Talked w/ a Nissan Tech today (VTC related)
#81
Ok after driving Max hard today I never got him above 5100- MABYE 5400 RPM before shift. So why on earth should I care about the last 1k of RPM?? I'm not going to the track so WTF?? What is the purpose of the VTC's really?? Just a ploy to be able to state HP and TQ numbers? If I'm wrong help me understand why I should care about the VTC's if I'm not going a-racing???
#82
Ok after driving Max hard today I never got him above 5000- MABYE 5100 RPM before shift. So why on earth should I care about the last 1k of RPM?? I'm not going to the track so WTF?? What is the purpose of the VTC's really?? Just a ploy to be able to state HP and TQ numbers? If I'm wrong help me understand why I should care about the VTC's if I'm not going a-racing???
#83
I'm brand new here. Got a 1992 Pearl white SE/Auto. VTC's (volunteers for what that stands for?) sound like a 1983 Mercedes Turbo Diesel at startup. Nissan Pimps said it would cost over $2000 to fix. I read what you guys had to say, but how feasible is it to fix these things myself?
#84
Originally Posted by ProfessionalMax
I'm brand new here. Got a 1992 Pearl white SE/Auto. VTC's (volunteers for what that stands for?) sound like a 1983 Mercedes Turbo Diesel at startup. Nissan Pimps said it would cost over $2000 to fix. I read what you guys had to say, but how feasible is it to fix these things myself?
T=timing
C=control
To replace the vtc's you really need to have more then moderate mechanical skills...Not for the beginner....
To ground them is fairly easy,it should quiet them down for you a little..Here is a website that will show you how to ground them....
http://www.geocities.com/craigbrace/ goto the HOW TO section....
#86
Hey! I'm new here as well. This is my 2nd Maxima, I had a 90 SE, so this problem is new to me. I just got my car and it's doing the same thing. I looked around the web for a while and here is the best description of the problem I found:
"ngine:
VE30DE
System:
Engine Mechanical
Symptom:
Top engine noise
This engine has a variable timing control (VTC) system. The intake camshafts are advanced by using oil pressure on the intake camshaft sprockets under certain conditions. Oil pressure to the sprockets is controlled by the VTC solenoids, and the solenoids in turn are controlled by the engine computer (PCM).
The common cause of top engine noise on this engine has been the intake camshaft sprockets themselves. The VTC solenoids are "off" when cam timing is not being advanced. When the VTC solenoids are turned "on" by the PCM, intake camshaft timing is advanced.
To determine if the noise is coming from the VTC sprockets, unplug the VTC solenoids and energize each solenoid. The power supply to the VTC solenoids is the red wire with black tracer (R/B), so jump the battery voltage supply to the solenoid that the R/B wire goes to. When the noise is present at idle, jump the other terminal of the VTC solenoid to ground. This is the yellow wire with green tracer going to it. This will energize or turn "on" the VTC solenoid and results in pressurizing the sprocket and advancing the cam timing.
Energize one VTC solenoid at a time to see if the noise decreases or goes away. Also energize both solenoids at the same time. Is the noise gone? If it is, a new spring assembly can be installed in the VTC sprocket to tighten it up and correct the problem. The sprocket needs to be pressed apart to replace this spring. Make sure to scribe a mark on the sprocket before pressing it apart so the sprocket can be reassembled in the same alignment, or a noise could result.
Other causes of top engine noise on these engines: timing chain tensioner noise, debris in an oil galley restricting oil to the VTC sprockets or chain tensioner, or from the hydraulic lifters themselves ... although the noise is seldom from the lifters.
Note: Nissan's TSB No. NTB95-022 addresses this issue. "
Here is my question, shouldn't this mean that if I grounded it, I would loose power at the low RPM, not the high?
Also, can anybody give a good description of taking VTC off and rebuilding them? I'm sure I can do it myself, but I can't find any good info on it, and I'd like to have some, would make me feel a lot safer when I do it. So can anybody help?
