iansw

iTrader: (7)

Last summer, I did a stupid downshift from high in 3rd Gear to 2nd gear on accident!! (Meant to shift to 4th, missed)

That was quite a while ago and the car still feels fine. Everything I've read tells me that the engine should have popped right then and there, leaving me by the side of the road.

Anyone else done something dumb like this and lived to tell about it?

Is there anything I should be looking at mechanically just to make sure there isn't some unknown damage? (besides compression test, which is fine)

Thanks!

JClaw

iTrader: (17)

Yeah check for compression. Highest mine's seen on accident is 6800-6900, which doesn't hurt the engine at all.

I30tMikeD

iTrader: (8)

I did that. Shifted at 7k from 3rd to 2nd. My motor was not as lucky.

Jeff92se

iTrader: (82)

Little late to worry Ian. If it hasn't broke by now..............

mtrai760

iTrader: (19)

Ha ha, yeah, if its still fine now, your probably good. Did you record the highest RPM on your SAFC? Tachometer would be horribly inaccurate at that level. I accidently ran my old integra up that high, and never had a problem. Heard a lot of stories though. M3's are especially susceptible to this, and there ECU records it all, making warranty claims useless.

Kevlo911

iTrader: (36)

That happened



Those peices are suppose to be on the Cam

Stephen Max

iTrader: (59)

The horror! The horrror!

Nealoc187

iTrader: (23)

I did it 3 times in my 96. Twice when I first got it, and once like two years ago. No ill effects whatsoever. Ran faster and faster until the day I started de-modding it. If your car didn't pop right away, it didn't do any damage. Also was in BriGuyMax's 97 when he did it. No damage.

Blu

iTrader: (63)

I did that boosted running the 3.33 pulley. Yea it recorded 9800 rpms on the DEFI link and I bent a couple exhaust valves. Had 5 compression in one cylider and 55 in another. You are lucky.....

vortechpower

iTrader: (1)

nope, never did that but I know someone that did and had to get a new motor...

mtcookson

iTrader: (2)

something similar happened to my in my 3rd gen. i was passing someone and shifted from 3rd to 4th pretty hard. the clutch slipped real bad and i saw the tach run up to 7,000+ rpm, which was recorded by the s-afc. happened to me another time and i saw the tach read 8,000+ rpm but the s-afc said only high 7,000 rpm. was still pretty scary but luckily nothing happened.

iansw

iTrader: (7)

Yeah - I was sure I was good now - mostly just wanted to hear some stories and make absolutely sure there isn't anything else besides compression to check.

Blu

iTrader: (63)

well after it happened to me the car idled terrible, cammed realy hard etc. So you would more than likely know if anything was wrong, but I would do a compression check just to be 100% sure there arent any hurt cyliders.

Zack342

iTrader: (89)

Happened to me in my 99. shifted from 3rd at about 95mph into 2nd and tach shot to 7500rpm....that was about a year ago

chaos356

A friend did that to anothers bmw dinan 3 series. Messed the head up.

Jeff92se

iTrader: (82)

This one time at band camp................

C MAX

iTrader: (4)

yeh same thing happend to me. im auto but my gear shift lock wasnt working and i accidentally knocked it in 2nd. all i know is im revving out over 7000rpm then bent a valve.

mtrai760

iTrader: (19)

We all know what happend to you at band camp jeffy...

Kevlo911

iTrader: (36)

We don't haev a lock like some cars do. We can throw it in 1 doing 100 and blow the tranny yot bits and peices. Some cars you put it in one and it will do nothing.

Mximus

yeah, i did about the same in my car too. I was going about 50 or 55 in second and shifted into first instead of third when i first got my car. the tach read about 8000 when i did that. It scared the **** outta me but i poped the hood just to listen and it didnt even seem to faze it. Shes a pretty rugged engine.

95turbo gxe

iTrader: (25)

nope never happend to me Im the master shifter.

But their was once that I rev up a little high and the safc recorded 6400rpms

Stillen Maxima

iTrader: (50)

Well my friend has a 2004 6 speed coming in the beltway she was in 5th gear and missed 6th to 2nd I was like OHHHH SHHH***** and her Max is still perfect

THT

iTrader: (8)

How, pray tell, do you shift to second when you meant to hit sixth?

~THT

98SEBlackMax

iTrader: (9)

Ive never been able to shift it back into 1st gear once the car was moving, it seems to have a lock out on my car.

I did the 3 to 2 once by accident when I first started driving stick, shot to about 7000 on the tach and no ill effects came about. To avoid the 3 to 2 when I want to goto 4th I throw the shift down and towards the front passenger's seat. The car can't go into reverse when going forward (well not without that awful grinding) and it saves you from going into 2nd. Ever since I adopted this method Ive never screwed up the 3 ~ 4 shift.

Kevlo911

iTrader: (36)

I am talking about hte Autotragic...