the INJENS on the 3.5..sorry not right behind the rad but close enough... wow..injen sure looks pretty...im not about looks.... INJEN IS NOT CAI... PERIOD. CATTMANN AND PRI are. thats why i got frankencar...

Dave Jr

Well lets see. What makes an intake a cold air intake? Well that would be an intake that would take in COLDER air than the stock air box. Fender mount intakes will take in colder air and so will the front mounts like the Injen. I have already proven this.

I'll ask you again since when does a cold air intake HAVE to be located in the fender to be a cold air intake ?????

If a cold air intake had to be mounted in the fender to be a CAI why name it a CAI then. Why would anyone else use that term CAI if it had to be mounted in the fender ?

Lumbee1

Are cold air intakes not measured by the temperature of the air coming in at the filter? If the temperature of the air at the end of an Injen intake is COOLER than that of the Place Racing, why would you label the Injen WAI and the Place Racing CAI?

It has been proven scientifically that the temperature at the filter of an Injen intake is colder than Place Racing with a temperature scope.

Dave Jr

The testing wasn't done with a Place Racing or Injen intake. The fender mount that was tested was an AEM and the front mount was a custom made intake. It was still polished SS just like the injen.

I am not sure where or how they measure the air coming in but a cold air intake simply takes in colder air than the stock air box. And it DOSN'T have to be mounted in the fender to do so.

Lumbee this is not directed towards you so please ignore.

I am done debating this simply put a CAI is an intake that takes in a cold air charge and uses it to make raw horse power on a NA vehicle. It simply doesn't matter were the air comes from. Below the car, under the car, in the fender what ever. An intake DOES NOT have to be mounted in the fender to be a cold air intake. PERIOD.

skandalouz

iTrader: (2)

werd......

00MaxSE

iTrader: (25)

Yeah, I used to have the Injen too and I sold it about 6 months ago when I got my Frankencar.

Shift_VQ

I plan on installing an injen with the apexi filter I have on my frankencar. It'll look better and i think it will perform better too. The Frank is pulling hot air in...I dont see how that can help performance.

Lumbee1

I am an Injen fan but don't overlook the fact that at speed a Hot Air Intake like Frankencar will perform better because the engine bay will have significant air circulation to cool the air temp. I am not saying it will be better or worse than Injen, just better than if it was sitting in rush hour traffic in the summer. For the highway cruisers that rarely see bumper to bumper conditions, the Frankencar might be a better choice. For myself and the traffic around Research Triangle Park, there was only one choice.

Shift_VQ

is it true that with an injen you lose torque? and why would a frankencar be better than an injen on the highway? Dont both intakes have the same air circulation at highway speeds, especially if you combine an injen intake with an apexi filter???

spirilis

iTrader: (2)

I've heard with the Injen you GAIN torque... low-end torque especially (longer tube)

Dave B

Are you making this up as you go along?

A cold air intake (Place Racing) doesn't mean it has to take air from the fender, but it's typically the best place to draw the coolest air within close proximity of the throttle body. I can assure you that the air in the fender (which is not near as enclosed as you believe), is the best place to draw the coolest air possible with the hood down, especially on a hot day. The piping of the PR pipe is cool to the touch on a hot day after sitting in traffic. A HAI (Frankencar, Injen) will be scalding hot. I know, I've had all types of setups (no Injen, but I've touched it on a hot day - deadly). The Injen intake sits in absolutely the worst place possible in terms of sucking in air. It sits in close proximity of the cooling fans which PULL OUT heat (ie it sucks hot air out of the bay, not into the bay). ALso, the Injen is damn close to the exhaust manifold and a baking engine block. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to understand why Injen intakes can cause pinging on hot days. DINAN (the BMW tuner) only uses true fender-style CAIs because they want intakes that make proven power under all conditions. They understand that putting the intake in the fender makes the best power. Thier M3/M5/3-series/5-series/7-series/Z-series intakes all pull from the fender. They know that the "POP" and HAI setup make a couple more HP in the upper rpms, but the CAIs give more consistent power across are broader powerband. Remember, power under the curve owns.

Hmmm...last time I checked turbo Audi's, 300ZX TTs, and 1.8T VW/Audi place their intercoolers in the fenders.


Dave

MaxAtack

I rarely say this, but somebody's theory just got

And I was lookin to get an Injen too..........

PearlWhtMaX2000

iTrader: (5)

so are u saying that PR CAI is the way to go?? because i too was going to get an injen some time soon

Dave B

IMO, the GAB intake or PR CAI are probably the best intakes to go with for all around performance. While the GAB does pull in some hot air, it pulls a majority of it's air from nose of the car plus the GAB uses much the OEM plastic intake which doesn't heat soak as badly. The PR CAI (style) is probably the most ideal, but is usually the most expensive.

The Injen, while looking quite nice, is situated in the worst possible location. I constantly read about people noting the location of the filter, but people need to also know about the placement of the metal intake pipe which is right next to a large mass of hot metal (block, head, exhaust manifold, intake manifold).


Dave

MannyNJ2k2max

iTrader: (3)

thanx for clearing that up....for the non-believers...

MaximaDisciple

All the things you've said may be true, but according to many people with the Injen and many dyno test there IS an improvement over the stock intake unit. So if its the worst possible location then why does it improve the hp & torque numbers over stock?

MannyNJ2k2max

iTrader: (3)

The Injen (as any other intake) produces gains ....theres no question about that
the issue at hand is whether its a CAI - the PR intake is truly a CAI because its set up allows
the best intake path- away from the engine.....and where the coolest air
is avalable...

Good point on Dinan...

Shift_VQ

So how much better is a PR intake than an injen? I am about to sell my frankencar for an injen but use the apexi filter on the injen...but this is making me think I dont want to do that...The only thing turning me off on the PR is the whole drilling idea.

So basically if the injen will not produce noticeable gains compared to the frankencar but PR will...I think Im sold on PR...help

ckohl23

you guys are arguing way too much about the temperature of the incoming air. you're forgetting an important advantage of a CAI over a WAI: the resonance of the airflow created by the long smooth tube. it's a nice continuous airflow (actually has a bit higher psi than normal, but nowhere near forced induction). hard to explain so look it up