"ngine:
VE30DE
System:
Engine Mechanical
Symptom:
Top engine noise
This engine has a variable timing control (VTC) system. The intake camshafts are advanced by using oil pressure on the intake camshaft sprockets under certain conditions. Oil pressure to the sprockets is controlled by the VTC solenoids, and the solenoids in turn are controlled by the engine computer (PCM).
The common cause of top engine noise on this engine has been the intake camshaft sprockets themselves. The VTC solenoids are "off" when cam timing is not being advanced. When the VTC solenoids are turned "on" by the PCM, intake camshaft timing is advanced.
To determine if the noise is coming from the VTC sprockets, unplug the VTC solenoids and energize each solenoid. The power supply to the VTC solenoids is the red wire with black tracer (R/B), so jump the battery voltage supply to the solenoid that the R/B wire goes to. When the noise is present at idle, jump the other terminal of the VTC solenoid to ground. This is the yellow wire with green tracer going to it. This will energize or turn "on" the VTC solenoid and results in pressurizing the sprocket and advancing the cam timing.
Energize one VTC solenoid at a time to see if the noise decreases or goes away. Also energize both solenoids at the same time. Is the noise gone? If it is, a new spring assembly can be installed in the VTC sprocket to tighten it up and correct the problem. The sprocket needs to be pressed apart to replace this spring. Make sure to scribe a mark on the sprocket before pressing it apart so the sprocket can be reassembled in the same alignment, or a noise could result.
Other causes of top engine noise on these engines: timing chain tensioner noise, debris in an oil galley restricting oil to the VTC sprockets or chain tensioner, or from the hydraulic lifters themselves ... although the noise is seldom from the lifters.
Note: Nissan's TSB No. NTB95-022 addresses this issue. "
Here is my question, shouldn't this mean that if I grounded it, I would loose power at the low RPM, not the high?
Also, can anybody give a good description of taking VTC off and rebuilding them? I'm sure I can do it myself, but I can't find any good info on it, and I'd like to have some, would make me feel a lot safer when I do it. So can anybody help?
#87
Originally Posted by valz23
Also, can anybody give a good description of taking VTC off and rebuilding them? I'm sure I can do it myself, but I can't find any good info on it, and I'd like to have some, would make me feel a lot safer when I do it. So can anybody help?
You need to have the FSM to do this job....
#88
Actually I just sold my everyday driver, a 12-second DSM (my 2nd), and with that car I went through 2 engines, both times I changed them in my drive way. I'm sure I could rebuild a VTC myself, and if I can't, I have a real good freind who owns a shop and who's been working as a mechanic for over 20 years, I'm sure he'll give me a hand. It's just it would be nice to get directions from somebody who's done it before. Like some of you guys mentioned, there are plenty of Nissan cert. mechanics who can't do the job right, so not matter how much experience one has, it's always nice to have directions.
#89
Originally Posted by valz23
Actually I just sold my everyday driver, a 12-second DSM (my 2nd), and with that car I went through 2 engines, both times I changed them in my drive way. I'm sure I could rebuild a VTC myself, and if I can't, I have a real good freind who owns a shop and who's been working as a mechanic for over 20 years, I'm sure he'll give me a hand. It's just it would be nice to get directions from somebody who's done it before. Like some of you guys mentioned, there are plenty of Nissan cert. mechanics who can't do the job right, so not matter how much experience one has, it's always nice to have directions.
The directions are in the FSM. Its a 50+ step process, no one has done a true writeup because if you aren't following the FSM, you probably shouldn't be doing it no matter how skilled you are. The FSM is available for download if you look hard enough.
![Nervous](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/nervous.gif)
#90
Here is a link that has a lot of pictures of the VTC rebuild job. CraigB took these when I went over to DaveP's house while the guys and awsm66 were swapping motors.
This might help a lot of people here:
http://community.webshots.com/album/228997037rnrRbN/1
This might help a lot of people here:
http://community.webshots.com/album/228997037rnrRbN/1
#91
Thanks a lot for the pics! I have a question, I've been trying to research this issue on this website, but neather the search, nor the FAQ sre seem to be working. I'm sure this subject has been posted here many times before. What's the best way to go about searching this site?
Thank you!
Thank you!
#92
Originally Posted by valz23
Thanks a lot for the pics! I have a question, I've been trying to research this issue on this website, but neather the search, nor the FAQ sre seem to be working. I'm sure this subject has been posted here many times before. What's the best way to go about searching this site?
Thank you!
Thank you!
They originally took away the search function b/c it was using too much bandwidth.
The FAQs that they are referring to, you will find at the top of the 3rd gen forum. They will be labeled as Stickies. There is a lot of info about VTCs there.
Another way to search this site is to do an Advanced Google search. Specify the domain "maxima.org" and only search that domain. You will get some results that way, but they will only be really old threads that the Google spider has already crawled.
#93
Originally Posted by CyMax
Ok after driving Max hard today I never got him above 5100- MABYE 5400 RPM before shift. So why on earth should I care about the last 1k of RPM?? I'm not going to the track so WTF?? What is the purpose of the VTC's really?? Just a ploy to be able to state HP and TQ numbers? If I'm wrong help me understand why I should care about the VTC's if I'm not going a-racing???
#95
Originally Posted by tman
bumping this question - curious about this myself. how much real-world difference do the VTCs really make?
So, there is plenty of real world difference by having the VTCs grounded. But if you never take your VE above 5K, then ground them, be happy. You won't notice any difference in acceleration. But if you're like me and the majority of the people on this board that have a VE, then you take it to redline almost every day.
![Big Grin](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/biggrin.gif)
Since mine are still ticking, even after my failed VTC repair attempt, I wired a switch that allows me to ground them easily from inside the car. I only ground them when I'm in parking lots and I feel embarassed to have what people think is a diesel under the hood.
#96
I called Courtesy to order the VTC repair kits yesterday...I think the guy was new because he wanted to ask another rep about them. The other guy said the kits were useless and I should replace them with new units at the tune of $800. That ain't gonna happen. He faxed me a page that showed the cams, chains, guides, and tensioners but it didn't have the breakdown of the VTCs. I found the TSB regarding VTCs online. It gives the part number so I ordered them per the part number. Incidentally, I called the local Nissan stealer...that guy said that the part number was good but did not apply to my engine (VE) I don't think he even knew the difference. Anyway, the springs are on order from Courtesy. These are going into a complete rebuild with all new timing components so I am hoping for no noise except from the Greddy exhaust that arrived today! WOOHOO!!!
![doublethumbsup](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/dblthumb2.gif)
#97
Originally Posted by Grace_Imports
I called Courtesy to order the VTC repair kits yesterday...I think the guy was new because he wanted to ask another rep about them. The other guy said the kits were useless and I should replace them with new units at the tune of $800. That ain't gonna happen. He faxed me a page that showed the cams, chains, guides, and tensioners but it didn't have the breakdown of the VTCs. I found the TSB regarding VTCs online. It gives the part number so I ordered them per the part number. Incidentally, I called the local Nissan stealer...that guy said that the part number was good but did not apply to my engine (VE) I don't think he even knew the difference. Anyway, the springs are on order from Courtesy. These are going into a complete rebuild with all new timing components so I am hoping for no noise except from the Greddy exhaust that arrived today! WOOHOO!!! ![doublethumbsup](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/dblthumb2.gif)
![doublethumbsup](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/dblthumb2.gif)
#98
Originally Posted by lanedrifters
I was always thinking that the loss of spring tension that causes the clacking was actually causing the sprocket to change tension on the chain as the cam lobes came around and that it would also cause a "stalling" of the cam for a quick period which could cause a power loss..??? Your thoughts?
![Smilie](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
#99
Originally Posted by lanedrifters
Another thought, do you think the clattering would be enough to interfere with or cause false knock sensor triggering? That would cause noticable power loss..
#100
Originally Posted by valz23
Actually I just sold my everyday driver, a 12-second DSM (my 2nd), and with that car I went through 2 engines, both times I changed them in my drive way. I'm sure I could rebuild a VTC myself, and if I can't, I have a real good freind who owns a shop and who's been working as a mechanic for over 20 years, I'm sure he'll give me a hand. It's just it would be nice to get directions from somebody who's done it before. Like some of you guys mentioned, there are plenty of Nissan cert. mechanics who can't do the job right, so not matter how much experience one has, it's always nice to have directions.
![Smilie](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
#101
Originally Posted by Mizeree_X
The directions are in the FSM. Its a 50+ step process, no one has done a true writeup because if you aren't following the FSM, you probably shouldn't be doing it no matter how skilled you are. The FSM is available for download if you look hard enough. ![Nervous](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/nervous.gif)
![Nervous](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/nervous.gif)
![Embarrassment](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/redface.gif)
premade particle board cabinets come with better instructions
![Embarrassment](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/redface.gif)
#102
Originally Posted by Aaron92SE
Here is a link that has a lot of pictures of the VTC rebuild job. CraigB took these when I went over to DaveP's house while the guys and awsm66 were swapping motors.
This might help a lot of people here:
http://community.webshots.com/album/228997037rnrRbN/1
This might help a lot of people here:
http://community.webshots.com/album/228997037rnrRbN/1
![Embarrassment](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/redface.gif)
#103
Originally Posted by Jeff92se
If you only reving the VE to 5400 rpm, you ain't even trying. My Ve with mods + JWT ecu is still PULLING when it hits the raised limiter at 7200-ish rpm.
mine used to pull HARD to redline and then try to run past it.
Originally Posted by Grace_Imports
I called Courtesy to order the VTC repair kits yesterday...I think the guy was new because he wanted to ask another rep about them. The other guy said the kits were useless and I should replace them with new units at the tune of $800. That ain't gonna happen. He faxed me a page that showed the cams, chains, guides, and tensioners but it didn't have the breakdown of the VTCs. I found the TSB regarding VTCs online. It gives the part number so I ordered them per the part number. Incidentally, I called the local Nissan stealer...that guy said that the part number was good but did not apply to my engine (VE) I don't think he even knew the difference. Anyway, the springs are on order from Courtesy. These are going into a complete rebuild with all new timing components so I am hoping for no noise except from the Greddy exhaust that arrived today! WOOHOO!!! ![doublethumbsup](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/dblthumb2.gif)
![doublethumbsup](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/dblthumb2.gif)
The kit's are not side specific, they are identical
Glad to hear you bought the GReddy, you will be extremely happy with it. You cannot buy a better exhaust
![Smilie](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
![jump](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/jump.gif)
Also people should realize the VTC's, like the VE 5spd Power Valve, are primarily load based and RPM is only used as a guideline. The VTC's are not grounded by default which was implied earlier. If you know your car well enough (and have a 5spd as you have much more control) you can go the entire RPM range from idle to redline without the VTC's grounding once (wouldn't do it where other cars are around as it will take a while, again if you know your car you'll know what I mean).
If you have a basic understanding of how a camshaft determines an engines behavior it is very easy to see how it all works and why. You will also realize 'hey, if I do this, then this will happen', and you might be surprised with what you can do
![GrinNo](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/grin_no.gif)
#104
Originally Posted by MrGone
atleast give credit to the guy that came up with that method of rebuilding them ![Embarrassment](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/redface.gif)
![Embarrassment](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/redface.gif)
#105
Neither Courtesy or the local stealer could come up with the kit so I had them order the part number on the TSB which is 13072-97EOO. They were about $30 a piece x 2. I hope to have the short block assembled this weekend and it completed next weekend. It's getting cold up here so I'd like to have her running before it's too cold.
I would add the importance of oil changes and keeping passages free and clear to get oil where it's supposed to go. The old 5MGE Toyotas were notorious for cams and followers going bad which was very costly to repair. I would always find a small clogged oil passage near each lifter from lack of maintenance. The last time I priced the cams followers and lifters were over $1200. Even machine shops would miss cleaning them. I know it's a different engine but the principal still applies.
I would add the importance of oil changes and keeping passages free and clear to get oil where it's supposed to go. The old 5MGE Toyotas were notorious for cams and followers going bad which was very costly to repair. I would always find a small clogged oil passage near each lifter from lack of maintenance. The last time I priced the cams followers and lifters were over $1200. Even machine shops would miss cleaning them. I know it's a different engine but the principal still applies.
#108
Originally Posted by Aaron92SE
I don't know what method you are talking about. I was just linking the pics CraigB took.
#109
Originally Posted by valz23
Thank you! I'll try to start on it next week, I'll let you know if I have any???
I have a spare assembly or two laying around aswell. It is actually very simple.
Also I was talking with the parts manager at the Bellevue Nissan (on NE 8th) about the VTC kits. He's never heard of them before, but could get them once I gave him the part number (I couldn't remember it off the top of my head). I was going to try and set up something for VE guys who couldn't find the kits, he said he would be able to do out of state orders
![Smilie](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
The last few times I had to drive to Younker, Performance, and Burien Nissan to get parts. I had the best luck with Performance, but Bellevue seems good aswell and it's a drive I don't mind making
![Smilie](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
#110
only way to tell would be to monitor the ignition timing in real time
#111
true, I guess they both do the same thing, although monitoring the knock might be better.
come to think of it, I've done that before on my SAFC-II. Didn't notice a difference.
come to think of it, I've done that before on my SAFC-II. Didn't notice a difference.
#112
Originally Posted by lanedrifters
Being that the knock map is only a couple of degrees off, i would think that monitoring the knock sensor voltage(ac) would be better, but my vtc's dont clatter so i cant test it...
#114
Originally Posted by MrGone
no prob. I don't envy you though (getting them off the engine with it still in the car kind of sucks, it's completely doable, just a tight squeeze compared to other things).
I have a spare assembly or two laying around aswell. It is actually very simple.
Also I was talking with the parts manager at the Bellevue Nissan (on NE 8th) about the VTC kits. He's never heard of them before, but could get them once I gave him the part number (I couldn't remember it off the top of my head). I was going to try and set up something for VE guys who couldn't find the kits, he said he would be able to do out of state orders![Smilie](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
The last few times I had to drive to Younker, Performance, and Burien Nissan to get parts. I had the best luck with Performance, but Bellevue seems good aswell and it's a drive I don't mind making![Smilie](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
I have a spare assembly or two laying around aswell. It is actually very simple.
Also I was talking with the parts manager at the Bellevue Nissan (on NE 8th) about the VTC kits. He's never heard of them before, but could get them once I gave him the part number (I couldn't remember it off the top of my head). I was going to try and set up something for VE guys who couldn't find the kits, he said he would be able to do out of state orders
![Smilie](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
The last few times I had to drive to Younker, Performance, and Burien Nissan to get parts. I had the best luck with Performance, but Bellevue seems good aswell and it's a drive I don't mind making
![Smilie](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
I live in Seattle, by the way. I just talked to the Burien Nissan lady, and she said it would take just a few days to get one. My mom lives in Burien, so I'll order them there tommorow. If you have a spare assembly to practice on, I'd buy it from you cheap. Let me know.
#115
Originally Posted by valz23
\
I live in Seattle, by the way. I just talked to the Burien Nissan lady, and she said it would take just a few days to get one. My mom lives in Burien, so I'll order them there tommorow. If you have a spare assembly to practice on, I'd buy it from you cheap. Let me know.
I live in Seattle, by the way. I just talked to the Burien Nissan lady, and she said it would take just a few days to get one. My mom lives in Burien, so I'll order them there tommorow. If you have a spare assembly to practice on, I'd buy it from you cheap. Let me know.
I'm in Issaquah
![Smilie](https://maxima.org/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
#116
Do any of you guys look in the For Sale section?
I have a NEVER USED rebuilt set of VTCs for sale...I am in Oregon and you could get them in a matter of days.
http://forums.maxima.org/showthread.php?t=427052
I have a NEVER USED rebuilt set of VTCs for sale...I am in Oregon and you could get them in a matter of days.
http://forums.maxima.org/showthread.php?t=427052
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Matt93SE
1st-3rd Generations Classifieds (1981-1994)
15
04-08-2018 09:23 AM
MaximaDrvr
7th Generation Maxima (2009-2015)
16
08-19-2015 08:20 PM